Record AAMAS public negative decision source checks

This commit is contained in:
2026-11-19 06:59:00 +08:00
parent 2037387efb
commit 9d27805c84
2 changed files with 177 additions and 0 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,169 @@
{
"database_snapshot_at": "2026-11-18T22:55:10.310168+00:00",
"scope": "AAMAS 2020–2026 main-track submission sources, plus bounded paper-level leads",
"official_sources": [
{
"year": 2020,
"submission_source": "https://www.ifaamas.org/AAMAS/aamas2020/submission-instructions.html",
"finding": "Official instructions describe the submission system and desk rejection; a paper-level negative list was not located in those instructions."
},
{
"year": 2021,
"submission_source": "https://www.ifaamas.org/AAMAS/aamas2021/call_for_papers.html",
"finding": "EasyChair main-track submission; a paper-level negative list was not located in the call."
},
{
"year": 2022,
"submission_source": "https://www.ifaamas.org/AAMAS/aamas2022/Submission_Instruction.html",
"finding": "EasyChair main-track submission; a paper-level negative list was not located in the instructions."
},
{
"year": 2023,
"submission_source": "https://www.ifaamas.org/AAMAS/aamas2023/submission_instructions.html",
"finding": "The main-track policy explicitly says submissions are confidential."
},
{
"year": 2024,
"submission_source": "https://www.aamas2024-conference.auckland.ac.nz/calls/submission-instruction/",
"proceedings_chairs_report": "https://www.ifaamas.org/Proceedings/aamas2024/pdfs/welcome.pdf",
"finding": "Proceedings and the chairs’ report are locatable; submission-policy detail could not be independently fetched in this pass."
},
{
"year": 2025,
"submission_source": "https://aamas2025.org/index.php/conference/calls/submission-instructions-main-technical-track/",
"finding": "The main-track policy explicitly says submissions are confidential."
},
{
"year": 2026,
"submission_source": "https://cyprusconferences.org/aamas2026/submission-instructions/",
"finding": "The main-track policy says submissions are confidential and explicitly provides for publication of accepted manuscripts and reviews."
}
],
"openreview_2026_main": {
"venue_group_id": "ifaamas.org/AAMAS/2026/Conference",
"configuration": {
"url": "https://api2.openreview.net/groups?id=ifaamas.org%2FAAMAS%2F2026%2FConference",
"http_status": 200,
"bytes": 11169,
"sha256": "4cee576b67b1a17a2d87f584ab5bb39e1c748d5b057c0e3086ee881ae495ecf7"
},
"flags": {
"public_submissions": false,
"public_desk_rejected_submissions": false,
"public_withdrawn_submissions": false
},
"probes": [
{
"status_probe": "rejected",
"venue_id": "ifaamas.org/AAMAS/2026/Conference/Rejected_Submission",
"url": "https://api2.openreview.net/notes?content.venueid=ifaamas.org%2FAAMAS%2F2026%2FConference%2FRejected_Submission&limit=1",
"http_status": 403,
"bytes": 357,
"sha256": "055b8b5cdd1af7b0b21beb9c6819da4b2fbf95f5fc2a2023f0b9f107c38c560a",
"response_type": "ChallengeRequiredError"
},
{
"status_probe": "desk_rejected",
"venue_id": "ifaamas.org/AAMAS/2026/Conference/Desk_Rejected_Submission",
"url": "https://api2.openreview.net/notes?content.venueid=ifaamas.org%2FAAMAS%2F2026%2FConference%2FDesk_Rejected_Submission&limit=1",
"http_status": 403,
"bytes": 362,
"sha256": "274a86f46ff7e03468579f1ddba4b381d892f4f6f156aa9d37c8575b0ccd8b63",
"response_type": "ChallengeRequiredError"
},
{
"status_probe": "withdrawn",
"venue_id": "ifaamas.org/AAMAS/2026/Conference/Withdrawn_Submission",
"url": "https://api2.openreview.net/notes?content.venueid=ifaamas.org%2FAAMAS%2F2026%2FConference%2FWithdrawn_Submission&limit=1",
"http_status": 403,
"bytes": 358,
"sha256": "05e1d201b7fcd9a6191e25ab7b22741c5c3d4d0dd397b4afca74f9320b851b2c",
"response_type": "ChallengeRequiredError"
},
{
"status_probe": "accepted_control",
"venue_id": "ifaamas.org/AAMAS/2026/Conference",
"url": "https://api2.openreview.net/notes?content.venueid=ifaamas.org%2FAAMAS%2F2026%2FConference&limit=1",
"http_status": 403,
"bytes": 333,
"sha256": "c684c705e77a1daa75595d6045b76e492c304a8ecc163d71f5aafcc7848ba7f4",
"response_type": "ChallengeRequiredError"
}
],
"public_negative_count": null,
"interpretation": "All four note requests, including the accepted control, hit a verification challenge. The configuration describes policy; the probes do not establish the number of public notes or the availability of an individual forum."
},
"official_2026_totals": {
"source": "https://www.ifaamas.org/Proceedings/aamas2026/pdfs/welcome.pdf",
"scope": "main",
"abstract_submissions": 1842,
"reviewed_submissions": 1359,
"accepted_full": 338,
"accepted_extended_abstract": 193,
"can_identify_individual_decisions": false
},
"database_exact_title_review": {
"trustgen_paper_ids": [],
"can_generative_agents_coordinate_paper_ids": [],
"evaluating_social_credibility_paper_ids": [],
"spatio_paper_ids": [
2657922
],
"spatio_submission_count": 0,
"aamas_2020_to_2026_negative_observations": [
{
"year": 2026,
"status": "withdrawn",
"count": 1
}
]
},
"author_leads": [
{
"title_as_reported": "TrustGen",
"reporter": "Shaun On",
"source": "https://www.linkedin.com/in/shaun-on",
"source_access": "Two posts visible in indexed public profile; direct profile response 999.",
"reported_outcomes": [
{
"venue": "AAMAS",
"year": 2026,
"status": "rejected"
}
],
"original_submission_id": null,
"original_track": null,
"original_decision_date": null,
"related_distinct_work": {
"title": "SpatiO: Adaptive Test-Time Orchestration of Vision-Language Agents for Spatial Reasoning",
"paper_id": 2657922,
"arxiv": "2604.21190",
"publication_source": "https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-032-37718-0_8",
"acceptance_venue": "ECCV",
"acceptance_year": 2026,
"same_work_link_supported": false,
"publication_import_route": "Existing ECCV 2026 publisher chapter ledger and identity review"
},
"disposition": "Held as an author-reported decision until a stable standalone source and work identity can be established. No link to the similarly titled foundation-model benchmarking project."
},
{
"title_as_reported": "Can Generative Agents Coordinate?",
"source": "https://gitlab.liris.cnrs.fr/mmorge/gaamas",
"source_access": "Anonymous README response 200; README explicitly describes the project as private work in progress.",
"reported_outcomes": [
{
"venue": "AAMAS",
"year": 2026,
"status": "rejected"
},
{
"venue": "ICTAI",
"year": 2025,
"status": "rejected"
}
],
"disposition": "Held pending an unambiguous public disclosure or archival manuscript. No manuscript or source contents archived. A related SE@AAMAS workshop paper has a different title and no verified same-work link."
}
],
"new_database_decisions": 0
}
@@ -100,3 +100,11 @@ CVPR 2023–2026 的作者指南明确说明评审及作者回复不公开。ICC
《Topological Autoencoders》的 arXiv、ICLR 2020 拒稿及 ICML 2020 录用已核实属于同一作品。《MAGNet》的早期稿和后期 ICLR 录用也已核对,两个版本独立保留原文。两组服务器内只读验收覆盖 9 条来源、4 次投稿、7 条决定和 32 条标签证据。生产库实体合并仍待明确授权。 [作者项目](https://github.com/BorgwardtLab/topological-autoencoders) · [作者公开投稿记录](https://bastian.rieck.me/blog/2025/rejections/) · [ICLR 正式出版](https://iclr.cc/virtual/2025/poster/30958)
《Bayesian Computation Meets Topology》换题后于 2024 年 11 月发表于 TMLR。对照早期 ICLR 论文与正式稿,确认作者、方法和关键验证实验对应。原论文 ID 已补记 TMLR 录用、NeurIPS 2023 和 ICML 2024 的两条作者公开拒稿。正常查询确认四个投稿结果都可找回,包括已有的 ICLR 2024 撤回。作者另提到 ICLR 2024 拒稿,该说法与现有论坛的撤回记录关系不明,暂缓录入。 [TMLR 目录](https://www.jmlr.org/tmlr/papers/) · [早期 ICLR 稿](https://openreview.net/pdf?id=PrkyCAspfx) · [逐条验收](version-links-and-bayesian-history-2026-11-19.json)
## AAMAS 2020–2026 主轨决定来源
逐年核对了投稿说明或征稿入口。2021、2022 年使用 EasyChair。2023、2025、2026 年的投稿政策明确说明投稿保密。2026 年明确公开录用稿和评审材料。2024 年可核对正式论文集和主席报告,投稿政策原页仍待复核。 [2020 投稿](https://www.ifaamas.org/AAMAS/aamas2020/submission-instructions.html) · [2021 征稿](https://www.ifaamas.org/AAMAS/aamas2021/call_for_papers.html) · [2022 投稿](https://www.ifaamas.org/AAMAS/aamas2022/Submission_Instruction.html) · [2023 投稿](https://www.ifaamas.org/AAMAS/aamas2023/submission_instructions.html) · [2024 主席报告](https://www.ifaamas.org/Proceedings/aamas2024/pdfs/welcome.pdf) · [2025 投稿](https://aamas2025.org/index.php/conference/calls/submission-instructions-main-technical-track/) · [2026 投稿](https://cyprusconferences.org/aamas2026/submission-instructions/)
2026 年 OpenReview 主轨配置可匿名读取,普通投稿、初筛拒稿和撤稿均未设置为公开。按配置查询拒稿、初筛拒稿和撤稿各一条,另查一条录用作对照,四次均返回 403 并要求验证。逐篇公开决定的总数仍未知。官方主席报告统计主轨收到 1,842 份摘要、评审 1,359 份投稿,录用 338 篇长文和 193 篇扩展摘要。这些汇总数仅记录各自的统计口径。库内已有一条官方论文集标注的 2026 年撤稿。 [OpenReview 主轨](https://openreview.net/group?id=ifaamas.org%2FAAMAS%2F2026%2FConference) · [主席报告](https://www.ifaamas.org/Proceedings/aamas2026/pdfs/welcome.pdf) · [论文集目录](https://www.ifaamas.org/Proceedings/aamas2026/forms/contents.htm)
作者公开叙述称 TrustGen 被 AAMAS 2026 拒稿,随后把经验用于另一篇作品 SpatiO。ECCV 出版记录与 arXiv 标识均指向 SpatiO,库内已有其预印本记录。TrustGen 暂缺稳定的原稿标识,按待核线索保留。另一条线索涉及 AAMAS 2026 和 ICTAI 2025 的两次拒稿,来源自称私有在研项目,暂待独立公开材料确认。 [作者公开叙述](https://www.linkedin.com/in/shaun-on) · [SpatiO 预印本](https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.21190) · [ECCV 正式出版](https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-032-37718-0_8) · [逐年状态与核查记录](aamas-negative-decision-sources-2020-2026.json)