{ "version": 1, "as_of": "2026-11-18", "scope": "930 cached ResearchArcade non-ICLR negative claims, NeurIPS 2021–2025 and EMNLP 2023; not a conference-completeness audit", "database_snapshot": { "database": "foundry_data", "schema": "research", "at": "2026-11-18 03:48:34.65659+00", "snapshot": "1048885:1048885:" }, "database_written": false, "approved_for_import": 0, "claims": 930, "known_same_scope_attempt_claims": 925, "all_925_have_rejected_status": true, "without_same_scope_attempt_claims": 5, "by_venue_year": [ { "venue": "EMNLP", "year": 2023, "claims": 10 }, { "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2021, "claims": 136 }, { "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2022, "claims": 153 }, { "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2023, "claims": 176 }, { "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2024, "claims": 201 }, { "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2025, "claims": 254 } ], "evidence": { "diff_report_sha256": "d49361a8622f3b3f59e824690ceb8bf1c878be35c3e3758366d3b46a407673f5", "candidate_packets_sha256": "3b21df27e0f30e56b81086d16d3943c4563bbe382200e866b15de14510e07472", "dataset_revision": "c61bb99b0452429c32f85b1e392f3afdb65731c4", "dataset_parquet_sha256": "bb6e165ee152a95d91a7ffa16abc9d4a6effbdfcf59183b3bb819d09171689d1", "candidate_jsonl_sha256": "848e646596e8c747e0c636c2381a139978aff8f2c19f01ad49c98e7f4270c5e6", "collector_repository": "https://github.com/ulab-uiuc/research-arcade", "collector_revision": "ecf9c7c2490840b029bd2add4f02d04aca1d014e", "collector_openreview_crawler_sha256": "4539d951ca05b20785169638eab3884148aa6c354a34c5ecc04e15c84a5910fe", "collector_revision_proven_to_generate_dataset": false }, "collector_semantics": { "legacy_2020_2022": "Reads Blind_Submission note.id; first reply with content.decision, no invitation/signature verification. Not a verified final-decision note.", "legacy_2019": "Reads first recommendation, which must not be promoted to a final decision. Outside active 2020+ backfill.", "modern_branch": "Reads Submission note.id and last venueid component; Conference replaced by venue literal. Withdrawn_Submission skipped.", "identity": "The exported field paper_openreview_id is note.id; forum equality or equivalence to another mirror ID is not independently proved.", "coverage": "Six-field table has no authors or decision signatures; no completeness inference for public withdrawn/rejected records." }, "held_claims": [ { "source_row": 33219, "note_id_claim": "FSf9h6t152", "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2025, "raw_decision": "Rejected_Submission", "title": "Hierarchical Restructuring of Graph Neural Networks for Robust Learning under Edge Perturbations", "same_scope_identifier_match": false, "exact_title_candidates": [], "approved_for_import": false, "disposition": "hold_no_exact_title_candidate_not_proof_of_novelty" }, { "source_row": 44669, "note_id_claim": "Pk972F7J8Um", "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2021, "raw_decision": "Reject", "title": "Differential Privacy of Dirichlet Posterior Sampling", "same_scope_identifier_match": false, "exact_title_candidates": [ { "paper_id": 3527429, "existing_identifiers": [ { "scheme": "openreview", "value": "fgBxcKcz9ea", "paper_id": 3527429 }, { "scheme": "papercopilot_openreview", "value": "nips/2021/fgBxcKcz9ea", "paper_id": 3527429 } ], "source_abstract_exact_equal": true, "existing_attempts": [ { "id": 444666, "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2021, "source_submission_id": "nips/2021/fgBxcKcz9ea", "statuses": [ "rejected" ] } ], "attempts_truncated": false, "identity_approved": false, "id_alias_approved": false } ], "approved_for_import": false, "disposition": "hold_distinct_note_ids_even_with_equal_title_and_abstract" }, { "source_row": 44696, "note_id_claim": "ki4eJ1fSJNq", "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2021, "raw_decision": "Reject", "title": "Fitting large mixture models using stochastic component selection", "same_scope_identifier_match": false, "exact_title_candidates": [ { "paper_id": 1545058, "existing_identifiers": [ { "scheme": "arxiv", "value": "2110.04776", "paper_id": 1545058 }, { "scheme": "openreview", "value": "ZS394D3djsg", "paper_id": 1545058 }, { "scheme": "papercopilot_openreview", "value": "nips/2021/ZS394D3djsg", "paper_id": 1545058 } ], "source_abstract_exact_equal": true, "existing_attempts": [ { "id": 444652, "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2021, "source_submission_id": "nips/2021/ZS394D3djsg", "statuses": [ "rejected" ] } ], "attempts_truncated": false, "identity_approved": false, "id_alias_approved": false } ], "approved_for_import": false, "disposition": "hold_distinct_note_ids_even_with_equal_title_and_abstract" }, { "source_row": 45757, "note_id_claim": "bDP7I2fYwLj", "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2021, "raw_decision": "Reject", "title": "WeaveNet for Approximating Assignment Problems", "same_scope_identifier_match": false, "exact_title_candidates": [ { "paper_id": 3527390, "existing_identifiers": [ { "scheme": "openreview", "value": "2rAiDBJgR_", "paper_id": 3527390 }, { "scheme": "papercopilot_openreview", "value": "nips/2021/2rAiDBJgR_", "paper_id": 3527390 } ], "source_abstract_exact_equal": true, "existing_attempts": [ { "id": 444580, "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2021, "source_submission_id": "nips/2021/2rAiDBJgR_", "statuses": [ "rejected" ] } ], "attempts_truncated": false, "identity_approved": false, "id_alias_approved": false } ], "approved_for_import": false, "disposition": "hold_distinct_note_ids_even_with_equal_title_and_abstract" }, { "source_row": 49327, "note_id_claim": "yB8cQIICqe", "venue": "EMNLP", "year": 2023, "raw_decision": "Desk_Rejected_Submission", "title": "EZ-STANCE: A Large Dataset for Zero-Shot Stance Detection", "same_scope_identifier_match": false, "exact_title_candidates": [], "approved_for_import": false, "disposition": "hold_possible_later_publication_with_changed_title_and_dataset_size_no_identity_or_author_transfer", "later_publication_retrieval_lead": { "url": "https://aclanthology.org/2024.acl-long.838/", "http_status": 200, "bytes": 40557, "response_sha256": "b50dd55c48e31e4c10e97927ce01679369735834aa2c0f8d9f41f8e8e02fc776", "checked_at": "2026-11-18T04:07:03.699767+00:00", "anthology_id": "2024.acl-long.838", "doi": "10.18653/v1/2024.acl-long.838", "title": "EZ-STANCE: A Large Dataset for English Zero-Shot Stance Detection", "venue": "ACL", "year": 2024, "publication_verified": true, "link_to_anonymous_rejection_verified": false, "authors_transferred_to_anonymous_claim": false, "dataset_pairs_published_version": 47316, "dataset_pairs_rejection_mirror_version": 30606, "database_written": false } } ], "access_probes": [ { "local_evidence": "researcharcade-neurips2021-original-note-check-v1/report.json", "sha256": "746d752535b516abba43b0e8e6ad901bf39c07da532188dfa97ff911869084ae", "receipt_summary": {}, "results": [ { "requested_note_id": "Pk972F7J8Um", "status": 403, "url": "https://api.openreview.net/notes?id=Pk972F7J8Um&select=id%2Cforum%2Cinvitation%2Creaders%2Csignatures%2Ccontent.title%2Ccontent.abstract%2Ccontent.venue%2Ccontent.venueid", "sha256": "b0113384cebc9d724284062f776b45044d22450219112342721d8f9683571c08", "checked_at": "2026-11-18T04:01:58.643552+00:00" } ] }, { "local_evidence": "emnlp2023-primary-public-metadata-probe-v1/notes-probe.json", "sha256": "47799dc4520e113d6a2e7c9ea2f362577bb21e3ad583ee02149a36c21cf6ea9d", "receipt_summary": { "url": "https://api.openreview.net/notes?invitation=EMNLP%2F2023%2FConference%2F-%2FSubmission&limit=1&select=id%2Cnumber%2Cforum%2Cinvitation%2Creaders%2Csignatures%2Ccdate%2Ctcdate%2Cmdate%2Ctmdate%2Ccontent.title%2Ccontent.abstract%2Ccontent.authors%2Ccontent.venue%2Ccontent.venueid%2Ccontent.keywords", "http_status": 403, "response_sha256": "798e964735eb1eff1e4954d5c9e79aad2afd40c3f88dcb82f8ef5bbc55cc0a61", "response_bytes": 546, "at": "2026-11-18T03:38:50.112624+00:00" } }, { "local_evidence": "emnlp2023-primary-public-metadata-probe-v1/group-access.json", "sha256": "8fcb9ccd5615a737c17ef0eeedc9121e85a84ebd63667e83df0bda9ffb83d792", "receipt_summary": { "url": "https://api.openreview.net/groups?id=EMNLP%2F2023%2FConference", "http_status": 200, "response_sha256": "7c0cc75e2e8be1c18dffc96a9ceabea34f0f7810139c0a990a6bb117d66f6456", "response_bytes": 13143, "at": "2026-11-18T03:38:49.929085+00:00" } } ], "access_limit": "NeurIPS 2021 first original note request and EMNLP 2023 source-declared Submission query returned 403. Requests stopped. No alternate API version, endpoint, authentication, or challenge bypass. 403 does not prove zero public records." }