Verify public ISMIR rejection and AIMC revision histories

This commit is contained in:
2026-11-20 01:57:48 +08:00
parent a570792f2b
commit ddc22a92ee
2 changed files with 103 additions and 0 deletions
+1
View File
@@ -72,6 +72,7 @@ PGSERVICEFILE=/etc/paper-atlas/pg_service.conf paper-atlas coverage \
## 优先缺口
- **ISMIR 2023–2024**:作者公开披露的两条拒稿已入生产库。2023 年稿与 AIMC 2024 的改题录用稿共用作品 ID,保留两次投稿与各自的题名和作者。2024 年稿保留为独立作品,另存拆分衍生论文的证据。两次拒稿的赛道和决定日期均未核实,覆盖仍为部分。 [入库与查询验收](ismir-author-public-decisions-2026-11-20.json)
- **UAI 2024–2026**:官方均允许作者选择公开拒稿,首份生产快照拒稿为零。原 notes 接口要求 Challenge 验证;新核验镜像的 2022–2025 年 902 个论坛来自录用子集,不能填补公开拒稿缺口。2024 年的元评审也不能直接转成最终决定,见 [2026-11-17 原始来源与回复结构核查](uai-public-negative-source-status-2026-11-17.md)。不能根据 PMLR 或镜像录用名单反推拒稿;政策参见 [2025 投稿指南](https://www.auai.org/uai2025/submission_instructions)、JSON 内其他年份官方证据。
- **EMNLP 2023**:官方允许公开 opt-in 拒稿,目前只导入 9 条。需继续核验实际公开全集。ARR 评审、conference commitment 与最终会议决定分开;[ARR 作者说明](https://aclrollingreview.org/authors) 明确其自愿捐赠数据与 EMNLP 2023 直接投稿发布的范围不同。
- **ICLR**:固定快照已观察 2017 与 2020–2026;快照之后,2013/2018/2019 的 1,654 条来源记录已完成独立 PostgreSQL 验收(报告时间 `2026-11-07T19:52:28.378Z`),不回写旧快照计数,也不据此宣称逐届全集已齐。快照中的 10,208 次 unknown 不等于 rejected,近期补采与冲突核对仍在进行;评审推荐不能当最终决定。
@@ -0,0 +1,102 @@
{
"status": "committed_and_readonly_verified",
"snapshot_at": "2026-11-19 17:57:02.66927+00",
"records": [
{
"paper_id": 3572581,
"source_record_id": 3824612,
"submission_id": 541155,
"decision_id": 580737,
"edition_id": 104119,
"venue": "AIMC",
"year": 2024,
"track": "main",
"status": "accepted",
"source": "aimc_proceedings",
"external_id": "2024/ej9b5mv1/release/2",
"title": "AI Music Studies: Preparing for the Coming Flood",
"evidence_url": "https://aimc2024.pubpub.org/pub/ej9b5mv1/release/2",
"decision_date": null,
"metadata": {
"official_proceedings": "https://aimc2024.pubpub.org/proceedings",
"proceedings_category": "Papers",
"deposit_url": "https://zenodo.org/records/15110181",
"published_date": "2024-08-29"
}
},
{
"paper_id": 3572581,
"source_record_id": 3824613,
"submission_id": 541156,
"decision_id": 580738,
"edition_id": 104120,
"venue": "ISMIR",
"year": 2023,
"track": "submission_unclassified",
"status": "rejected",
"source": "author_public_rejection",
"external_id": "ismir/2023/dagstuhl-24302-musaicology",
"title": "MusAIcology: AI Music and the Need for a New Kind of Music Studies",
"evidence_url": "https://drops.dagstuhl.de/storage/04dagstuhl-reports/volume14/issue07/24302/DagRep.14.7.115/DagRep.14.7.115.pdf",
"decision_date": null,
"metadata": {
"report_section": "3.19",
"report_page": 139,
"preprint": "https://osf.io/9pz4x",
"byline_registry": "https://cordis.europa.eu/project/id/864189/results",
"later_accepted_revision": "https://aimc2024.pubpub.org/pub/ej9b5mv1/release/2",
"relationship": "First author explicitly identifies the AIMC 2024 paper as the revised ISMIR 2023 manuscript."
}
},
{
"paper_id": 3572582,
"source_record_id": 3824614,
"submission_id": 541157,
"decision_id": 580739,
"edition_id": 104121,
"venue": "ISMIR",
"year": 2024,
"track": "submission_unclassified",
"status": "rejected",
"source": "author_public_rejection",
"external_id": "ismir/2024/dagstuhl-24302-ai-music-frontier",
"title": "AI Music: A New Frontier for Music Information Retrieval",
"evidence_url": "https://drops.dagstuhl.de/storage/04dagstuhl-reports/volume14/issue07/24302/DagRep.14.7.115/DagRep.14.7.115.pdf",
"decision_date": null,
"metadata": {
"report_section": "3.19",
"report_page": 139,
"corroboration": "https://www.speech.kth.se/publications/pdfs/cros_vila_l.pdf",
"corroboration_page": 8,
"derivative_publication_doi": "10.5334/tismir.254",
"relationship": "Lead author reports that the expanded manuscript was split into separate articles. The detection work is a derivative, not an acceptance of the original submission."
}
}
],
"run_ids": [
1968,
1969
],
"new_papers": 2,
"decision_counts": {
"accepted": 1,
"rejected": 2
},
"normal_query_outcomes": {
"cross_venue_acceptance": true,
"derivative_not_credited_as_original_acceptance": true
},
"abstract_status": "Not captured in this decision-evidence batch.",
"coverage_status": "partial",
"completeness_claim": false,
"preflight": {
"exact_normalized_title_matches": 0,
"stable_identifier_matches": 0,
"checked_before_mutation": true
},
"unresolved": [
"Original ISMIR submission identifiers, tracks and exact decision dates were not published in the reviewed sources.",
"Individual author disclosures do not establish the size or completeness of the conference-wide public decision list.",
"AIMC is recorded for the verified work’s publication history. No conference-wide AIMC coverage is implied."
]
}