From ff60fa4cdb774d372299812f0f2f3126e30879f8 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Codex Bot Date: Sun, 8 Nov 2026 17:03:25 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] Verify CLeaR and CoRL editions and organize conference census evidence --- docs/coverage/README.md | 39 +++---- docs/coverage/clear-editions-2026-11-08.json | 66 +++++++++++ docs/coverage/corl-editions-2026-11-08.json | 117 +++++++++++++++++++ docs/coverage/inventory-2026-11-08.json | 57 ++++++++- 4 files changed, 252 insertions(+), 27 deletions(-) create mode 100644 docs/coverage/clear-editions-2026-11-08.json create mode 100644 docs/coverage/corl-editions-2026-11-08.json diff --git a/docs/coverage/README.md b/docs/coverage/README.md index 87f8bdf..79d2067 100644 --- a/docs/coverage/README.md +++ b/docs/coverage/README.md @@ -76,33 +76,30 @@ PGSERVICEFILE=/etc/paper-atlas/pg_service.conf paper-atlas coverage \ ## 官方历届目录核对 -首项独立年份普查为 [RecSys 官方历届目录](https://recsys.acm.org/)，证据见 [recsys-editions-2026-11-08.json](recsys-editions-2026-11-08.json)：保留页面 SHA256、实际链接、检查时间和截至 2026 年的 2007–2026 共 20 届，2027 作为未来届次明确排除。与前述固定生产快照比较，缺 2026 年；这不是对当前主库的新查询，也不证明其他 19 年的论文和 track 已完整。其他会议仍需各自独立目录普查，不能仅凭数据库观察年份推导应举办全集。 +已完成 **12/43** 个目标的独立年份普查，另31个尚未完成。每份证据保存官方目录实际条目、URL、页面哈希和检查时间；不能用数据库已观察年份或首尾年份插值替代官方目录。下表差集仅对应前述固定旧快照，不是当前主库查询，也不代表逐篇、track、摘要或公开拒稿已完整。 -新增两项独立目录普查，该批次推进至 3/43 个目标： - -- [MLSys 官方历届目录](https://mlsys.org/) 列出 2018–2026，[证据文件](mlsys-editions-2026-11-08.json) 保留实际链接及三个官方页面的哈希。[2018 SysML 首届说明](https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2018/) 明确为非存档 oral/poster，允许已有发表研究和后续原样再投；[正式论文集目录](https://proceedings.mlsys.org/) 从 2019 年开始。固定快照缺 2018，不能忽略首届，也不能把展示或 PDF 链接改作正式出版。2027 是未来届次，排除在本次截止范围外。 -- [COLM 官方历届目录](https://colm.cc/) 与首届/第三届说明确认 2024–2026，[证据文件](colm-editions-2026-11-08.json) 保留目录及旧年页面哈希。固定快照的年份差集为空，逐篇、track 和实际论文数仍待核对。[2024 官方 CFP](https://colmweb.org/2024/cfp.html) 明确拒稿元数据不公开，本页没有单独确认撤稿和 desk rejection 的范围。 - -以上均为会议年份目录核查，未执行新的主库覆盖查询，也不替代逐年逐轨道拒稿政策核查。下表补充另外四个目标；下文再补两项；当前累计 10/43，余下 33 个仍待独立普查。 - -本轮再补四项，均保留官方页面哈希、检查时间和实际目录条目；年份差集只与前述固定快照比较： - -| 目标 | 官方截至2026年届次 | 固定快照缺年 | 证据边界 | +| 目标 | 官方截至2026年届次 | 固定旧快照缺年 | 证据与边界 | | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| UAI | 1985–2026，42届 | 1985–2018，34届 | [AUAI](https://www.auai.org/) 旧年表与2026第42届说明；早期编辑图书与会议年分开。见 [证据](uai-editions-2026-11-08.json)。 | -| COLT | 1988–2026，39届 | 1988–2010，23届 | [协会目录](https://www.learningtheory.org/) 的 EuroCOLT 四届另列；排除未来2027。见 [证据](colt-editions-2026-11-08.json)。 | -| AISTATS | 实际目录29届 | 1985、1989–2005奇数年，10届 | [官方会议目录](https://aistats.org/other.html) 早期不连续，不凭起止年补出1987或2008。见 [证据](aistats-editions-2026-11-08.json)。 | -| EMNLP | 1996–2026，31个不同年份 | 无 | [SIGDAT目录](https://sigdat.org/events) 的WVLC另列，2020重复只计一次。年份、日期及地点文字冲突保留在 [证据](emnlp-editions-2026-11-08.json)，不据此修造事件元数据。 | +| NeurIPS | 1987–2025已列论文集，另公告2026，共40届 | 2026 | [证据](neurips-editions-2026-11-08.json)；2026未列论文集，不能称为漏了已出版论文。 | +| ICLR | 2013–2026，14届 | 2013–2016、2018、2019 | [证据](iclr-editions-2026-11-08.json)；2013/2018/2019后续来源已验收，不能因旧快照缺年而重放。 | +| COLM | 2024–2026，3届 | 无 | [证据](colm-editions-2026-11-08.json)；无年份差集不证明逐篇或轨道完整。 | +| COLT | 1988–2026，39届 | 1988–2010，23届 | [证据](colt-editions-2026-11-08.json)；EuroCOLT四届另列，混合论文集保留范围限制。 | +| AISTATS | 官方目录实际29届，早期不连续 | 1985、1989–2005奇数年，共10届 | [证据](aistats-editions-2026-11-08.json)；不补造1987或2008。 | +| UAI | 1985–2026，42届 | 1985–2018，34届 | [证据](uai-editions-2026-11-08.json)；早期编辑图书出版年与会议年分开。 | +| CLeaR | 2022–2026，5届 | 无 | [证据](clear-editions-2026-11-08.json)；由官方出版社首届说明、实际各卷及会议日期核对。 | +| EMNLP | 1996–2026，31个不同年份 | 无 | [证据](emnlp-editions-2026-11-08.json)；WVLC另列，2020重复只计一次，保留年份/日期/地点文字冲突。 | +| IJCAI | 1969–2026，35届，早期隔年 | 无 | [证据](ijcai-editions-2026-11-08.json)；保留IJCAI-ECAI / IJCAI-PRICAI联合名称，多卷不增加届数。 | +| RecSys | 2007–2026，20届 | 2026 | [证据](recsys-editions-2026-11-08.json)；未来2027排除。 | +| CoRL | 2017–2025已列论文集，另公告2026，共10个年份 | 2026 | [证据](corl-editions-2026-11-08.json)；截至11月8日，11月9–12日活动即将举办，PMLR未列该届，不能称为漏了已出版论文。 | +| MLSys | 2018–2026，9届 | 2018 | [证据](mlsys-editions-2026-11-08.json)；首届SysML为非存档oral/poster，正式论文集从2019开始。 | -[UAI 2023 投稿说明](https://www.auai.org/uai2023/submission_instructions) 同样明确作者可选公开拒稿，补入已有2024–2026核查；逐篇公开来源仍未验收。EMNLP2023 的 [官方审稿流程说明](https://2023.emnlp.org/blog/EMNLP-2023-openreview/) 确认 opt-in 范围，不提供可见记录全集，当前9条不能直接称为全量。 +CLeaR与CoRL的出版届次由 [PMLR官方目录](https://proceedings.mlr.press/) 和每卷会议日期核对；[CoRL2026官网](https://www.corl.org/) 的已公告活动另记，不把公告当作已出版论文集。main、workshop、demo与late-breaking展示还需分别核对。MLSys2018允许已有发表研究及后续原样再投，展示或PDF链接不能自动作正式出版证据。 -再补两项独立年份目录，该两项完成后累计 **9/43**；另有 ICML 部分证据，不计入完成数： +NeurIPS2021 Datasets & Benchmarks使用独立目录，2022起混入主卷，2025 Main Conference与Creative AI分索引，仍须保留逐篇轨道证据。EMNLP目录文字冲突保留在证据中，不据此修改事件元数据。 -- [ICLR 官方导航](https://iclr.cc/) 列出2013–2026共14届，2027排除，见 [证据](iclr-editions-2026-11-08.json)。差集仍与旧固定快照比较；2013/2018/2019后续已验收来源不能因旧快照缺年而重放。年份存在不证明逐篇、track 或公开拒稿全量。 -- [NeurIPS 官方论文集目录](https://proceedings.neurips.cc/) 列出1987–2025，另由 [2026官网](https://neurips.cc/) 确认第40届。见 [证据](neurips-editions-2026-11-08.json)。截至检查时目录未列2026论文集，属于已公告而未列出版目录的届次，不能直接说漏了已出版论文。2021 Datasets & Benchmarks 独立目录，2022起混入主卷，2025 Main Conference / Creative AI 分索引，均需保留轨道区别。 -- [ICML 官网](https://icml.cc/) 的2007、2006、2004导航标签分别指向2008、2007、2005，外部 IMLS archive 本次访问失败。见 [部分证据](icml-partial-editions-2026-11-08.json)；保留 `expected_years: null`，不按最早/最晚年份猜全历届，也不计为完成普查。 +ICML仅有 [部分证据](icml-partial-editions-2026-11-08.json)，**不计入完成数**：[官网](https://icml.cc/) 的2007、2006、2004导航标签分别指向2008、2007、2005，外部IMLS archive本次访问失败。保持 `expected_years: null`，不能推测完整历届。 -新增 [IJCAI 官方历届目录](https://ijcai.org/past_conferences/) 普查，当前累计 **10/43**，尚余 33 个目标；见 [证据](ijcai-editions-2026-11-08.json)。目录实际列出1969–2026共35届，早期隔年、2016起逐年，不按首尾年份补不存在的届次。保留 IJCAI-ECAI / IJCAI-PRICAI 联合名称，多卷论文集不增加会议届数。与固定旧快照无年份差集仍不证明逐篇、track 或摘要完整。 +[UAI2023投稿说明](https://www.auai.org/uai2023/submission_instructions) 与2024–2026核查均包含作者可选公开拒稿；逐篇公开来源仍未验收。[EMNLP2023审稿流程说明](https://2023.emnlp.org/blog/EMNLP-2023-openreview/) 确认opt-in范围，但不提供可见记录全集，目前9条不能称为全量。年份普查不替代逐年、逐轨道的公开决定核查。 ## 政策证据的边界 diff --git a/docs/coverage/clear-editions-2026-11-08.json b/docs/coverage/clear-editions-2026-11-08.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4884daa --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/coverage/clear-editions-2026-11-08.json @@ -0,0 +1,66 @@ +{ + "source_url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:00:14.927398+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "6b0c53798d285af02e4425adfd01b51db9d0945e2dc7c92772daa517e8847843", + "cutoff_year": 2026, + "expected_years": [ + 2022, + 2023, + 2024, + 2025, + 2026 + ], + "excluded_future_years": [], + "publisher_index_years": [ + 2022, + 2023, + 2024, + 2025, + 2026 + ], + "editions": [ + { + "year": 2026, + "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v323/", + "publisher_index_label": "Volume 323 Proceedings of CLeaR 2026", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:01:38.679644+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "57f28747aa48a7d7c22d951ec7ea63ca725e0d39d7135a309f62e2ad09ffbe44", + "event_heading": "Volume 323: Causal Learning and Reasoning, 6-8 April 2026, Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard, Cambridge, USA" + }, + { + "year": 2025, + "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v275/", + "publisher_index_label": "Volume 275 Proceedings of CLeaR 2025", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:01:38.558502+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "c5aafeebab81c47def2ca3f62bed9140c890cc8a2bfc5dca80ad44bf6f2db86d", + "event_heading": "Volume 275: Causal Learning and Reasoning, 7-9 May 2025, Lausanne, Switzerland" + }, + { + "year": 2024, + "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v236/", + "publisher_index_label": "Volume 236 Proceedings of CLeaR 2024", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:01:38.730670+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "3f71ca96a2c87880b8cfcb040356d5fb17ba54535d0c9421d6d4622cfce10bb7", + "event_heading": "Volume 236: Causal Learning and Reasoning, 1-3 April 2024, Los Angeles, California, USA" + }, + { + "year": 2023, + "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v213/", + "publisher_index_label": "Volume 213 Proceedings of CLeaR 2023", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:01:40.519783+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "7b70177fb388db0f60bdbe0b83fa2505ebed7b24eeb8eb0fc65b008e12c68c95", + "event_heading": "Volume 213: Conference on Causal Learning and Reasoning, 11-14 April 2023, Amazon Development Center, Tübingen, Germany" + }, + { + "year": 2022, + "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v177/", + "publisher_index_label": "Volume 177 Proceedings of CLeaR 2022", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:01:39.465244+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "b55542996032f89a89d1edb4a2f5daa1f68c624181721466d4a8dbba2b0e769e", + "event_heading": "Volume 177: Conference on Causal Learning and Reasoning, 11-13 April 2022, Sequoia Conference Center, Eureka, CA, USA" + } + ], + "first_edition_explicitly_named_by_publisher": true, + "announced_not_in_publisher_proceedings_index": [], + "scope": "Independent first-edition and all actual publisher-index conference/event-year labels, checked against each volume event heading. No annual interpolation, per-paper/track/abstract completeness or public rejection census. CoRL2026 is separately announced/upcoming and not listed in PMLR index; missing snapshot year does not prove missing published papers." +} diff --git a/docs/coverage/corl-editions-2026-11-08.json b/docs/coverage/corl-editions-2026-11-08.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e96a921 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/coverage/corl-editions-2026-11-08.json @@ -0,0 +1,117 @@ +{ + "source_url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:00:14.927398+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "6b0c53798d285af02e4425adfd01b51db9d0945e2dc7c92772daa517e8847843", + "cutoff_year": 2026, + "expected_years": [ + 2017, + 2018, + 2019, + 2020, + 2021, + 2022, + 2023, + 2024, + 2025, + 2026 + ], + "excluded_future_years": [], + "publisher_index_years": [ + 2017, + 2018, + 2019, + 2020, + 2021, + 2022, + 2023, + 2024, + 2025 + ], + "editions": [ + { + "year": 2025, + "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v305/", + "publisher_index_label": "Volume 305 Proceedings of CoRL 2025", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:01:41.131259+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "6d006392265f4eec3a40cb44a89cf1c9b75d9b2cb393acdf711e91bda0d60e80", + "event_heading": "Volume 305: Conference on Robot Learning, 27-30 September 2025, Seoul, Korea" + }, + { + "year": 2024, + "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v270/", + "publisher_index_label": "Volume 270 Proceedings of CoRL 2024", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:01:46.083656+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "9bf9b3c63c131f8779ee3af7e9ffb3950be4e8eed0dd88d5dd75c7e956764bae", + "event_heading": "Volume 270: Conference on Robot Learning, 6-9 November 2024, Munich, Germany" + }, + { + "year": 2023, + "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v229/", + "publisher_index_label": "Volume 229 Proceedings of CoRL 2023", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:01:41.859103+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "7411f1baa35bc2034af476079fc14dc7198aea1943979f832c0415e34eb91421", + "event_heading": "Volume 229: Conference on Robot Learning, 6-9 November 2023, Atlanta, USA" + }, + { + "year": 2022, + "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v205/", + "publisher_index_label": "Volume 205 Proceedings of CoRL 2022", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:01:42.212859+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "ea69a217883f22500ce1153fc23c6dfa140ffbebb60081945b57baebee5e8db4", + "event_heading": "Volume 205: Conference on Robot Learning, 14-18 December 2022, Auckland, New Zealand" + }, + { + "year": 2021, + "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v164/", + "publisher_index_label": "Volume 164 Proceedings of CoRL 2021", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:01:43.424032+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "5dbbb03b4b021f50898b66ce2f9896ef809a2813210e17c1a97809ac36e0bf71", + "event_heading": "Volume 164: Conference on Robot Learning, 8-11 November 2021, London, UK" + }, + { + "year": 2020, + "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v155/", + "publisher_index_label": "Volume 155 Proceedings of CoRL 2020", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:01:43.030373+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "80350d6dac2b430312639d7a7c8973e5f5c91e1430c45a50fa7b10b7668b6905", + "event_heading": "Volume 155: Conference on Robot Learning, 16-18 November 2020, virtual" + }, + { + "year": 2019, + "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v100/", + "publisher_index_label": "Volume 100 CoRL 2019", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:01:45.269656+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "13c5f8504612969fc76a0547437d5e1ed00f6bc9e5961950dce9bd074e02962c", + "event_heading": "Volume 100: Conference on Robot Learning, 30 October to 1 November 2019," + }, + { + "year": 2018, + "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v87/", + "publisher_index_label": "Volume 87 CoRL 2018", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:01:47.815772+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "9820e3ef1d900d1479a1dd2e90bdbf36d88bd1841cac3c1c23cf1aa4cd548396", + "event_heading": "Volume 87: Conference on Robot Learning, 29-31 October 2018," + }, + { + "year": 2017, + "url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v78/", + "publisher_index_label": "Volume 78 CoRL 2017 Proceedings", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:01:47.618892+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "9cf96de10cea85ea94e841861d6a17deccf9d89a0058c991fab7c69ac9a300e9", + "event_heading": "Volume 78: Conference on Robot Learning, 13-15 November 2017," + } + ], + "first_edition_explicitly_named_by_publisher": true, + "announced_not_in_publisher_proceedings_index": [ + { + "source_url": "https://www.corl.org/", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:01:51.370877+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "346f02407c7247f3de4e8124d65c391f8786afe5bdf6c2261de91b34a8ab25d2", + "year": 2026, + "event_dates": "2026-11-09/2026-11-12", + "as_of": "2026-11-08", + "state": "announced_upcoming_event_not_in_publisher_proceedings_index" + } + ], + "scope": "Independent first-edition and all actual publisher-index conference/event-year labels, checked against each volume event heading. No annual interpolation, per-paper/track/abstract completeness or public rejection census. CoRL2026 is separately announced/upcoming and not listed in PMLR index; missing snapshot year does not prove missing published papers." +} diff --git a/docs/coverage/inventory-2026-11-08.json b/docs/coverage/inventory-2026-11-08.json index 3105e1f..00d3a48 100644 --- a/docs/coverage/inventory-2026-11-08.json +++ b/docs/coverage/inventory-2026-11-08.json @@ -1119,7 +1119,7 @@ "source_record_counts": { "pmlr": 243 }, - "historical_coverage": "pending_independent_census", + "historical_coverage": "conference_year_census_checked_tracks_and_records_pending", "policy_checks": [ { "year": 2026, @@ -1131,10 +1131,28 @@ } ], "remaining": [ - "按真实举办届次及独立官方目录核对历史年度和 track，不能用已观察年份代替预期全集。", + "独立官方年份目录已核对；固定旧快照差集不代表逐篇/track/摘要完整，也不代表当前主库覆盖。", "逐年核对公开拒稿/desk-rejected/withdrawn 政策与可获取记录，其他年份仍未核实。", "最终全库实体、投稿、决定、摘要和标签审计尚未完成。" - ] + ], + "edition_census": { + "source_url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:00:14.927398+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "6b0c53798d285af02e4425adfd01b51db9d0945e2dc7c92772daa517e8847843", + "evidence_file": "clear-editions-2026-11-08.json", + "cutoff_year": 2026, + "expected_years": [ + 2022, + 2023, + 2024, + 2025, + 2026 + ], + "excluded_future_years": [], + "missing_years_in_fixed_snapshot": [], + "not_yet_in_publisher_proceedings_index": [], + "scope": "Independent first-edition and all actual publisher-index conference/event-year labels, checked against each volume event heading. No annual interpolation, per-paper/track/abstract completeness or public rejection census. CoRL2026 is separately announced/upcoming and not listed in PMLR index; missing snapshot year does not prove missing published papers." + } }, { "acronym": "ACL", @@ -4021,7 +4039,7 @@ "source_record_counts": { "pmlr": 1488 }, - "historical_coverage": "pending_independent_census", + "historical_coverage": "conference_year_census_checked_tracks_and_records_pending", "policy_checks": [ { "year": 2021, @@ -4041,10 +4059,37 @@ } ], "remaining": [ - "按真实举办届次及独立官方目录核对历史年度和 track，不能用已观察年份代替预期全集。", + "独立官方年份目录已核对；固定旧快照差集不代表逐篇/track/摘要完整，也不代表当前主库覆盖。CoRL2026活动已公告尚未举办，PMLR目录未列该届，不能当作漏了已出版论文。", "逐年核对公开拒稿/desk-rejected/withdrawn 政策与可获取记录，其他年份仍未核实。", "最终全库实体、投稿、决定、摘要和标签审计尚未完成。" - ] + ], + "edition_census": { + "source_url": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/", + "checked_at": "2026-11-08T09:00:14.927398+00:00", + "source_html_sha256": "6b0c53798d285af02e4425adfd01b51db9d0945e2dc7c92772daa517e8847843", + "evidence_file": "corl-editions-2026-11-08.json", + "cutoff_year": 2026, + "expected_years": [ + 2017, + 2018, + 2019, + 2020, + 2021, + 2022, + 2023, + 2024, + 2025, + 2026 + ], + "excluded_future_years": [], + "missing_years_in_fixed_snapshot": [ + 2026 + ], + "not_yet_in_publisher_proceedings_index": [ + 2026 + ], + "scope": "Independent first-edition and all actual publisher-index conference/event-year labels, checked against each volume event heading. No annual interpolation, per-paper/track/abstract completeness or public rejection census. CoRL2026 is separately announced/upcoming and not listed in PMLR index; missing snapshot year does not prove missing published papers." + } }, { "acronym": "ICAPS",