Compare commits

..

5 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Zayden-Jung 59053fd4fb Merge pull request '封装CoRL2026官方名单及分字段档案来源' (#54) from codex/corl2026 into main
Metadata integrity checks / metadata (push) Successful in 2m54s
Reviewed-on: #54
2026-11-16 16:50:20 +00:00
codex-bot b50136d5bc Merge main into CoRL branch and preserve both conference guides
Metadata integrity checks / metadata (push) Successful in 2m52s
2026-11-17 00:46:21 +08:00
Zayden-Jung 87a0689fcc Merge pull request '封装ICAPS2026官方名单与独立注册元数据' (#55) from codex/icaps2026 into main
Metadata integrity checks / metadata (push) Successful in 2m49s
Reviewed-on: #55
2026-11-16 16:41:57 +00:00
codex-bot 19d03ced54 Verify installed CoRL collector against all 687 source records
Metadata integrity checks / metadata (push) Successful in 2m52s
2026-11-16 22:59:19 +08:00
codex-bot c33f5422de Collect CoRL 2026 program with versioned public metadata provenance
Metadata integrity checks / metadata (push) Successful in 2m51s
2026-11-16 22:54:52 +08:00
7 changed files with 300 additions and 0 deletions
+13
View File
@@ -75,6 +75,19 @@ jobs:
(rss_snapshots/'receipts.json').write_text(json.dumps(rss_fixture['receipts'])) (rss_snapshots/'receipts.json').write_text(json.dumps(rss_fixture['receipts']))
subprocess.run([python,'-I','-B','-m','paper_atlas','collect','rss2026-proceedings','--snapshots',str(rss_snapshots),'--out',str(root/'installed-rss2026')],cwd=outside,check=True) subprocess.run([python,'-I','-B','-m','paper_atlas','collect','rss2026-proceedings','--snapshots',str(rss_snapshots),'--out',str(root/'installed-rss2026')],cwd=outside,check=True)
assert json.loads((root/'installed-rss2026/collection-report.json').read_text())['records'] == 210 assert json.loads((root/'installed-rss2026/collection-report.json').read_text())['records'] == 210
corl_fixture = json.loads(gzip.decompress((src/'tests/fixtures/corl2026-source.json.gz').read_bytes()))
corl_official = root/'corl2026-official'
corl_archive = root/'corl2026-archive'
corl_official.mkdir()
corl_archive.mkdir()
(corl_official/'accepted.html').write_text(corl_fixture['official_html'])
(corl_official/'research.json').write_text(json.dumps(corl_fixture['research']))
(corl_archive/'explorer-paper-metadata-filtered-v1.json').write_text(corl_fixture['filtered'])
subprocess.run([python,'-I','-B','-m','paper_atlas','collect','corl2026-program','--official-snapshots',str(corl_official),'--archive-snapshots',str(corl_archive),'--out',str(root/'installed-corl2026')],cwd=outside,check=True)
corl_report = json.loads((root/'installed-corl2026/collection-report.json').read_text())
assert corl_report['records'] == 687 and corl_report['presentations'] == 780
assert len(corl_report['title_variants']) == 34 and corl_report['public_rejected_availability'] == 'unknown'
assert not corl_report['database_written'] and not corl_report['pdfs_downloaded']
subprocess.run([python,'-I','-B','-m','paper_atlas','collect','www-archive','--help'],cwd=outside,check=True) subprocess.run([python,'-I','-B','-m','paper_atlas','collect','www-archive','--help'],cwd=outside,check=True)
subprocess.run([python,'-I','-B','-m','paper_atlas','collect','aamas-proceedings','--help'],cwd=outside,check=True) subprocess.run([python,'-I','-B','-m','paper_atlas','collect','aamas-proceedings','--help'],cwd=outside,check=True)
subprocess.run([python,'-I','-B','-m','paper_atlas','collect','neurips-program','--help'],cwd=outside,check=True) subprocess.run([python,'-I','-B','-m','paper_atlas','collect','neurips-program','--help'],cwd=outside,check=True)
+4
View File
@@ -124,3 +124,7 @@ RSS 2026 已独立适配官方论文集与录用表;使用方法和与 2025 de
ICAPS 2026 的[官方名单采集器](docs/icaps2026-program.md)区分 90 篇主会轨道组录用与 10 篇既有论文展示;逐篇 track、摘要和稳定标识尚未解决,输出均待审核,不能直接视作已完成入库。 ICAPS 2026 的[官方名单采集器](docs/icaps2026-program.md)区分 90 篇主会轨道组录用与 10 篇既有论文展示;逐篇 track、摘要和稳定标识尚未解决,输出均待审核,不能直接视作已完成入库。
ICAPS 2026 也提供独立的 `collect icaps2026-registry`,保留 Crossref 卷 36 的 DOI、作者与摘要版本;不覆盖节目表文字,不把卷 35 或版本差异自动并入。配置与边界见同一份[ICAPS 来源说明](docs/icaps2026-program.md)。 ICAPS 2026 也提供独立的 `collect icaps2026-registry`,保留 Crossref 卷 36 的 DOI、作者与摘要版本;不覆盖节目表文字,不把卷 35 或版本差异自动并入。配置与边界见同一份[ICAPS 来源说明](docs/icaps2026-program.md)。
### CoRL 2026 官方程序快照
`collect corl2026-program` 将官方 687 个论坛与固定公开档案按 ID 对照,保留 34 条标题版本差异及分字段来源。不会自动接受 arXiv 匹配或推断拒稿;详情见 [CoRL 2026 使用与恢复说明](docs/corl2026-program.md)。
+24
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,24 @@
# CoRL 2026:官方程序与公开档案
这是长期维护、按需运行的来源适配器。命令只读已冻结的元数据快照,生成待核验文件;不连接数据库,不抓取 PDF、评审或作者个人档案,不执行网页脚本,也不尝试通过 OpenReview 验证挑战。
```sh
paper-atlas collect corl2026-program \
--official-snapshots /data/paper-index/collected/corl2026-official-listing-research-v1 \
--archive-snapshots /data/paper-index/collected/corl2026-public-archive-inventory-v1 \
--out /data/paper-index/collected/corl2026-normalized-v1
```
官方快照包含 `accepted.html` 和 `research.json` 的 HTTP 回执。适配器解析 Google Sites 的 `data-code`,不把外层文本提取为空误作无论文。687 个论坛有 780 次展示:687 次海报、21 次口头、72 次 Spotlight。论坛 ID 确定投稿身份,展示形式不是新的投稿或 track。
作者及摘要来自 `gisbi-kim/conference-explorers` 的固定提交 `75b3f7a04b3a77c454540fe2506bfa615b8e038e`,经字段过滤后的 `explorer-paper-metadata-filtered-v1.json`。输入、上游原始数据 SHA-256 及 Git blob 均固定;改变来源需要另行研究、更新快照及检查,不能静默接受。
这是独立整理者的版本证据,并非本次重新核验的 OpenReview 原页。每条保留档案标题、作者、摘要、分字段来源 URL、官方标题及全部展示场次。34 个官方与档案标题差异会显式标记,不能视作勘误或自动作者别名。规范记录中的标题与作者摘要保持档案版本一致;官方标题单独保留,避免拼成没有来源的版本。
档案的 arXiv 链接和匹配标题只存为未批准候选,不进入作品标识;不沿用其推断机构、个人档案、作者 ID 或生成标签。只有 OpenReview 论坛 ID 进入作品和投稿标识。
所有输出均为 partial。官方政策只证实录用论文及评审公开,没有证实 rejected 集可见性。不能由此生成拒稿记录,也不能声称这 687 条覆盖了公开拒稿或全部论文关系。
输出目录必须全新;失败留下 `failed.json`,成功报告最后原子发布。恢复时先检查原目录,不覆盖失败现场或重跑已消费的导入队列。生成文件仍需元数据版本审阅、当前数据库身份候选检查、独立保护基线及导入后核验,最后另做全库去重。
测试和安装验证只在用户授权的 `ces-control:host` runner 上运行。
+1
View File
@@ -29,6 +29,7 @@ COMMANDS = {
('collect','cvf'): ('paper_atlas.collectors.vision', {'source':'cvf'}, 'CVPR / ICCV 官方开放目录'), ('collect','cvf'): ('paper_atlas.collectors.vision', {'source':'cvf'}, 'CVPR / ICCV 官方开放目录'),
('collect','ecva'): ('paper_atlas.collectors.vision', {'source':'ecva'}, 'ECCV 官方开放目录'), ('collect','ecva'): ('paper_atlas.collectors.vision', {'source':'ecva'}, 'ECCV 官方开放目录'),
('collect','aamas-proceedings'): ('paper_atlas.collectors.aamas', {}, '按官方目录区分 AAMAS 发表形式和摘要'), ('collect','aamas-proceedings'): ('paper_atlas.collectors.aamas', {}, '按官方目录区分 AAMAS 发表形式和摘要'),
('collect','corl2026-program'): ('paper_atlas.collectors.corl2026', {}, '核验 CoRL 2026 官方论坛名单与分字段公开档案'),
('collect','neurips-program'): ('paper_atlas.collectors.neurips_program', {}, '按公开节目来源区分 NeurIPS 2026 投稿与重复展示'), ('collect','neurips-program'): ('paper_atlas.collectors.neurips_program', {}, '按公开节目来源区分 NeurIPS 2026 投稿与重复展示'),
('collect','www-archive'): ('paper_atlas.collectors.www_archive', {}, '核验早期WWW官方档案并分开待核查条目'), ('collect','www-archive'): ('paper_atlas.collectors.www_archive', {}, '核验早期WWW官方档案并分开待核查条目'),
('collect','dblp'): ('paper_atlas.collectors.dblp_records', {}, '核对并整理 DBLP 历史发表记录'), ('collect','dblp'): ('paper_atlas.collectors.dblp_records', {}, '核对并整理 DBLP 历史发表记录'),
+183
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,183 @@
"""Frozen CoRL 2026 official program joined to attributed public archive metadata."""
import argparse
from collections import Counter
from datetime import datetime
import hashlib
import json
from pathlib import Path
import re
import unicodedata
from urllib.parse import parse_qs, urlsplit
from paper_atlas.io.html import Document, clean
SOURCE = 'corl_program_archive'
OFFICIAL = 'https://2026.corl.org/program/accepted-papers'
REVISION = '75b3f7a04b3a77c454540fe2506bfa615b8e038e'
ARCHIVE = f'https://raw.githubusercontent.com/gisbi-kim/conference-explorers/{REVISION}/corl2026/data.json'
OFFICIAL_SHA = '3f026639c1a777b0b5fbd132e1935a27cdd519ca0a04e60ca3b650a3bc7eaef4'
FILTERED_SHA = '6e6d7ecd57ee139c61283188fec39ebe9dc7f5c30ec14c8c5839d1277b03a588'
RAW_SHA = '1e96ed2dffcd96c2584a7ba020201c831e49ae1a69eae3ef1553fd5a34802810'
BLOB = '322eeef71126b85e13a98fdce9c73fac81934d3f'
FIELDS = {'id', 'title', 'openreview', 'poster_session', 'poster_day', 'poster_date',
'poster_time', 'poster_venue', 'poster_number', 'index', 'presentation_type',
'arxiv', 'matched_title', 'abstract', 'metadata_source', 'author_source',
'abstract_source', 'identity_note', 'authors', 'openreview_updated', 'metadata_checked'}
def digest(raw):
return hashlib.sha256(raw).hexdigest()
def comparable(text):
return ''.join(c for c in unicodedata.normalize('NFKD', text).casefold() if c.isalnum())
def forum_id(url):
if not isinstance(url, str):
raise ValueError('Forum URL must be text')
u = urlsplit(url); q = parse_qs(u.query, keep_blank_values=True)
if (u.scheme != 'https' or u.netloc != 'openreview.net' or u.path != '/forum'
or u.fragment or set(q) != {'id'} or len(q['id']) != 1
or not re.fullmatch(r'[A-Za-z0-9_-]{8,32}', q['id'][0])):
raise ValueError('Invalid original forum identity')
return q['id'][0]
def parse_program(raw):
embeds = [n.attrs['data-code'] for n in Document(raw).root.walk() if 'data-code' in n.attrs]
if len(embeds) != 1:
raise ValueError('Expected one official embedded program')
doc = Document(embeds[0]); nodes = list(doc.root.walk())
if [clean(n.text()) for n in nodes if n.tag == 'h1'] != ['CoRL 2026 Accepted Papers']:
raise ValueError('Unexpected program edition')
summary = [clean(n.text()) for n in nodes if n.tag == 'p' and n.attrs.get('class') == 'sub']
if len(summary) != 1 or not summary[0].startswith('687 accepted papers · 21 orals · 72 spotlights · 687 posters'):
raise ValueError('Reviewed program census changed')
papers = {}; sessions = {}; occurrences = []
for section in (n for n in nodes if n.tag == 'section' and 'session' in n.attrs.get('class', '').split()):
sid = section.attrs.get('data-sess', section.attrs.get('id'))
if not isinstance(sid, str) or not re.fullmatch(r'(?:O[1-7]|S[1-8]|post-p[1-3])', sid) or sid in sessions:
raise ValueError('Unexpected or repeated presentation session')
kind = 'oral' if sid.startswith('O') else 'spotlight' if sid.startswith('S') else 'poster'
headings = [clean(n.text()) for n in section.walk() if n.tag == 'h3']
if len(headings) != 1:
raise ValueError('Ambiguous session heading')
sessions[sid] = {'kind': kind, 'heading': headings[0]}
seen = set()
for link in (n for n in section.walk() if n.tag == 'a' and 'openreview.net' in n.attrs.get('href', '')):
fid = forum_id(link.attrs['href']); title = clean(link.text())
if fid in seen or not title:
raise ValueError('Repeated or empty paper in session')
seen.add(fid)
paper = papers.setdefault(fid, {'title': title, 'presentations': []})
if paper['title'] != title:
raise ValueError('Conflicting official titles share a forum')
event = {'session_id': sid, **sessions[sid]}
paper['presentations'].append(event); occurrences.append((fid, sid, kind))
counts = Counter(kind for _, _, kind in occurrences)
if len(papers) != 687 or len(sessions) != 18 or counts != {'poster': 687, 'oral': 21, 'spotlight': 72}:
raise ValueError('Incomplete official program')
for paper in papers.values():
kinds = Counter(p['kind'] for p in paper['presentations'])
if kinds['poster'] != 1 or len(paper['presentations']) not in (1, 2):
raise ValueError('Invalid poster/talk multiplicity')
return papers
def join_metadata(program, archive):
if (archive.get('repository') != 'gisbi-kim/conference-explorers'
or archive.get('revision') != REVISION or archive.get('source_url') != ARCHIVE
or archive.get('source_data_sha256') != RAW_SHA or archive.get('source_git_blob_sha1') != BLOB
or not isinstance(archive.get('papers'), list)):
raise ValueError('Unpinned public metadata provenance')
indexed = {}
for row in archive['papers']:
if not isinstance(row, dict) or set(row) - FIELDS:
raise ValueError('Unexpected metadata/profile fields')
fid = forum_id(row.get('openreview'))
if fid != row.get('id') or fid in indexed:
raise ValueError('Repeated or mismatched archive forum')
if any(forum_id(row.get(key)) != fid for key in ('metadata_source', 'author_source', 'abstract_source')):
raise ValueError('Field source belongs to another submission')
if (not isinstance(row.get('title'), str) or not row['title'].strip()
or not isinstance(row.get('abstract'), str) or not row['abstract'].strip()
or not isinstance(row.get('authors'), list) or not row['authors']
or any(not isinstance(a, str) or not a.strip() or '@' in a or 'anonymous' in a.casefold() for a in row['authors'])):
raise ValueError('Incomplete scholarly metadata')
indexed[fid] = row
if set(indexed) != set(program):
raise ValueError('Official and archive forum sets differ')
return indexed
def collect(out, *, official_snapshots, archive_snapshots):
out = Path(out)
if out.exists():
raise ValueError('Output exists; inspect previous operation before retrying')
out.mkdir(parents=True)
try:
official_root = Path(official_snapshots); archive_root = Path(archive_snapshots)
official = official_root/'accepted.html'; filtered = archive_root/'explorer-paper-metadata-filtered-v1.json'
if official.is_symlink() or filtered.is_symlink():
raise ValueError('Snapshot symlinks rejected')
raw = official.read_bytes(); data = filtered.read_bytes()
if len(raw) > 8*1024**2 or len(data) > 8*1024**2 or digest(raw) != OFFICIAL_SHA or digest(data) != FILTERED_SHA:
raise ValueError('Reviewed snapshot hash changed')
receipts = json.loads((official_root/'research.json').read_bytes())['receipts']
matches = [r for r in receipts if r.get('url') == OFFICIAL]
if len(matches) != 1:
raise ValueError('Missing official source receipt')
receipt = matches[0]; observed = receipt['at']
if (receipt.get('final_url') != OFFICIAL or receipt['http_status'] != 200
or receipt['sha256'] != digest(raw) or receipt['bytes'] != len(raw)
or datetime.fromisoformat(observed.replace('Z', '+00:00')).utcoffset() is None):
raise ValueError('Invalid official receipt')
program = parse_program(raw.decode('utf-8')); archive = json.loads(data); indexed = join_metadata(program, archive)
evidence = out/'evidence'; evidence.mkdir()
sources = {}
for body, suffix, url, name in [(raw, 'html', OFFICIAL, 'program'), (data, 'json', ARCHIVE, 'archive')]:
rel = f'evidence/{digest(body)}.{suffix}'; (out/rel).write_bytes(body)
sources[name] = {'file': rel, 'sha256': digest(body), 'url': url}
rows = []; variants = []
for fid in sorted(program):
p = program[fid]; a = indexed[fid]; variant = comparable(p['title']) != comparable(a['title'])
if variant: variants.append({'forum': fid, 'official_title': p['title'], 'archive_title': a['title']})
rows.append({'source': SOURCE, 'external_id': f'2026/{fid}', 'url': a['openreview'],
'title': a['title'], 'authors': a['authors'], 'abstract': a['abstract'],
'identifiers': {'openreview': fid}, 'submission_identifiers': [{'scheme': 'openreview', 'value': fid}],
'venue': 'CoRL', 'year': 2026, 'track': 'main', 'status': 'accepted',
'raw_decision': 'listed in official CoRL 2026 accepted program', 'evidence_url': OFFICIAL,
'observed_at': observed, 'tags': [], 'metadata': {
'official_program': p, 'archive_fields': a, 'title_variant_requires_review': variant,
'source_evidence': sources, 'archive_revision': REVISION,
'field_provenance': {k: a[k] for k in ('metadata_source', 'author_source', 'abstract_source')},
'original_decision_signature_verified': False,
'scope': 'Acceptance from official forum listing; title/authors/abstract are curator snapshot versions, not live original metadata. arXiv links remain unapproved candidates. No reject inference or person aliases.'}})
if len(variants) != 34:
raise ValueError('Reviewed title-variant census changed')
path = out/'corl-program-archive-2026-main.jsonl'
payload = ''.join(json.dumps(r, ensure_ascii=False)+'\n' for r in rows).encode(); path.write_bytes(payload)
manifest = {'source': SOURCE, 'parser_version': 1, 'venue': 'CoRL', 'year': 2026, 'track': 'main',
'count': len(rows), 'file': str(path), 'file_sha256': digest(payload), 'list_url': OFFICIAL,
'status': 'partial', 'missing_abstract_count': 0}
path.with_suffix('.manifest.json').write_text(json.dumps(manifest, indent=2)+'\n')
report = {'status': 'collected_pending_identity_review', 'records': len(rows), 'presentations': 780,
'files': [manifest], 'title_variants': variants, 'source_evidence': sources,
'database_written': False, 'pdfs_downloaded': False, 'public_rejected_availability': 'unknown',
'scope': 'Source collection only; requires identity and metadata-version review before import; no exhaustive deduplication or rejected-set claim.'}
part = out/'collection-report.json.part'; part.write_text(json.dumps(report, ensure_ascii=False, indent=2)+'\n'); part.replace(out/'collection-report.json')
return report
except Exception as error:
(out/'failed.json').write_text(json.dumps({'status': 'failed_not_complete', 'error_type': type(error).__name__, 'database_written': False})+'\n')
raise
def main(argv=None, *, prog=None):
parser = argparse.ArgumentParser(prog=prog, description=__doc__)
parser.add_argument('--out', type=Path, required=True)
parser.add_argument('--official-snapshots', type=Path, required=True)
parser.add_argument('--archive-snapshots', type=Path, required=True)
args = parser.parse_args(argv)
report = collect(args.out, official_snapshots=args.official_snapshots, archive_snapshots=args.archive_snapshots)
print(json.dumps({'status': report['status'], 'records': report['records'], 'database_written': False}))
Binary file not shown.
+75
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,75 @@
import gzip
import json
from pathlib import Path
import tempfile
import unittest
from paper_atlas.collectors import corl2026 as c
class CoRL2026Test(unittest.TestCase):
@classmethod
def setUpClass(cls):
cls.bundle = json.loads(gzip.decompress((Path(__file__).parent/'fixtures/corl2026-source.json.gz').read_bytes()))
def test_official_census_and_presentation_dedup(self):
program = c.parse_program(self.bundle['official_html'])
self.assertEqual(len(program), 687)
self.assertEqual(sum(len(p['presentations']) for p in program.values()), 780)
self.assertEqual(sum(len(p['presentations']) == 2 for p in program.values()), 93)
def test_conflicting_official_title_is_not_silently_folded(self):
html = self.bundle['official_html']
title = 'Diagnosing Compositional Generalization in Sequential Robot Tasks'
self.assertIn(title, html)
with self.assertRaises(ValueError):
c.parse_program(html.replace(title, 'Different paper', 1))
def test_foreign_forum_source_is_rejected(self):
program = c.parse_program(self.bundle['official_html']); archive = json.loads(self.bundle['filtered'])
archive['papers'][0]['author_source'] = 'https://openreview.net/forum?id=WrongPaper'
with self.assertRaisesRegex(ValueError, 'another submission'):
c.join_metadata(program, archive)
def test_unknown_profile_fields_are_rejected(self):
program = c.parse_program(self.bundle['official_html']); archive = json.loads(self.bundle['filtered'])
archive['papers'][0]['authorids'] = ['profile']
with self.assertRaisesRegex(ValueError, 'profile'):
c.join_metadata(program, archive)
def test_source_sets_must_agree(self):
program = c.parse_program(self.bundle['official_html']); archive = json.loads(self.bundle['filtered'])
archive['papers'].pop()
with self.assertRaisesRegex(ValueError, 'forum sets'):
c.join_metadata(program, archive)
def test_complete_snapshot_and_explicit_version_provenance(self):
with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as tmp:
root = Path(tmp); official = root/'official'; archive = root/'archive'
official.mkdir(); archive.mkdir()
(official/'accepted.html').write_text(self.bundle['official_html'])
(official/'research.json').write_text(json.dumps(self.bundle['research']))
(archive/'explorer-paper-metadata-filtered-v1.json').write_text(self.bundle['filtered'])
out = root/'out'; report = c.collect(out, official_snapshots=official, archive_snapshots=archive)
self.assertEqual(report['records'], 687); self.assertEqual(len(report['title_variants']), 34)
self.assertEqual(report['public_rejected_availability'], 'unknown')
rows = [json.loads(l) for l in (out/'corl-program-archive-2026-main.jsonl').read_text().splitlines()]
self.assertEqual(len({r['external_id'] for r in rows}), 687)
self.assertTrue(all(set(r['identifiers']) == {'openreview'} for r in rows))
self.assertTrue(all(r['submission_identifiers'] == [{'scheme': 'openreview', 'value': r['identifiers']['openreview']}] for r in rows))
self.assertTrue(all(not r['tags'] and not r['metadata']['original_decision_signature_verified'] for r in rows))
self.assertTrue(all(r['title'] == r['metadata']['archive_fields']['title'] for r in rows))
self.assertTrue(all(r['authors'] and r['abstract'] for r in rows))
self.assertFalse(report['database_written']); self.assertFalse(report['pdfs_downloaded'])
with self.assertRaisesRegex(ValueError, 'Output exists'):
c.collect(out, official_snapshots=official, archive_snapshots=archive)
(official/'accepted.html').write_text('tampered')
with self.assertRaisesRegex(ValueError, 'hash changed'):
c.collect(root/'failed', official_snapshots=official, archive_snapshots=archive)
self.assertTrue((root/'failed/failed.json').exists())
self.assertFalse((root/'failed/collection-report.json').exists())
def test_forum_identity_validation(self):
for bad in ['https://openreview.net/challenge?redirect=forum', 'https://evil.test/forum?id=abcdefgh', 'https://openreview.net/forum?id=abcdefgh&other=1']:
with self.assertRaises(ValueError):
c.forum_id(bad)