Census official MLSys and COLM editions with nonarchival boundaries
Metadata integrity checks / metadata (push) Successful in 1m8s

This commit is contained in:
2026-11-08 14:55:37 +08:00
parent 040712b9c1
commit 91505844be
4 changed files with 212 additions and 5 deletions
+8 -1
View File
@@ -78,6 +78,13 @@ PGSERVICEFILE=/etc/paper-atlas/pg_service.conf paper-atlas coverage \
首项独立年份普查为 [RecSys 官方历届目录](https://recsys.acm.org/),证据见 [recsys-editions-2026-11-08.json](recsys-editions-2026-11-08.json):保留页面 SHA256、实际链接、检查时间和截至 2026 年的 2007–2026 共 20 届,2027 作为未来届次明确排除。与前述固定生产快照比较,缺 2026 年;这不是对当前主库的新查询,也不证明其他 19 年的论文和 track 已完整。其他会议仍需各自独立目录普查,不能仅凭数据库观察年份推导应举办全集。
新增两项独立目录普查,目前共 3/43 个目标:
- [MLSys 官方历届目录](https://mlsys.org/) 列出 2018–2026,[证据文件](mlsys-editions-2026-11-08.json) 保留实际链接及三个官方页面的哈希。[2018 SysML 首届说明](https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2018/) 明确为非存档 oral/poster,允许已有发表研究和后续原样再投;[正式论文集目录](https://proceedings.mlsys.org/) 从 2019 年开始。固定快照缺 2018,不能忽略首届,也不能把展示或 PDF 链接改作正式出版。2027 是未来届次,排除在本次截止范围外。
- [COLM 官方历届目录](https://colm.cc/) 与首届/第三届说明确认 2024–2026,[证据文件](colm-editions-2026-11-08.json) 保留目录及旧年页面哈希。固定快照的年份差集为空,逐篇、track 和实际论文数仍待核对。[2024 官方 CFP](https://colmweb.org/2024/cfp.html) 明确拒稿元数据不公开,本页没有单独确认撤稿和 desk rejection 的范围。
以上均为会议年份目录核查,未执行新的主库覆盖查询,也不替代逐年逐轨道拒稿政策核查。其余 40 个目标的独立年份目录普查仍待完成。
## 政策证据的边界
- [COLM 2026 固定版 CFP](https://raw.githubusercontent.com/COLM-org/colm-org.github.io/f1718e86fd16ed9b10b4e010c9098c1b6223c2a8/cfp.md) 明确不发布拒稿、撤稿及其元数据,哈希与提交号保存在 JSON;不再依赖含 2024 旧链接的 2026 AuthorGuide。2025 有独立政策证据。
@@ -87,7 +94,7 @@ PGSERVICEFILE=/etc/paper-atlas/pg_service.conf paper-atlas coverage \
## 新增政策核查与建模边界
本次仅补充政策证据,前面的已观察记录表仍对应固定生产快照,不滚动改写旧计数。43 个目标中,目前 25 个有至少一条限定年份的政策核查,共 31 条;“有核查”包含仍然 unknown 的结果,不代表这些会议的全部历史年份已查清。额外的 TMLR 期刊政策单列在 JSON 的 `additional_nonconference_policy_checks`,不增加会议目标数。
本次仅补充政策证据,前面的已观察记录表仍对应固定生产快照,不滚动改写旧计数。43 个目标中,目前 25 个有至少一条限定年份的政策核查,共 33 条;“有核查”包含仍然 unknown 的结果,不代表这些会议的全部历史年份已查清。额外的 TMLR 期刊政策单列在 JSON 的 `additional_nonconference_policy_checks`,不增加会议目标数。
- [ICAPS 2024 主会 CFP / FAQ](https://icaps24.icaps-conference.org/calls/main_track/) 仅明确录用论文的评审和最终 rebuttal 公开,不能据此推断所有拒稿元数据私密。该年把此前主题轨道统一为主轨道内的可选 primary keywords;technical/position、long/short 仍是论文属性,不能互相混用。
- [ICCV 2025 作者指南](https://iccv.thecvf.com/Conferences/2025/AuthorGuidelines) 明确评审和作者回复不公开;拒稿元数据的会后发布范围仍未独立确认,不将审稿期保密外推为永久不公开。
@@ -0,0 +1,36 @@
{
"source_url": "https://colm.cc/",
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T06:51:08.576901+00:00",
"source_html_sha256": "2fcea9d2a73cf3d88c09a731fbc4f16314fbb04e81b3506d3c355d14e7a8ae0d",
"cutoff_year": 2026,
"expected_years": [
2024,
2025,
2026
],
"excluded_future_years": [],
"year_links": {
"2026": [
"https://colm.cc/Conferences/2026/index.html"
],
"2025": [
"https://colmweb.org/2025/"
],
"2024": [
"https://colmweb.org/2024/"
]
},
"edition_pages": [
{
"source_url": "https://colmweb.org/2024/",
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T06:51:09.525917+00:00",
"source_html_sha256": "d757f26ff2876cac240bc07e0b1dd78638307b9d4fcea3d3c2f848f799e85cf9"
},
{
"source_url": "https://colmweb.org/2025/",
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T06:51:11.606331+00:00",
"source_html_sha256": "cd82ab43a570aad227dffdb9ea2302b2ab28f73d88e53d6955d49710cd514f62"
}
],
"scope": "Official first-through-third conference enumeration only; no claim of per-track/paper completeness or public rejection coverage."
}
+64 -4
View File
@@ -438,7 +438,7 @@
"source_record_counts": {
"colm": 1573
},
"historical_coverage": "pending_independent_census",
"historical_coverage": "conference_year_census_checked_tracks_and_records_pending",
"policy_checks": [
{
"year": 2026,
@@ -457,13 +457,38 @@
"primary_url": "https://github.com/COLM-org/Website/blob/master/cfp.md",
"checked_on": "2026-11-08",
"note": "官方 2025 CFP 明确不发布拒稿、撤稿及其讨论和元数据。该旧仓库不能单独证明 2026 政策。"
},
{
"year": 2024,
"track": "main",
"status": "not_published",
"primary_url": "https://colmweb.org/2024/cfp.html",
"checked_on": "2026-11-08",
"source_sha256": "b051ea25fc9aab33ae2ed553a5c22ca9edc4628ebaa74a657a66c54a3dfc4c25",
"note": "官方首届 CFP 明确拒稿及其讨论/元数据不公开;录用论文及评审在决定后公开。本证据未单独确认撤稿或 desk rejection 范围,不外推其他年份。"
}
],
"remaining": [
"官方历届目录确认2024–2026,固定快照年份差集为空;仍需逐篇/逐track核对,年份齐全不等于记录全集。2024明确拒稿不公开,未单独确认撤稿和desk范围。",
"按真实举办届次及独立官方目录核对历史年度和 track,不能用已观察年份代替预期全集。",
"逐年核对公开拒稿/desk-rejected/withdrawn 政策与可获取记录,其他年份仍未核实。",
"最终全库实体、投稿、决定、摘要和标签审计尚未完成。"
]
],
"edition_census": {
"source_url": "https://colm.cc/",
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T06:51:08.576901+00:00",
"source_html_sha256": "2fcea9d2a73cf3d88c09a731fbc4f16314fbb04e81b3506d3c355d14e7a8ae0d",
"evidence_file": "colm-editions-2026-11-08.json",
"cutoff_year": 2026,
"expected_years": [
2024,
2025,
2026
],
"excluded_future_years": [],
"missing_years_in_fixed_snapshot": [],
"scope": "Conference-year enumeration only; per-track/paper completeness, current database coverage and negative decisions remain independently unverified."
}
},
{
"acronym": "COLT",
@@ -4449,7 +4474,7 @@
"dblp": 313,
"mlsys": 448
},
"historical_coverage": "pending_independent_census",
"historical_coverage": "conference_year_census_checked_tracks_and_records_pending",
"policy_checks": [
{
"year": 2026,
@@ -4458,14 +4483,49 @@
"primary_url": "https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2026/CallForResearchPapers",
"checked_on": "2026-11-08",
"note": "该年研究及工业 track 使用 HotCRP。已核对 CFP 未建立会后拒稿公开政策;不能由其他年份 OpenReview 用法推断。"
},
{
"year": 2018,
"track": "oral_and_poster",
"status": "unknown",
"primary_url": "https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2018/",
"checked_on": "2026-11-08",
"source_sha256": "474b710e34c938d287f923c65b4bdc28ac3d61d6a97d14fde66db818e707673e",
"note": "官方首届 SysML 接收非存档 oral/poster,允许近期已发表研究及后续原样再投;CMT投稿不证明拒稿公开,未确认会后负面元数据来源。"
}
],
"remaining": [
"官方会议目录包含2018 SysML非存档首届,正式论文集始于2019;固定快照缺2018。2019–2026无年份差集不证明论文/轨道完整;2018允许已有发表研究,必须保留展示与正式出版区别。",
"2019–2026 的 448 次投稿已关联官方论文集;与 313 条 DBLP 来源重叠,不相加。2026 研究/工业 track 需独立核查,未由 CFP 自动重分类现有记录。",
"按真实举办届次及独立官方目录核对历史年度和 track,不能用已观察年份代替预期全集。",
"逐年核对公开拒稿/desk-rejected/withdrawn 政策与可获取记录,其他年份仍未核实。",
"最终全库实体、投稿、决定、摘要和标签审计尚未完成。"
]
],
"edition_census": {
"source_url": "https://mlsys.org/",
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T06:51:13.127546+00:00",
"source_html_sha256": "2309b47c1294e42a3b5eee4ffe52a192aabc25fcd642710750f4ade6928cdf7d",
"evidence_file": "mlsys-editions-2026-11-08.json",
"cutoff_year": 2026,
"expected_years": [
2018,
2019,
2020,
2021,
2022,
2023,
2024,
2025,
2026
],
"excluded_future_years": [
2027
],
"missing_years_in_fixed_snapshot": [
2018
],
"scope": "Conference-year enumeration only; per-track/paper completeness, current database coverage and negative decisions remain independently unverified."
}
},
{
"acronym": "MM",
@@ -0,0 +1,104 @@
{
"source_url": "https://mlsys.org/",
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T06:51:13.127546+00:00",
"source_html_sha256": "2309b47c1294e42a3b5eee4ffe52a192aabc25fcd642710750f4ade6928cdf7d",
"cutoff_year": 2026,
"expected_years": [
2018,
2019,
2020,
2021,
2022,
2023,
2024,
2025,
2026
],
"excluded_future_years": [
2027
],
"year_links": {
"2018": [
"https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2018"
],
"2019": [
"https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2019/"
],
"2020": [
"https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2020"
],
"2021": [
"https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2021"
],
"2022": [
"https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2022"
],
"2023": [
"https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2023"
],
"2024": [
"https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2024"
],
"2025": [
"https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2025"
],
"2026": [
"https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2026"
],
"2027": [
"https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2027/CallForResearchPapers",
"https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2027/Dates"
]
},
"proceedings_archive": {
"source_url": "https://proceedings.mlsys.org/",
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T06:51:09.375277+00:00",
"source_html_sha256": "3102f1921a5c120dd02749f3c7e31ec3d58c32e03da21c244469903f04f833ba",
"expected_proceedings_years": [
2019,
2020,
2021,
2022,
2023,
2024,
2025,
2026
],
"year_links": {
"2019": [
"https://proceedings.mlsys.org/paper_files/paper/2019"
],
"2020": [
"https://proceedings.mlsys.org/paper_files/paper/2020"
],
"2021": [
"https://proceedings.mlsys.org/paper_files/paper/2021"
],
"2022": [
"https://proceedings.mlsys.org/paper_files/paper/2022"
],
"2023": [
"https://proceedings.mlsys.org/paper_files/paper/2023"
],
"2024": [
"https://proceedings.mlsys.org/paper_files/paper/2024"
],
"2025": [
"https://proceedings.mlsys.org/paper_files/paper/2025"
],
"2026": [
"https://proceedings.mlsys.org/paper_files/paper/2026"
]
}
},
"predecessor_edition": {
"source_url": "https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2018/",
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T06:51:18.356899+00:00",
"source_html_sha256": "474b710e34c938d287f923c65b4bdc28ac3d61d6a97d14fde66db818e707673e",
"year": 2018,
"name": "SysML",
"publication_mode": "non_archival",
"note": "官方首届录用 oral/poster 非存档;允许近期已发表研究,后续可原样再投。不由 PDF 链接制造正式出版或重复录用;拒稿公开范围未核实。"
},
"scope": "Conference-year enumeration only; archival proceedings begin in 2019. Per-track/paper coverage and public negative availability require independent verification."
}