Compare commits

..

2 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
codex-bot a980b1a1df Record verified ISMIR increment to31 existing-work source links
Metadata integrity checks / metadata (push) Successful in 6m45s
2026-11-18 14:51:27 +08:00
codex-bot e38b2f1ca8 Record verified ISMIR source links and preserved rejection history
Metadata integrity checks / metadata (push) Successful in 7m36s
2026-11-18 13:25:06 +08:00
8 changed files with 646 additions and 379 deletions
-2
View File
@@ -202,5 +202,3 @@ IJCAI 联办届次的逐条后续核查见 [2018/2022 分区与目录差集](ijc
[早期NLP来源范围复核](historical-source-scope-2026-11-09.md)保留3份官方网页的响应哈希,排除4个COLING卷对ACL缺口的误匹配,并区分会议举办记录、目录可获取性与论文级覆盖;尚未导入或关闭这些年度缺口。 [早期NLP来源范围复核](historical-source-scope-2026-11-09.md)保留3份官方网页的响应哈希,排除4个COLING卷对ACL缺口的误匹配,并区分会议举办记录、目录可获取性与论文级覆盖;尚未导入或关闭这些年度缺口。
- [MM 2026 官方节目来源状态](../mm2026-source-status.md):完整官方日程 JSON、重复展示盘点、28 个来源 track、缺失作者/摘要和四条匿名决定路径的 403 证据;这些不是已导入或公开拒稿全集。 - [MM 2026 官方节目来源状态](../mm2026-source-status.md):完整官方日程 JSON、重复展示盘点、28 个来源 track、缺失作者/摘要和四条匿名决定路径的 403 证据;这些不是已导入或公开拒稿全集。
- [2026-11-18 公开负面来源核查](public-negative-source-audit-2026-11-18.md):ResearchArcade 930 条非 ICLR 声明的当前库比对、5 条未绑定声明及原始接口访问证据;不把镜像差集算作新增拒稿。
@@ -1493,7 +1493,7 @@
}, },
"TMLR_current20261108": { "TMLR_current20261108": {
"url": "https://www.jmlr.org/tmlr/faq.html", "url": "https://www.jmlr.org/tmlr/faq.html",
"finding": "Additionalnonconferencepolicyreference; TMLR is not in the current 43-conference registry:accepted/rejected/withdrawn/retractedallpublic; deskrejectedneverpublic. Authorshiddenonnotyetacceptedpapers; donotinferanonymousidentities. Continuousjournal; eventcertification/journal-to-conferencepresentationnotanotherindependentreviewacceptance." "finding": "Additionalnonconferencevenuealreadyinregistry:accepted/rejected/withdrawn/retractedallpublic; deskrejectedneverpublic. Authorshiddenonnotyetacceptedpapers; donotinferanonymousidentities. Continuousjournal; eventcertification/journal-to-conferencepresentationnotanotherindependentreviewacceptance."
} }
}, },
"public_negative_recovery_notes": { "public_negative_recovery_notes": {
@@ -1507,12 +1507,6 @@
"original_rejection_notes_obtained": false, "original_rejection_notes_obtained": false,
"prior_decisions_inserted": 0, "prior_decisions_inserted": 0,
"requires": "Per-paper primary original identifiers/decisions or an explicitly distinguished policy-supported relation; never manufacture an original note." "requires": "Per-paper primary original identifiers/decisions or an explicitly distinguished policy-supported relation; never manufacture an original note."
},
"researcharcade_20261118": {
"audit": "public-negative-source-audit-2026-11-18.json",
"summary": "930 non-ICLR 2020+ mirror claims:925 scoped ID matches all have rejected status;5 held,3 with equal title+source abstract but distinct unverified note IDs. No writes or new rejections approved.",
"access": "NeurIPS2021 and EMNLP2023 original note queries403; stopped, no bypass.",
"next": "Seek independent primary evidence for note.id/forum relationships and final decisions; no title-only merge or duplicate-rejection import. No full-public-set coverage claim."
} }
}, },
"restore_rules": [ "restore_rules": [
@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
# 2020 起补漏状态:2026-11-18
总体仍为 **13/17,第 14 步未完成**。主动补漏从 2020 年起,2000–2019 年已发现线索仍保留,43 个早期历史缺口仍为延期,没有据此算作补齐。更早状态页保留为历史快照。
## 当前生产结果
ISMIR 两批累计31项已关联到现有论文,新增论文实体为0。第二批新增来源记录、独立投稿、录用观察各21条及173条来源标签证据;两批累计267条标签证据。覆盖 `partial31/140`,109项仍待核验。详见[来源说明](../ismir2026-program.md)、[首批验收](ismir2026-import10-2026-11-18.json)和[第二批逐条验收](ismir2026-import21-2026-11-18.json)。
最新精确计数:论文实体 **3,568,022**,来源记录 **3,815,534**,投稿 **532,223**,决定来源观察 **571,775**。实体数量不是已经完成最终科学工作去重的数量;同一次投稿可能有多条决定来源观察。
paper `2757497` 保留 ICLR2026 一次拒稿投稿下的两条来源观察,并新增 ISMIR2026 录用投稿;实际 CLI 查询显示已知录用,旧拒稿历史仍可查询。不将两条来源观察计作两次拒稿,也不将来源采集时间当作决定时间。
## 固定范围存在性盘点
只读快照 `2026-11-18 06:46:44.099675+00`,范围仍为 43 会、278 个目标年度槽位:**274 个至少有一条投稿,4 个完全为空**,均为 2026 年的 **CIKM、ECCV、ICDM、IROS**。首批ISMIR使空槽从5降至4;第二批只增加同届来源覆盖,空槽数不变。
这只统计“该年度至少有数据”,不是逐篇、逐 track、摘要或公开拒稿覆盖完整。2020–2025 没有整年空槽,仍有来源完整性和公开负面历史缺口。
|证据(相对服务器 `/data/paper-index/`)|SHA256|
|---|---|
|`collected/active-scope-census-20261118-v22/summary.json`|`ee4ec2e6d6eaed55ce3475e735bfba9bd94e512893cd3c3024035b48b744f475`|
|`collected/active-scope-census-20261118-v22/snapshot.json`|`5aabc91217ad787946ba50d6a670296b1e3152a54f5ecaa0e3a9b3a952b63fa7`|
|`validation/active-scope-fixed278-v1.json`|`a835bef5b9c3a0f76069d840cecdb9a6bcf65d3a38796d70dbfdfd4b49242264`|
本机使用固定分母、会议别名和逐 edition 快照独立重算 274/278;没有使用 `max(id)` 代替计数。
## 尚待完成
- ISMIR 仍有109项;62项无精确标题候选不等于新作品,6项作者部分匹配仍待审查。31项摘要逐字一致候选已分两批审查并消费;其余候选不能仅凭标题、作者或摘要检索结果算作已批准。
- MM 已验收572项来源观察,注册清单1918项中仍有1346项待处理。已有134个暂建索引实体仍须后续身份审计;H2AL 来源及轨道纠正、版本化来源覆盖方案尚未用于生产,不能把不同版本轨道预期数相加当完整分母。
- ECCV 的初步节目、ICDM 的研究/应用来源和缺失摘要仍需作品及出版核查;CIKM 缺实际逐篇目录;IROS 官方访问403仍保留限制,不重试绕过。各来源的采集、批准和导入状态必须分开。
- 公开 rejected、desk-rejected、withdrawn 继续按会议、年份、track核查。ISMIR 的101组自愿公开评审来自录用节目,不是101条拒稿;UAI accepted-only 镜像与 EMNLP/NeurIPS 原始接口403均不能关闭拒稿缺口。近期镜像差集核查见 [PR #72](https://gitea.entroia.com/Zayden-Jung/paper-atlas/pulls/72)。
- 后续仍需完成跨会作品与历史、独立类型和标签关系(第15步);全部导入结束后的全库去重、标识冲突、近似标题作者、摘要/约束/查询及覆盖审计(第16步);长期运行与恢复文档最终整理(第17步)。
已消费输入不得重放。下次从[ISMIR 当前增量父状态和恢复说明](../ismir2026-program.md)及 `work-state.json` 的本批已接受回执继续;保留旧 SQLite 只读备份,不因查询超时重新执行导入。
@@ -0,0 +1,247 @@
{
"as_of": "2026-11-18",
"goal_progress": "13/17; stage14 incomplete",
"source": "ismir_program",
"scope": "First10 reviewed existing-work source links, partial10/140, not public-rejection completeness or final deduplication",
"database_acceptance": {
"status": "passed",
"at": "2026-11-18 05:15:27.565655+00:00",
"writer_commit": "12f95cff91813a2143bc8fab5bc3e89df1bd0fdb",
"before_counts": {
"papers": {
"rows": 3568022,
"max_id": 3568595
},
"source_records": {
"rows": 3815503,
"max_id": 3815504
},
"submissions": {
"rows": 532192,
"max_id": 532193
},
"decisions": {
"rows": 571744,
"max_id": 571744
}
},
"after_counts": {
"papers": {
"rows": 3568022,
"max_id": 3568595
},
"source_records": {
"rows": 3815513,
"max_id": 3815514
},
"submissions": {
"rows": 532202,
"max_id": 532203
},
"decisions": {
"rows": 571754,
"max_id": 571754
}
},
"new_papers": 0,
"new_sources": 1,
"new_editions": 1,
"new_source_records": 10,
"new_attempts": 10,
"new_decisions": 10,
"source_id": 123160,
"source_tag_evidence_links": 94,
"protected_papers": 6394,
"all_protected_old_profiles_sources_tags_identifiers_preserved": true,
"source_observations": 10,
"source_expected": 140,
"source_remaining": 130,
"coverage": "partial",
"foundry_readyz": [
200
],
"sqlite_frozen": true,
"imported": [
{
"external_id": "2026/3",
"paper_id": 2813483,
"record_id": 3815505,
"submission_id": 532194,
"decision_id": 571745,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/12",
"paper_id": 2785459,
"record_id": 3815506,
"submission_id": 532195,
"decision_id": 571746,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/35",
"paper_id": 2757859,
"record_id": 3815507,
"submission_id": 532196,
"decision_id": 571747,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/51",
"paper_id": 2752643,
"record_id": 3815508,
"submission_id": 532197,
"decision_id": 571748,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/74",
"paper_id": 2762340,
"record_id": 3815509,
"submission_id": 532198,
"decision_id": 571749,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/75",
"paper_id": 2757480,
"record_id": 3815510,
"submission_id": 532199,
"decision_id": 571750,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/78",
"paper_id": 2768260,
"record_id": 3815511,
"submission_id": 532200,
"decision_id": 571751,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/84",
"paper_id": 2740614,
"record_id": 3815512,
"submission_id": 532201,
"decision_id": 571752,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/87",
"paper_id": 2752271,
"record_id": 3815513,
"submission_id": 532202,
"decision_id": 571753,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/363",
"paper_id": 2757497,
"record_id": 3815514,
"submission_id": 532203,
"decision_id": 571754,
"edition_id": 104044
}
]
},
"history_protection": {
"submissions": {
"rows": 532192,
"sha256": "34e2fe27cccf89e6e80228318212a846369fdd315c4cfe67d7d535013eac8298"
},
"decisions": {
"rows": 571744,
"sha256": "efbda4e91950c5c7298f536bc5967f7fee57d8b20a7843e00dc69871b1553bd1"
},
"decision_sources": {
"rows": 571744,
"sha256": "1d8899b16b40e9f37ac84dc601efc3e7906af5c06bca49946100697f22c96174"
},
"submission_sources": {
"rows": 581976,
"sha256": "ab3ab200c4abbfef39bc5a2a757550191441c703ae505372d38d9afa9a4daf65"
},
"submission_identifiers": {
"rows": 383956,
"sha256": "0e8f514e186e08bd00a65f8e14fc7f63db6add76722271e0111e14f5d27b9dbe"
}
},
"evidence": {
"accepted_report": "/data/paper-index/collected/ismir2026-import10-v1/postgresql-postcheck-v1.json",
"accepted_report_sha256": "8a08015bbd725b400de53477837e850ca92a50479d7f86f2cfed56d50bb22577",
"baseline": "/data/paper-index/collected/ismir2026-baseline10-v1/baseline.json",
"baseline_sha256": "a0b5b8c2c21ee567cf80152b16f66643309bbe33ee9cd67d19da33d6b6337656",
"baseline_archive_sha256": "eb94f99cb53c9a30f63d34ea11b23c11759e45b571b7efce2dcbe8cb4fe52fb8",
"preparation_sha256": "0d9fad74640ab57fc8bea8aaf72ba07202a40b174d05253db7348b14455a0462",
"acceptance_archive": "/data/paper-index/validation/ismir2026-import10-acceptance-recovery-v1.tar.gz",
"acceptance_archive_sha256": "138e1fb986f5aa6a42794eed982fdc91ae994b8be82f8bf25360db2f7ba6c70c",
"fresh_packets_sha256": "88e423aede0ea83b9f736891c09b12d0cb24f2f8b70508e4863cd07760de5e0d",
"local_acceptance_check_sha256": "42d31337c76b96f93505011db7c797123b67ce2eec7defd0175ea0e9c1df2089",
"census_summary_sha256": "2157035b72d351e2fe91f2bc0c6ebb305f91d95f8772ab9a088076ce4b86e1c2"
},
"native_query_example": {
"paper_id": 2757497,
"publication_outcome": "accepted",
"prior_venue": "ICLR",
"prior_year": 2026,
"prior_submission_id": 131721,
"prior_negative_attempts": 1,
"prior_negative_observations": 2,
"prior_decision_ids": [
133086,
538172
],
"later_observed_venue": "ISMIR",
"later_observed_year": 2026,
"original_ismir_signed_decision_verified": false,
"ismir_decision_date": null,
"observation_time_is_not_decision_time": true
},
"presence_census": {
"snapshot_at": "2026-11-18 05:20:48.641315+00",
"scope": "Fixed278 venue-year presence only, not paper/track/abstract/public-negative completeness or final deduplication. Legacy43 gaps deferred, not filled.",
"target_venues": 43,
"expected_slots": 278,
"populated_slots": 274,
"missing_slots": 4,
"missing": [
{
"venue": "CIKM",
"year": 2026
},
{
"venue": "ECCV",
"year": 2026
},
{
"venue": "ICDM",
"year": 2026
},
{
"venue": "IROS",
"year": 2026
}
],
"delta_from_v20": {
"newly_present": [
{
"venue": "ISMIR",
"year": 2026
}
],
"previous_missing": 5,
"current_missing": 4
},
"snapshot_sha256": "c14bab883c5fcab33b450fcf240dec7225f2f17bc04c3e728b5583657b4ad23b",
"fixed_scope_sha256": "a835bef5b9c3a0f76069d840cecdb9a6bcf65d3a38796d70dbfdfd4b49242264",
"accepted_import_sha256": "8a08015bbd725b400de53477837e850ca92a50479d7f86f2cfed56d50bb22577",
"database_written": false
},
"consumed_queue": "/data/paper-index/collected/ismir2026-prepared10-v1: NEVER REPLAY",
"next": [
"Review130 remaining source observations, including31 total verbatim-abstract candidates of which10 consumed; do not count a title/author screen as identity approval.",
"Fresh incremental parent must be partial10/140; old preparation0/140 is consumed.",
"Continue all venue/year/track public negative availability and formal source coverage.",
"Finish cross-venue identities/types, then final whole-DB dedup/identifier/abstract/constraints/query audit after imports."
]
}
@@ -0,0 +1,330 @@
{
"as_of": "2026-11-18",
"goal_progress": "13/17; stage14 incomplete",
"source": "ismir_program",
"scope": "21 additional reviewed existing-work source links; cumulativepartial31/140, not public-rejection completeness or final deduplication",
"database_acceptance": {
"status": "passed",
"at": "2026-11-18 06:38:55.148539+00:00",
"writer_commit": "3754545003e1f96b88c6533cc3a69dc557f07305",
"before_counts": {
"papers": {
"rows": 3568022,
"max_id": 3568595
},
"source_records": {
"rows": 3815513,
"max_id": 3815514
},
"submissions": {
"rows": 532202,
"max_id": 532203
},
"decisions": {
"rows": 571754,
"max_id": 571754
}
},
"after_counts": {
"papers": {
"rows": 3568022,
"max_id": 3568595
},
"source_records": {
"rows": 3815534,
"max_id": 3815535
},
"submissions": {
"rows": 532223,
"max_id": 532224
},
"decisions": {
"rows": 571775,
"max_id": 571775
}
},
"new_papers": 0,
"new_sources": 0,
"new_editions": 0,
"new_source_records": 21,
"new_attempts": 21,
"new_decisions": 21,
"source_id": 123160,
"source_tag_evidence_links": 173,
"protected_papers": 6415,
"all_protected_old_profiles_sources_tags_identifiers_preserved": true,
"source_observations": 31,
"source_expected": 140,
"source_remaining": 109,
"coverage": "partial",
"foundry_readyz": [
200
],
"sqlite_frozen": true,
"imported": [
{
"external_id": "2026/148",
"paper_id": 2755057,
"record_id": 3815515,
"submission_id": 532204,
"decision_id": 571755,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/184",
"paper_id": 2752723,
"record_id": 3815516,
"submission_id": 532205,
"decision_id": 571756,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/196",
"paper_id": 2784571,
"record_id": 3815517,
"submission_id": 532206,
"decision_id": 571757,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/240",
"paper_id": 2738896,
"record_id": 3815518,
"submission_id": 532207,
"decision_id": 571758,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/251",
"paper_id": 2753889,
"record_id": 3815519,
"submission_id": 532208,
"decision_id": 571759,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/258",
"paper_id": 2662030,
"record_id": 3815520,
"submission_id": 532209,
"decision_id": 571760,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/270",
"paper_id": 2769109,
"record_id": 3815521,
"submission_id": 532210,
"decision_id": 571761,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/298",
"paper_id": 2752114,
"record_id": 3815522,
"submission_id": 532211,
"decision_id": 571762,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/317",
"paper_id": 2765378,
"record_id": 3815523,
"submission_id": 532212,
"decision_id": 571763,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/318",
"paper_id": 2764935,
"record_id": 3815524,
"submission_id": 532213,
"decision_id": 571764,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/342",
"paper_id": 2738585,
"record_id": 3815525,
"submission_id": 532214,
"decision_id": 571765,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/370",
"paper_id": 2830871,
"record_id": 3815526,
"submission_id": 532215,
"decision_id": 571766,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/371",
"paper_id": 2858445,
"record_id": 3815527,
"submission_id": 532216,
"decision_id": 571767,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/373",
"paper_id": 2820562,
"record_id": 3815528,
"submission_id": 532217,
"decision_id": 571768,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/409",
"paper_id": 2522863,
"record_id": 3815529,
"submission_id": 532218,
"decision_id": 571769,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/418",
"paper_id": 2750749,
"record_id": 3815530,
"submission_id": 532219,
"decision_id": 571770,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/468",
"paper_id": 2846824,
"record_id": 3815531,
"submission_id": 532220,
"decision_id": 571771,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/518",
"paper_id": 2761686,
"record_id": 3815532,
"submission_id": 532221,
"decision_id": 571772,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/524",
"paper_id": 2784543,
"record_id": 3815533,
"submission_id": 532222,
"decision_id": 571773,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/539",
"paper_id": 2761760,
"record_id": 3815534,
"submission_id": 532223,
"decision_id": 571774,
"edition_id": 104044
},
{
"external_id": "2026/552",
"paper_id": 2758575,
"record_id": 3815535,
"submission_id": 532224,
"decision_id": 571775,
"edition_id": 104044
}
]
},
"history_protection": {
"submissions": {
"rows": 532202,
"sha256": "9d41955c80fc91dae4f65d65e0f69198ce2d79508ceebfe943bdc19825983df8"
},
"decisions": {
"rows": 571754,
"sha256": "c8dc762d089d1656ee1308dacec9109605e1a4be7e5fcfa8f95013e77a0cb55c"
},
"decision_sources": {
"rows": 571754,
"sha256": "231f15b4c70435977d6ab784112ff5c748541eeb4d54c28bb861f8835f1eba10"
},
"submission_sources": {
"rows": 581986,
"sha256": "b9d8c39e945df340daf1c695a6359cfb549b8bd2f391cb139dabba2c16afa242"
},
"submission_identifiers": {
"rows": 383956,
"sha256": "0e8f514e186e08bd00a65f8e14fc7f63db6add76722271e0111e14f5d27b9dbe"
}
},
"evidence": {
"parent_acceptance_sha256": "8a08015bbd725b400de53477837e850ca92a50479d7f86f2cfed56d50bb22577",
"accepted_report": "/data/paper-index/collected/ismir2026-import21-v1/postgresql-postcheck-v1.json",
"accepted_report_sha256": "153ef13dbac9f4243c81bdd2a16d3ade74372d3e45ca5e84acc2b7258bca7bfc",
"baseline": "/data/paper-index/collected/ismir2026-baseline21-v1/baseline.json",
"baseline_sha256": "204b571b47e164d68930158c2578f609814969940628d421a2b64c3a6ce1b018",
"baseline_archive_sha256": "ecac32e1d3890786a5670ff06f88fa7bd92155306cf8133f3164de0cb9f48e6b",
"preparation_sha256": "6781edfaa67798d76329fb5c7948d83693607c96352a38eccce0067faa95deaa",
"acceptance_archive": "/data/paper-index/validation/ismir2026-import21-acceptance-recovery-v1.tar.gz",
"acceptance_archive_sha256": "55e1cc8301548ff0abc195add5f40d7082a06e4f087f6da5838ffd2f6b33339c",
"fresh_packets_sha256": "79e0e8187a522478c443d036fdbf2f8d5e6a22c949d46fb0592a664ec1bc22fe",
"local_acceptance_check_sha256": "04f4ec6969a71655d70f446347646f63efc56e5a5a8e974b931703482e5e7ceb",
"census_summary_sha256": "ee4ec2e6d6eaed55ce3475e735bfba9bd94e512893cd3c3024035b48b744f475",
"ci_run": 1257,
"ci_tests": 556,
"ci_proof_sha256": "5ad08aa907caec5a1ca63df5e7345db4802dab4e3a91293a0303bf481a903ff8"
},
"consumed_queue": "/data/paper-index/collected/ismir2026-prepared21-v2: NEVER REPLAY",
"previous_consumed_queue": "/data/paper-index/collected/ismir2026-prepared10-v1: NEVER REPLAY",
"query_example_rechecked": {
"paper_id": 2757497,
"publication_outcome": "accepted",
"rejected_attempts": 1,
"rejection_source_observations": 2,
"distinct_ismir_accepted_attempts": 1,
"original_ismir_signed_decision_verified": false,
"ismir_decision_date": null
},
"new_batch_prior_negative_attempts": 0,
"new_batch_prior_negative_observations": 0,
"source_tag_links_cumulative": 267,
"presence_census": {
"snapshot_at": "2026-11-18 06:46:44.099675+00",
"scope": "Fixed278 venue-year presence only, not paper/track/abstract/public-negative completeness or final deduplication. Legacy43 gaps deferred, not filled.",
"target_venues": 43,
"expected_slots": 278,
"populated_slots": 274,
"missing_slots": 4,
"missing": [
{
"venue": "CIKM",
"year": 2026
},
{
"venue": "ECCV",
"year": 2026
},
{
"venue": "ICDM",
"year": 2026
},
{
"venue": "IROS",
"year": 2026
}
],
"delta_from_v21": {
"newly_present": [],
"previous_missing": 4,
"current_missing": 4,
"ISMIR_source_observations": 31
},
"snapshot_sha256": "5aabc91217ad787946ba50d6a670296b1e3152a54f5ecaa0e3a9b3a952b63fa7",
"fixed_scope_sha256": "a835bef5b9c3a0f76069d840cecdb9a6bcf65d3a38796d70dbfdfd4b49242264",
"accepted_import_sha256": "153ef13dbac9f4243c81bdd2a16d3ade74372d3e45ca5e84acc2b7258bca7bfc",
"database_written": false
},
"next": [
"Remaining109 observations require review;31 exact-source-abstract candidates are now consumed, not reusable queues.",
"Future increments require a fresh partial31/140 parent and new preservation baseline.",
"Keep raw authors/title/abstract/keyword versions; no numeric miniconf-to-OpenReview-ID assumption, global person aliases or inferred research types.",
"Continue all43 venue/year/track formal-source and public-negative availability audits, then final whole-DB dedup after imports."
]
}
@@ -1,320 +0,0 @@
{
"version": 1,
"as_of": "2026-11-18",
"scope": "930 cached ResearchArcade non-ICLR negative claims, NeurIPS 2021–2025 and EMNLP 2023; not a conference-completeness audit",
"database_snapshot": {
"database": "foundry_data",
"schema": "research",
"at": "2026-11-18 03:48:34.65659+00",
"snapshot": "1048885:1048885:"
},
"database_written": false,
"approved_for_import": 0,
"claims": 930,
"known_same_scope_attempt_claims": 925,
"all_925_have_rejected_status": true,
"without_same_scope_attempt_claims": 5,
"by_venue_year": [
{
"venue": "EMNLP",
"year": 2023,
"claims": 10
},
{
"venue": "NeurIPS",
"year": 2021,
"claims": 136
},
{
"venue": "NeurIPS",
"year": 2022,
"claims": 153
},
{
"venue": "NeurIPS",
"year": 2023,
"claims": 176
},
{
"venue": "NeurIPS",
"year": 2024,
"claims": 201
},
{
"venue": "NeurIPS",
"year": 2025,
"claims": 254
}
],
"evidence": {
"diff_report_sha256": "d49361a8622f3b3f59e824690ceb8bf1c878be35c3e3758366d3b46a407673f5",
"candidate_packets_sha256": "3b21df27e0f30e56b81086d16d3943c4563bbe382200e866b15de14510e07472",
"dataset_revision": "c61bb99b0452429c32f85b1e392f3afdb65731c4",
"dataset_parquet_sha256": "bb6e165ee152a95d91a7ffa16abc9d4a6effbdfcf59183b3bb819d09171689d1",
"candidate_jsonl_sha256": "848e646596e8c747e0c636c2381a139978aff8f2c19f01ad49c98e7f4270c5e6",
"collector_repository": "https://github.com/ulab-uiuc/research-arcade",
"collector_revision": "ecf9c7c2490840b029bd2add4f02d04aca1d014e",
"collector_openreview_crawler_sha256": "4539d951ca05b20785169638eab3884148aa6c354a34c5ecc04e15c84a5910fe",
"collector_revision_proven_to_generate_dataset": false
},
"collector_semantics": {
"legacy_2020_2022": "Reads Blind_Submission note.id; first reply with content.decision, no invitation/signature verification. Not a verified final-decision note.",
"legacy_2019": "Reads first recommendation, which must not be promoted to a final decision. Outside active 2020+ backfill.",
"modern_branch": "Reads Submission note.id and last venueid component; Conference replaced by venue literal. Withdrawn_Submission skipped.",
"identity": "The exported field paper_openreview_id is note.id; forum equality or equivalence to another mirror ID is not independently proved.",
"coverage": "Six-field table has no authors or decision signatures; no completeness inference for public withdrawn/rejected records."
},
"held_claims": [
{
"source_row": 33219,
"note_id_claim": "FSf9h6t152",
"venue": "NeurIPS",
"year": 2025,
"raw_decision": "Rejected_Submission",
"title": "Hierarchical Restructuring of Graph Neural Networks for Robust Learning under Edge Perturbations",
"same_scope_identifier_match": false,
"exact_title_candidates": [],
"approved_for_import": false,
"disposition": "hold_no_exact_title_candidate_not_proof_of_novelty"
},
{
"source_row": 44669,
"note_id_claim": "Pk972F7J8Um",
"venue": "NeurIPS",
"year": 2021,
"raw_decision": "Reject",
"title": "Differential Privacy of Dirichlet Posterior Sampling",
"same_scope_identifier_match": false,
"exact_title_candidates": [
{
"paper_id": 3527429,
"existing_identifiers": [
{
"scheme": "openreview",
"value": "fgBxcKcz9ea",
"paper_id": 3527429
},
{
"scheme": "papercopilot_openreview",
"value": "nips/2021/fgBxcKcz9ea",
"paper_id": 3527429
}
],
"source_abstract_exact_equal": true,
"existing_attempts": [
{
"id": 444666,
"venue": "NeurIPS",
"year": 2021,
"source_submission_id": "nips/2021/fgBxcKcz9ea",
"statuses": [
"rejected"
]
}
],
"attempts_truncated": false,
"identity_approved": false,
"id_alias_approved": false
}
],
"approved_for_import": false,
"disposition": "hold_distinct_note_ids_even_with_equal_title_and_abstract"
},
{
"source_row": 44696,
"note_id_claim": "ki4eJ1fSJNq",
"venue": "NeurIPS",
"year": 2021,
"raw_decision": "Reject",
"title": "Fitting large mixture models using stochastic component selection",
"same_scope_identifier_match": false,
"exact_title_candidates": [
{
"paper_id": 1545058,
"existing_identifiers": [
{
"scheme": "arxiv",
"value": "2110.04776",
"paper_id": 1545058
},
{
"scheme": "openreview",
"value": "ZS394D3djsg",
"paper_id": 1545058
},
{
"scheme": "papercopilot_openreview",
"value": "nips/2021/ZS394D3djsg",
"paper_id": 1545058
}
],
"source_abstract_exact_equal": true,
"existing_attempts": [
{
"id": 444652,
"venue": "NeurIPS",
"year": 2021,
"source_submission_id": "nips/2021/ZS394D3djsg",
"statuses": [
"rejected"
]
}
],
"attempts_truncated": false,
"identity_approved": false,
"id_alias_approved": false
}
],
"approved_for_import": false,
"disposition": "hold_distinct_note_ids_even_with_equal_title_and_abstract"
},
{
"source_row": 45757,
"note_id_claim": "bDP7I2fYwLj",
"venue": "NeurIPS",
"year": 2021,
"raw_decision": "Reject",
"title": "WeaveNet for Approximating Assignment Problems",
"same_scope_identifier_match": false,
"exact_title_candidates": [
{
"paper_id": 3527390,
"existing_identifiers": [
{
"scheme": "openreview",
"value": "2rAiDBJgR_",
"paper_id": 3527390
},
{
"scheme": "papercopilot_openreview",
"value": "nips/2021/2rAiDBJgR_",
"paper_id": 3527390
}
],
"source_abstract_exact_equal": true,
"existing_attempts": [
{
"id": 444580,
"venue": "NeurIPS",
"year": 2021,
"source_submission_id": "nips/2021/2rAiDBJgR_",
"statuses": [
"rejected"
]
}
],
"attempts_truncated": false,
"identity_approved": false,
"id_alias_approved": false
}
],
"approved_for_import": false,
"disposition": "hold_distinct_note_ids_even_with_equal_title_and_abstract"
},
{
"source_row": 49327,
"note_id_claim": "yB8cQIICqe",
"venue": "EMNLP",
"year": 2023,
"raw_decision": "Desk_Rejected_Submission",
"title": "EZ-STANCE: A Large Dataset for Zero-Shot Stance Detection",
"same_scope_identifier_match": false,
"exact_title_candidates": [],
"approved_for_import": false,
"disposition": "hold_possible_later_publication_with_changed_title_and_dataset_size_no_identity_or_author_transfer",
"later_publication_retrieval_lead": {
"url": "https://aclanthology.org/2024.acl-long.838/",
"http_status": 200,
"bytes": 40557,
"response_sha256": "b50dd55c48e31e4c10e97927ce01679369735834aa2c0f8d9f41f8e8e02fc776",
"checked_at": "2026-11-18T04:07:03.699767+00:00",
"anthology_id": "2024.acl-long.838",
"doi": "10.18653/v1/2024.acl-long.838",
"title": "EZ-STANCE: A Large Dataset for English Zero-Shot Stance Detection",
"venue": "ACL",
"year": 2024,
"publication_verified": true,
"link_to_anonymous_rejection_verified": false,
"authors_transferred_to_anonymous_claim": false,
"dataset_pairs_published_version": 47316,
"dataset_pairs_rejection_mirror_version": 30606,
"database_written": false,
"current_database_evidence": {
"snapshot": {
"at": "2026-11-18 04:09:23.720956+00",
"snapshot": "1051887:1051887:"
},
"paper_id": 2131805,
"verified_identifiers": [
{
"scheme": "acl",
"value": "2024.acl-long.838",
"paper_id": 2131805
},
{
"scheme": "acl_anthology",
"value": "2024.acl-long.838",
"paper_id": 2131805
},
{
"scheme": "doi",
"value": "10.18653/v1/2024.acl-long.838",
"paper_id": 2131805
}
],
"existing_attempts": [
{
"venue": "ACL",
"year": 2024,
"track": "main",
"statuses": [
"accepted"
]
}
],
"packet_file_sha256": "de5dfa658177adef87134cf7723afc086bd7395405a31166ff9597b03b3c8af3",
"original_rejection_link_verified": false
}
}
}
],
"access_probes": [
{
"local_evidence": "researcharcade-neurips2021-original-note-check-v1/report.json",
"sha256": "746d752535b516abba43b0e8e6ad901bf39c07da532188dfa97ff911869084ae",
"receipt_summary": {},
"results": [
{
"requested_note_id": "Pk972F7J8Um",
"status": 403,
"url": "https://api.openreview.net/notes?id=Pk972F7J8Um&select=id%2Cforum%2Cinvitation%2Creaders%2Csignatures%2Ccontent.title%2Ccontent.abstract%2Ccontent.venue%2Ccontent.venueid",
"sha256": "b0113384cebc9d724284062f776b45044d22450219112342721d8f9683571c08",
"checked_at": "2026-11-18T04:01:58.643552+00:00"
}
]
},
{
"local_evidence": "emnlp2023-primary-public-metadata-probe-v1/notes-probe.json",
"sha256": "47799dc4520e113d6a2e7c9ea2f362577bb21e3ad583ee02149a36c21cf6ea9d",
"receipt_summary": {
"url": "https://api.openreview.net/notes?invitation=EMNLP%2F2023%2FConference%2F-%2FSubmission&limit=1&select=id%2Cnumber%2Cforum%2Cinvitation%2Creaders%2Csignatures%2Ccdate%2Ctcdate%2Cmdate%2Ctmdate%2Ccontent.title%2Ccontent.abstract%2Ccontent.authors%2Ccontent.venue%2Ccontent.venueid%2Ccontent.keywords",
"http_status": 403,
"response_sha256": "798e964735eb1eff1e4954d5c9e79aad2afd40c3f88dcb82f8ef5bbc55cc0a61",
"response_bytes": 546,
"at": "2026-11-18T03:38:50.112624+00:00"
}
},
{
"local_evidence": "emnlp2023-primary-public-metadata-probe-v1/group-access.json",
"sha256": "8fcb9ccd5615a737c17ef0eeedc9121e85a84ebd63667e83df0bda9ffb83d792",
"receipt_summary": {
"url": "https://api.openreview.net/groups?id=EMNLP%2F2023%2FConference",
"http_status": 200,
"response_sha256": "7c0cc75e2e8be1c18dffc96a9ceabea34f0f7810139c0a990a6bb117d66f6456",
"response_bytes": 13143,
"at": "2026-11-18T03:38:49.929085+00:00"
}
}
],
"access_limit": "NeurIPS 2021 first original note request and EMNLP 2023 source-declared Submission query returned 403. Requests stopped. No alternate API version, endpoint, authentication, or challenge bypass. 403 does not prove zero public records."
}
@@ -1,50 +0,0 @@
# 公开负面来源核查:2026-11-18
本次检查 ResearchArcade 缓存中 NeurIPS 2021–2025、EMNLP 2023 的 930 条负面声明,不包括 ICLR 或 2020 年以前的补漏。原始候选文件未重新下载,PostgreSQL 查询为只读。逐条待办、来源哈希与数据库快照见[机器可读记录](public-negative-source-audit-2026-11-18.json)。没有新增论文、决定、ID 别名或合并。
## 当前库比对
925 条声明通过同会议、同年份的 OpenReview 标识匹配到投稿,且每条都有 rejected 决定。这里只证明对应拒稿已记录,未核验这些论文的所有后续录用历史,也未证明会议公开拒稿全集完整。
另 5 条没有同届标识匹配:
|来源 note.id 声明|会议|标题或识别信息|处置|
|---|---|---|---|
|FSf9h6t152|NeurIPS 2025|Hierarchical Restructuring of Graph Neural Networks for Robust Learning under Edge Perturbations|无精确标题候选;不是已证明的新论文|
|Pk972F7J8Um|NeurIPS 2021|Differential Privacy of Dirichlet Posterior Sampling|候选 paper 3527429,已有同届 rejected,原 ID fgBxcKcz9ea|
|ki4eJ1fSJNq|NeurIPS 2021|Fitting large mixture models using stochastic component selection|候选 paper 1545058,已有同届 rejected,原 ID ZS394D3djsg;另保留 arXiv 2110.04776|
|bDP7I2fYwLj|NeurIPS 2021|WeaveNet for Approximating Assignment Problems|候选 paper 3527390,已有同届 rejected,原 ID 2rAiDBJgR_|
|yB8cQIICqe|EMNLP 2023|EZ-STANCE: A Large Dataset for Zero-Shot Stance Detection|镜像称 Desk_Rejected_Submission;原始公开范围及身份未核验|
三个标题候选的镜像摘要都与已有 PaperCopilot 来源摘要逐字相等,但来源 ID 不同。相等文本不能独立证明两个 note.id 指向同一个 forum,也不能据此创建第二次投稿或批准 ID 别名。现有实体包没有截断投稿列表,均只有已记录的 NeurIPS 2021 拒稿;这不代表从未在其他地方录用。
## 采集器证据与使用限制
作者仓库 [research-arcade](https://github.com/ulab-uiuc/research-arcade) 固定版本 `ecf9c7c2490840b029bd2add4f02d04aca1d014e` 的 `openreview_crawler.py` 显示:
- 2020–2022 的旧接口路径读取 Blind_Submission 的 `note.id`,从 replies 中取第一个带 `decision` 字段的值,未验证决定 invitation 或签名。
- 2019 路径取第一个 `recommendation`,不能将其升级为正式决定。该年度属于保留线索的范围,本轮不补导。
- 新接口路径读取 Submission 的 `note.id`,用 `venueid` 尾段作为标签;遇 Conference 再取 `venue`,并跳过 Withdrawn_Submission。
三个源码文件均核对 Git blob SHA-1 和完整文件 SHA-256;没有执行第三方采集器。源码版本早于数据集版本,但未证明该提交实际生成了此数据集。数据集仅有六个元数据字段,缺少作者和决定签名,因此既不能证明完整 withdrawn 覆盖,也不能将导出的 ID 无条件认作已验证 forum。
## 原始来源访问结果
EMNLP 2023 官方分组元数据返回 200,其声明的 Submission invitation 与既有配置一致;对该 invitation 的匿名元数据查询返回 403。NeurIPS 2021 对第一条候选 note `Pk972F7J8Um` 的匿名元数据查询同样返回 403,余下五个 ID 未发请求。均已停止对应来源查询,没有换接口版本、登录或绕过访问限制。403 不能说明没有公开投稿;未保留完整错误正文,也不将具体拒绝原因猜测为已知。
[EMNLP 2023 官方政策](https://2023.emnlp.org/blog/EMNLP-2023-openreview/)说明公开录用稿件与选择公开的拒稿,现有 9 条 rejected 或本镜像的 1 条 desk-rejected 均不能证明完整公开集合。
## EZ-STANCE 后续发表线索
独立的 [ACL Anthology 官方条目](https://aclanthology.org/2024.acl-long.838/)确认相近标题的 EZ-STANCE 在 ACL 2024 Long Papers 发表,DOI `10.18653/v1/2024.acl-long.838`。正式标题多了 English,数据集由拒稿镜像中的 30,606 对变为 47,316 对。已保存官方 HTML 的完整哈希,登记为版本关系核查线索;尚未证明与匿名 EMNLP 2023 声明属于同一投稿或同一科学工作,没有把已发表作者转填到匿名记录,也没有写入关联或第二份论文。后续必须核验版本关系并保留各自的投稿决定证据。
当前 PostgreSQL 的正式标题变体查询命中已有 paper `2131805`,其 ACL/DOI 标识与官方条目一致,已有 `ACL / 2024 / main / accepted` 投稿历史。该实体无需重复新建。匿名 EMNLP 声明与该实体的关系仍未批准,不能把这条线索表述为已经确认的“先拒后录”。快照、标识及完整实体包哈希已记入机器记录。
## 下次从哪里继续
1. 保留五条候选及旧 ID,等待可验证的原始公开元数据或独立可靠来源;不要反复重放已拒绝的原始接口请求。
2. 对三对 ID 分歧先取得 note/forum 关系证据,再独立审核科学工作身份与逐次投稿关系;保留已有拒稿及以后发现的录用。
3. 两条没有精确标题候选的记录仍需标题变体、作者及摘要交叉核查;匿名元数据不能用于推断作者身份。
4. 继续其余会议与年度的公开负面可用性核查,不将这 930 条当作全会、全年份覆盖,也不将 accepted-only 镜像算作拒稿补全。
另修正交接记录:TMLR 是额外的期刊政策线索,当前 43 个会议的 registry 中没有 TMLR;没有因此更改会议分母。2000–2019 已发现线索仍保留。
+33
View File
@@ -48,3 +48,36 @@ paper-atlas collect ismir2026-program \
正式名单与政策恢复包:同目录 `remaining2026-listings-research-v2-recovery.tar.gz`,SHA256 为 `f5ef7c2e73d46712146e4d6711ad5ad562e16b8b55c0cd75d1041cd0b81142cb`。安全恢复三个源目录、核验文件后可重跑上述命令。 正式名单与政策恢复包:同目录 `remaining2026-listings-research-v2-recovery.tar.gz`,SHA256 为 `f5ef7c2e73d46712146e4d6711ad5ad562e16b8b55c0cd75d1041cd0b81142cb`。安全恢复三个源目录、核验文件后可重跑上述命令。
完整来源和独立 140 项清单在测试夹具中冻结。测试、构建、打包、安装及实际隔离目录 CLI 验证只在用户指定 `ces-control:host` runner 执行。生产规范化后还需独立核验全部记录,并用 PostgreSQL 只读预检检查候选作品和既往投稿;不自动合并来源差异或人物身份。 完整来源和独立 140 项清单在测试夹具中冻结。测试、构建、打包、安装及实际隔离目录 CLI 验证只在用户指定 `ces-control:host` runner 执行。生产规范化后还需独立核验全部记录,并用 PostgreSQL 只读预检检查候选作品和既往投稿;不自动合并来源差异或人物身份。
## 2026-11-18:首批 10 条验收(历史阶段)
本段保留首批历史状态;当前累计结果和增量父状态见下方最新验收段。
首批 10 项已逐篇核查研究内容,并通过当前数据库实体、作者、摘要及完整历史的只读复核,随后使用已通过远程 CI 的包内 `import records` 导入。新增论文实体 **0**,新增来源记录、投稿、录用观察各 **10**,来源标签证据 **94** 条;规范标题、作者、摘要及旧历史保留。原始来源摘要另存,不覆盖规范摘要。覆盖为 `partial10/140`,还有 **130** 项待核验。数值节目 ID 仍只作为节目定位符,未冒充 OpenReview 投稿 ID,未新增全局人名别名或推断研究类型。
[逐条验收与恢复记录](coverage/ismir2026-import10-2026-11-18.json)包含生产行 ID、保护基线、归档及证据哈希。服务器基线保护此前 6,384 篇与本批 10 篇的并集 **6,394** 篇,全库旧投稿、决定及来源关系哈希未变;独立新快照的 10 个完整实体包、来源字段、标签和标识也逐项核验。Foundry `/readyz` 返回200,17,987,751,936字节的 SQLite 备份保持只读。该验收不是最终全库科学工作去重。
例如 paper `2757497`(Learning Music Style for Piano Arrangement Through Cross-Modal Bootstrapping)保留一次 ICLR2026 拒稿投稿和两条拒稿来源观察,并新增独立 ISMIR2026 录用投稿。实际执行以下查询,返回 `publication_outcome=accepted`,同时保留原拒稿历史:
```sh
paper-atlas query --pg-service foundry-research --pg-schema research \
--paper 2757497 --outcome accepted
```
ISMIR 的 accepted 来自正式名单和节目,尚无原始签名决定或具体决定日期;不能把采集时间当作决定时间。决定的规范时间使用包内既有毫秒格式,来源回执的原始微秒时间仍保留于元数据。
**禁止重放** `/data/paper-index/collected/ismir2026-prepared10-v1` 的文件。导入单元 `paper-atlas-ismir2026-import10-v1.service`、invocation `538ce9c9324a4f59b5bb49d3094d5265` 已成功结束;该阶段建立了 `partial10/140` 父状态;后续累计结果见下方最新段,不得沿用已消费的 `0/140` 父状态。保护基线恢复包为 `/data/paper-index/validation/ismir2026-baseline10-recovery-v1.tar.gz`,验收恢复包为 `/data/paper-index/validation/ismir2026-import10-acceptance-recovery-v1.tar.gz`;本机 paper-index 工作目录有同名副本及独立检查记录。
## 2026-11-18:新增 21 条,累计 31/140
第二批21项已通过逐篇研究内容审查、新鲜只读父状态检查、保护基线及独立入库验收。新增论文实体、来源和edition均为0;新增来源记录、投稿、录用观察各21条,新增173条来源标签证据。累计31条录用来源观察、267条标签证据,覆盖仍为 `partial31/140`,**109项待核验**。三十一项摘要都保留在原始来源记录中,既有规范资料没有被覆盖。
本批明确保留不同研究工作,例如UOT-IR音乐压缩与SymphonyGen交响生成,以及AI混合音轨占比回归与BAMM真实广播检测;不因作者或主题相近合并。源关键词和展示方式继续使用各自namespace,没有推断全局人名别名、原始OpenReview投稿ID或研究类型。
[第二批逐条验收及恢复记录](coverage/ismir2026-import21-2026-11-18.json)包含21组生产行ID、源码提交、全部证据哈希和新计数。保护并核验了6,415篇作品的规范资料、旧来源与标签,以及所有旧全局投稿/决定/来源关系指纹;新快照另导出21个完整实体包逐字段核验。首批10项保留;paper2757497的实际查询仍显示accepted及原ICLR一次拒稿下的两条来源观察。
本批使用固定源码 `3754545003e1f96b88c6533cc3a69dc557f07305`,已在远程 `ces-control` CI1257通过556项测试,含真实PostgreSQL只读增量门禁回归。该修复解决预检对Mapping行对象切片的错误,未弱化覆盖校验;旧的只读准备v1失败时没有写库,修复后v2重新检查通过。默认运行时未因本批操作切换。
**禁止重放** `/data/paper-index/collected/ismir2026-prepared21-v2`。服务 `paper-atlas-ismir2026-import21-v1.service`、invocation `78077b901a274426bb161ef8d69963ad` 已成功结束。新批次必须从当前 `partial31/140` 准备,不能再用 `10/140` 或 `0/140`。保护基线恢复包为 `/data/paper-index/validation/ismir2026-baseline21-recovery-v1.tar.gz`,验收恢复包为 `/data/paper-index/validation/ismir2026-import21-acceptance-recovery-v1.tar.gz`;本机paper-index目录有同名副本与独立检查结果。
新的固定范围盘点仍为274/278个年度有数据;本批提高ISMIR来源覆盖,没有填补其他空年度,也没有关闭公开拒稿或最终全库去重任务。Foundry就绪检查200,SQLite备份继续只读。