{ "scope": "Public named-work author disclosures and two official PMLR records; no venue-wide rejection counts.", "source_receipts": { "https://bastian.rieck.me/blog/2025/rejections/": { "url": "https://bastian.rieck.me/blog/2025/rejections/", "sha256": "d08f7c35198a36833dba283b34a106a8d248663cf6d1e60eaae212bb32b6e762", "bytes": 17035 }, "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v269/ballester25a.html": { "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v269/ballester25a.html", "sha256": "9b6a139071b2b685697124cbba8526ea217e6e7e7e49c63b2215d2b6655151e0", "bytes": 14643 }, "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v269/buffelli25a.html": { "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v269/buffelli25a.html", "sha256": "e2b5b35c529722be520d65574966100e4ad600a5c532ffcd3372a80c0382d1c2", "bytes": 16154 }, "https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T354565": { "url": "https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T354565", "access": "readable indexed copy from web search; direct raw capture timed out", "comments_utc": [ "2024-01-24T22:33:09Z", "2024-05-27T17:06:21Z" ] } }, "production_acceptance": { "status": "committed_and_readonly_verified", "plan_sha256": "852385e6b099f0a3858ed634c3bea5371f6ee4eee719066a00a61ae4a9588528", "snapshot_at": "2026-11-18 19:18:18.994786+00", "records": [ { "paper_id": 1426542, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816609, "external_id": "icml:2021:arxiv:2102.07835", "submission_id": 533292, "decision_id": 572843, "venue": "ICML", "year": 2021, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected" }, { "paper_id": 1426542, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816610, "external_id": "neurips:2021:arxiv:2102.07835", "submission_id": 533293, "decision_id": 572844, "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2021, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected" }, { "paper_id": 1481049, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816611, "external_id": "neurips:2021:arxiv:2106.01098", "submission_id": 533294, "decision_id": 572845, "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2021, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected" }, { "paper_id": 1608991, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816612, "external_id": "icml:2022:arxiv:2202.08070", "submission_id": 533295, "decision_id": 572846, "venue": "ICML", "year": 2022, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected" }, { "paper_id": 1723457, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816613, "external_id": "iclr:2022:arxiv:2210.00069", "submission_id": 533296, "decision_id": 572847, "venue": "ICLR", "year": 2022, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected" }, { "paper_id": 1785967, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816614, "external_id": "icml:2023:arxiv:2301.12906", "submission_id": 533297, "decision_id": 572848, "venue": "ICML", "year": 2023, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected" }, { "paper_id": 1960916, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816615, "external_id": "iclr:2024:arxiv:2311.16054", "submission_id": 533298, "decision_id": 572849, "venue": "ICLR", "year": 2024, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected" }, { "paper_id": 1960916, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816616, "external_id": "icml:2024:arxiv:2311.16054", "submission_id": 533299, "decision_id": 572850, "venue": "ICML", "year": 2024, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected" }, { "paper_id": 1796748, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816617, "external_id": "neurips:2023:arxiv:2302.09826", "submission_id": 533300, "decision_id": 572851, "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2023, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected" }, { "paper_id": 1796748, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816618, "external_id": "neurips:2024:arxiv:2302.09826", "submission_id": 533301, "decision_id": 572852, "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2024, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected" }, { "paper_id": 1796748, "source": "pmlr", "source_record_id": 3816622, "external_id": "v269/ballester25a", "submission_id": 533305, "decision_id": 572856, "venue": "LoG", "year": 2024, "track": "main", "status": "accepted" }, { "paper_id": 2220808, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816619, "external_id": "kdd:2024:arxiv:2409.08217", "submission_id": 533302, "decision_id": 572853, "venue": "KDD", "year": 2024, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected" }, { "paper_id": 2220808, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816620, "external_id": "neurips:2024:arxiv:2409.08217", "submission_id": 533303, "decision_id": 572854, "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2024, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected" }, { "paper_id": 2220808, "source": "pmlr", "source_record_id": 3816623, "external_id": "v269/buffelli25a", "submission_id": 533306, "decision_id": 572857, "venue": "LoG", "year": 2024, "track": "main", "status": "accepted" }, { "paper_id": 2042710, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816621, "external_id": "www:2024:arxiv:2404.03428", "submission_id": 533304, "decision_id": 572855, "venue": "WWW", "year": 2024, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected" } ], "new_papers": 0, "existing_history_preserved": true }, "independent_query": [ { "paper_id": 1426542, "publication_outcome": "accepted", "records": [ { "paper_id": 1426542, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816609, "external_id": "icml:2021:arxiv:2102.07835", "submission_id": 533292, "decision_id": 572843, "venue": "ICML", "year": 2021, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected", "source_refs": [ { "name": "author_public_rejection", "external_id": "icml:2021:arxiv:2102.07835", "source_decision_id": "" } ] }, { "paper_id": 1426542, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816610, "external_id": "neurips:2021:arxiv:2102.07835", "submission_id": 533293, "decision_id": 572844, "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2021, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected", "source_refs": [ { "name": "author_public_rejection", "external_id": "neurips:2021:arxiv:2102.07835", "source_decision_id": "" } ] } ], "known_acceptances": [ { "submission_id": 100735, "venue": "ICLR", "year": 2022, "track": "main", "event_key": "", "decision_id": 100735, "decision_date": null, "observed_at": "2026-11-06T05:07:32.701Z", "evidence_url": "https://iclr.cc/virtual/2022/papers.html" } ] }, { "paper_id": 1481049, "publication_outcome": "accepted", "records": [ { "paper_id": 1481049, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816611, "external_id": "neurips:2021:arxiv:2106.01098", "submission_id": 533294, "decision_id": 572845, "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2021, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected", "source_refs": [ { "name": "author_public_rejection", "external_id": "neurips:2021:arxiv:2106.01098", "source_decision_id": "" } ] } ], "known_acceptances": [ { "submission_id": 100478, "venue": "ICLR", "year": 2022, "track": "main", "event_key": "", "decision_id": 100478, "decision_date": null, "observed_at": "2026-11-06T05:07:31.352Z", "evidence_url": "https://iclr.cc/virtual/2022/papers.html" } ] }, { "paper_id": 1608991, "publication_outcome": "accepted", "records": [ { "paper_id": 1608991, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816612, "external_id": "icml:2022:arxiv:2202.08070", "submission_id": 533295, "decision_id": 572846, "venue": "ICML", "year": 2022, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected", "source_refs": [ { "name": "author_public_rejection", "external_id": "icml:2022:arxiv:2202.08070", "source_decision_id": "" } ] } ], "known_acceptances": [ { "submission_id": 488071, "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2022, "track": "main", "event_key": "", "decision_id": 493683, "decision_date": null, "observed_at": "2026-11-07T09:35:06.211Z", "evidence_url": "https://proceedings.neurips.cc/paper_files/paper/2022/hash/420492060687ca7448398c4c3fa10366-Abstract-Conference.html" } ] }, { "paper_id": 1723457, "publication_outcome": "accepted", "records": [ { "paper_id": 1723457, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816613, "external_id": "iclr:2022:arxiv:2210.00069", "submission_id": 533296, "decision_id": 572847, "venue": "ICLR", "year": 2022, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected", "source_refs": [ { "name": "author_public_rejection", "external_id": "iclr:2022:arxiv:2210.00069", "source_decision_id": "" } ] } ], "known_acceptances": [ { "submission_id": 17446, "venue": "ICML", "year": 2023, "track": "main", "event_key": "", "decision_id": 17446, "decision_date": null, "observed_at": "2026-11-06T05:03:08.184Z", "evidence_url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v202/von-rohrscheidt23a.html" } ] }, { "paper_id": 1785967, "publication_outcome": "accepted", "records": [ { "paper_id": 1785967, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816614, "external_id": "icml:2023:arxiv:2301.12906", "submission_id": 533297, "decision_id": 572848, "venue": "ICML", "year": 2023, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected", "source_refs": [ { "name": "author_public_rejection", "external_id": "icml:2023:arxiv:2301.12906", "source_decision_id": "" } ] } ], "known_acceptances": [ { "submission_id": 492870, "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2023, "track": "main", "event_key": "", "decision_id": 498482, "decision_date": null, "observed_at": "2026-11-07T09:39:38.256Z", "evidence_url": "https://proceedings.neurips.cc/paper_files/paper/2023/hash/c710d6b4507e70c6332bee871b8d1ca5-Abstract-Conference.html" } ] }, { "paper_id": 1796748, "publication_outcome": "accepted", "records": [ { "paper_id": 1796748, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816617, "external_id": "neurips:2023:arxiv:2302.09826", "submission_id": 533300, "decision_id": 572851, "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2023, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected", "source_refs": [ { "name": "author_public_rejection", "external_id": "neurips:2023:arxiv:2302.09826", "source_decision_id": "" } ] }, { "paper_id": 1796748, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816618, "external_id": "neurips:2024:arxiv:2302.09826", "submission_id": 533301, "decision_id": 572852, "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2024, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected", "source_refs": [ { "name": "author_public_rejection", "external_id": "neurips:2024:arxiv:2302.09826", "source_decision_id": "" } ] }, { "paper_id": 1796748, "source": "pmlr", "source_record_id": 3816622, "external_id": "v269/ballester25a", "submission_id": 533305, "decision_id": 572856, "venue": "LoG", "year": 2024, "track": "main", "status": "accepted", "source_refs": [ { "name": "pmlr", "external_id": "v269/ballester25a", "source_decision_id": "" } ] } ], "known_acceptances": [ { "submission_id": 533305, "venue": "LoG", "year": 2024, "track": "main", "event_key": "", "decision_id": 572856, "decision_date": null, "observed_at": "2026-11-18T19:18:00.775Z", "evidence_url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v269/ballester25a.html" } ] }, { "paper_id": 1960916, "publication_outcome": "accepted", "records": [ { "paper_id": 1960916, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816615, "external_id": "iclr:2024:arxiv:2311.16054", "submission_id": 533298, "decision_id": 572849, "venue": "ICLR", "year": 2024, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected", "source_refs": [ { "name": "author_public_rejection", "external_id": "iclr:2024:arxiv:2311.16054", "source_decision_id": "" } ] }, { "paper_id": 1960916, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816616, "external_id": "icml:2024:arxiv:2311.16054", "submission_id": 533299, "decision_id": 572850, "venue": "ICML", "year": 2024, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected", "source_refs": [ { "name": "author_public_rejection", "external_id": "icml:2024:arxiv:2311.16054", "source_decision_id": "" } ] } ], "known_acceptances": [ { "submission_id": 497581, "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2024, "track": "main", "event_key": "", "decision_id": 503193, "decision_date": null, "observed_at": "2026-11-07T09:43:31.807Z", "evidence_url": "https://proceedings.neurips.cc/paper_files/paper/2024/hash/dfc24bd3ec5d74960e104268bbb52849-Abstract-Conference.html" } ] }, { "paper_id": 2042710, "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance", "records": [ { "paper_id": 2042710, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816621, "external_id": "www:2024:arxiv:2404.03428", "submission_id": 533304, "decision_id": 572855, "venue": "WWW", "year": 2024, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected", "source_refs": [ { "name": "author_public_rejection", "external_id": "www:2024:arxiv:2404.03428", "source_decision_id": "" } ] } ], "known_acceptances": [] }, { "paper_id": 2220808, "publication_outcome": "accepted", "records": [ { "paper_id": 2220808, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816619, "external_id": "kdd:2024:arxiv:2409.08217", "submission_id": 533302, "decision_id": 572853, "venue": "KDD", "year": 2024, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected", "source_refs": [ { "name": "author_public_rejection", "external_id": "kdd:2024:arxiv:2409.08217", "source_decision_id": "" } ] }, { "paper_id": 2220808, "source": "author_public_rejection", "source_record_id": 3816620, "external_id": "neurips:2024:arxiv:2409.08217", "submission_id": 533303, "decision_id": 572854, "venue": "NeurIPS", "year": 2024, "track": "submission_unclassified", "status": "rejected", "source_refs": [ { "name": "author_public_rejection", "external_id": "neurips:2024:arxiv:2409.08217", "source_decision_id": "" } ] }, { "paper_id": 2220808, "source": "pmlr", "source_record_id": 3816623, "external_id": "v269/buffelli25a", "submission_id": 533306, "decision_id": 572857, "venue": "LoG", "year": 2024, "track": "main", "status": "accepted", "source_refs": [ { "name": "pmlr", "external_id": "v269/buffelli25a", "source_decision_id": "" } ] } ], "known_acceptances": [ { "submission_id": 533306, "venue": "LoG", "year": 2024, "track": "main", "event_key": "", "decision_id": 572857, "decision_date": null, "observed_at": "2026-11-18T19:18:00.775Z", "evidence_url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v269/buffelli25a.html" } ] } ], "already_present": [ { "paper_id": 1184477, "title": "Set Functions for Time Series", "claims": [ [ "ICLR", 2020 ] ], "publication": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v119/horn20a" } ], "held": [ { "title": "Topological Autoencoders", "active_rejection_claims": [ [ "ICLR", 2020 ] ], "paper_ids": [ 1135322, 2113891, 3537122 ], "identity_url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v119/moor20a.html", "reason": "separate existing publication and rejection entities" }, { "title": "Bayesian Computation Meets Topology", "active_rejection_claims": [ [ "NeurIPS", 2023 ], [ "ICLR", 2024 ], [ "ICML", 2024 ] ], "paper_ids": [], "identity_url": "https://openreview.net/forum?id=0h1DtRK6dA", "reason": "missing work match on exact title and linked forum" }, { "title": "MAGNet: Motif-Agnostic Generation of Molecules from Scaffolds", "active_rejection_claims": [ [ "NeurIPS", 2023 ], [ "ICLR", 2024 ], [ "ICML", 2024 ], [ "NeurIPS", 2024 ] ], "paper_ids": [ 1854320, 2177209 ], "identity_url": "https://openreview.net/forum?id=5FXKgOxmb2", "reason": "separate existing publication and rejection entities" } ], "pre_2020_recheck_leads": [ { "title": "Neural Persistence: A Complexity Measure for Deep Neural Networks Using Algebraic Topology", "url": "https://openreview.net/forum?id=ByxkijC5FQ", "rejected": [ [ "NeurIPS", 2018 ] ], "acceptance": "ICLR 2019" }, { "title": "A Wasserstein Subsequence Kernel for Time Series", "url": "https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8970694", "rejected": [ [ "KDD", 2019 ] ], "acceptance": "ICDM 2019" }, { "title": "Graph Filtration Learning", "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v119/hofer20b.html", "rejected": [ [ "NeurIPS", 2019 ] ], "acceptance": "ICML 2020" }, { "title": "Topological Autoencoders", "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v119/moor20a.html", "rejected": [ [ "NeurIPS", 2019 ] ], "acceptance": "ICML 2020" } ], "sha256": { "rieck-author-decision-preflight-v1.json": "6939ffe4bfa846494a3fefa002be2924596920da05cb7af1d3a2313d98d7304e", "rieck-author-decision-preflight-extra-v1.json": "79c6efa5191a8e87f035a6455b81fff1d73eeb3bb4d946afb9d45ab087b9835f", "rieck-author-decision-plan-v1.json": "852385e6b099f0a3858ed634c3bea5371f6ee4eee719066a00a61ae4a9588528", "rieck-author-decision-accepted-v1.json": "5c304039bd0d07cf873201a512218782f88e4d672a3a1f76f4597d12491820ab", "rieck-author-decision-query-v1.json": "315f4051c750f4a62daedd6349b5d6fd08eaa0cde9ed91adcc5c2598322f414a", "rieck-author-decision-evidence-v1/author.html": "d08f7c35198a36833dba283b34a106a8d248663cf6d1e60eaae212bb32b6e762", "rieck-author-decision-evidence-v1/ballester.html": "9b6a139071b2b685697124cbba8526ea217e6e7e7e49c63b2215d2b6655151e0", "rieck-author-decision-evidence-v1/buffelli.html": "e2b5b35c529722be520d65574966100e4ad600a5c532ffcd3372a80c0382d1c2", "rieck-author-decision-evidence-v1/claims.json": "570e75170131ac5b9e6f68acc8795db3ba04858f562aacd105f830fe2aed8d33", "rieck-author-decision-evidence-v1/log-volume.html": "1f0de5fae9d83243ea4d6ceee2ba76712c787838a9015e2bf639efaaff6c7018" } }