Inventory early WWW proceedings and preserve source scope discrepancies
Metadata integrity checks / metadata (push) Successful in 1m45s

This commit is contained in:
2026-11-08 21:18:40 +08:00
parent 838731025c
commit ce5ace0c21
3 changed files with 282 additions and 3 deletions
+2
View File
@@ -184,3 +184,5 @@ ICAPS官方共同历史明确列出两个前身系列,现有DBLP映射只覆
这份基线不关闭长期目标:还需完成 43 个会议逐年公开决定核查、跨来源身份/标签规范化、全部导入后的全库去重与冲突/摘要/约束/查询审计,以及运维文档最终整理。
MM 2026 的[官方 CFP](https://2026.acmmm.org/site/cfp-guidelines.html)说明会后公开最终评审及适用的作者回复,但未明确包含全部被拒投稿。2026-11-08 对官方组的匿名 API 查询返回200,对该组 `venueid` 的投稿查询返回403;[证据](mm-editions-2026-11-08.json)保存查询、时间和响应哈希。公开拒稿可用性仍为 unknown,403不能作为零记录或不存在公开拒稿的证据。
WWW早期逐来源核查见 `www-early-proceedings-2026-11-08.json`:1995春季论文三目录均为38个相同条目ID,海报摘要53个条目与作者链接47个条目不齐;1994春季50个Title字段与主页49场报告说法待逐项核对。上述为源目录观察,不是已导入或全部录用数量;主会、海报、教程等继续独立核验。
@@ -0,0 +1,276 @@
{
"checked_at": "2026-11-08",
"status": "primary_source_inventory_complete_not_normalized_or_imported",
"sources": [
{
"url": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/proceedings/www1/index.html",
"resolved": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/proceedings/www1/index.html",
"http_status": 200,
"sha256": "dc0ca83f552c3bb89b5c8cf40a688e41874087a0ac29979720a53120938f818a",
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T13:11:50.509805+00:00",
"decoded_as": "utf-8"
},
{
"url": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/proceedings/www2/index.html",
"resolved": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/proceedings/www2/index.html",
"http_status": 200,
"sha256": "ead63295f45dc68bbd55e3c1f4f28f5fbaed0a1e902068a0e16073ab277a25cc",
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T13:11:52.335785+00:00",
"decoded_as": "utf-8"
},
{
"url": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/proceedings/www3/index.html",
"resolved": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/proceedings/www3/index.html",
"http_status": 200,
"sha256": "5a4bfa0e44d3723500ced8c5375bb1d5447838ab91d3c62cf21a3ac5fd533f74",
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T13:11:53.350674+00:00",
"decoded_as": "utf-8"
},
{
"url": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www3/proceedings/proceedings.html",
"resolved": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www3/proceedings/proceedings.html",
"http_status": 200,
"sha256": "93457641ea3291dc250af40c284f3c9f7df34830d383bc6e972249b7e5c50792",
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T13:11:54.408737+00:00",
"decoded_as": "utf-8"
},
{
"url": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www1/Proceedings.html",
"resolved": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www1/Proceedings.html",
"http_status": 200,
"sha256": "ffc8766e1771398988d4c0ef1c648510e4ab6c689a94b675a3e6f068ab88e20d",
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T13:11:55.626468+00:00",
"decoded_as": "utf-8"
},
{
"url": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www1/PrelimProcs.html",
"resolved": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www1/PrelimProcs.html",
"http_status": 200,
"sha256": "f2e0e0efcdd748059597a1d82bacd30901a5e7bf72b2d21df2307b79892ca616",
"bytes": 21649,
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T13:12:19.093459+00:00",
"decoded_as": "utf-8"
},
{
"url": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www2/Proceedings/WWW2_Proceedings.html",
"resolved": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www2/Proceedings/WWW2_Proceedings.html",
"http_status": 200,
"sha256": "62bcb038775cdffa50454037cbd0db60255bc52c190691adaab9a286e7c84c76",
"bytes": 3052,
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T13:12:18.071445+00:00",
"decoded_as": "utf-8"
},
{
"url": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www3/proceedings/papers/author.html",
"resolved": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www3/proceedings/papers/author.html",
"http_status": 200,
"sha256": "19aa53681f21b33e2f126ea4e050a5843cf27b55989fde6b53fca1a5875ecb23",
"bytes": 17760,
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T13:12:18.257055+00:00",
"decoded_as": "iso-8859-1"
},
{
"url": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www3/proceedings/papers/session.html",
"resolved": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www3/proceedings/papers/session.html",
"http_status": 200,
"sha256": "df9d09c330c6eb30c1138e63175bc2079c417db4a77e8577367d25edf29949a9",
"bytes": 5207,
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T13:12:19.798816+00:00",
"decoded_as": "utf-8"
},
{
"url": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www3/proceedings/papers/abstract.html",
"resolved": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www3/proceedings/papers/abstract.html",
"http_status": 200,
"sha256": "dd6861a4f9905c690ae59beea8dc2e7214d6349c001f5a6101f17088753d0f2b",
"bytes": 47315,
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T13:12:20.090797+00:00",
"decoded_as": "iso-8859-1"
},
{
"url": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www3/proceedings/posters/author.html",
"resolved": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www3/proceedings/posters/author.html",
"http_status": 200,
"sha256": "f0d20819e675874b67527675eb96c633117f412790daa1477cb7da17ac0ae679",
"bytes": 17561,
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T13:12:20.189771+00:00",
"decoded_as": "utf-8"
},
{
"url": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www3/proceedings/posters/abstract.html",
"resolved": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www3/proceedings/posters/abstract.html",
"http_status": 200,
"sha256": "bb1cbbc0391a6168947763e8aa2edc61a0e2a48634dda421b686250c68d693c0",
"bytes": 47202,
"checked_at": "2026-11-08T13:12:21.727587+00:00",
"decoded_as": "utf-8"
}
],
"events": [
{
"year": 1994,
"event_key": "www-1994-spring",
"source_url": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www1/PrelimProcs.html",
"title_field_occurrences": 50,
"homepage_formal_presentations_claim": 49,
"count_discrepancy": "50 explicit Title fields vs homepage49 formal presentations; per-entry audit required, neither number is an accepted-paper total.",
"track_scope": "Some keyword lines explicitly say BUSINESS TRACK?; preserve raw scope, not all regularmain.",
"abstracts": "Not on this HTML list; PDF files not fetched.",
"journal_boundary": "Official publication note says journal specialissue contains selected fullpapers plus abstracts ofotherpapers; not a full conference acceptance listing."
},
{
"year": 1994,
"event_key": "www-1994-fall",
"source_url": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www2/Proceedings/WWW2_Proceedings.html",
"top_level_categories": 34,
"scope": "Categories include Birds ofaFeather, DevelopersDay, tutorials, products as well as papers. No individualpaper count inferred from34categories; unlinked title does notmeanReject."
},
{
"year": 1995,
"event_key": "www-1995-spring",
"source_url": "https://archives.iw3c2.org/www3/proceedings/proceedings.html",
"papers": {
"author_index_link_occurrences": 90,
"distinct_author_index_entry_ids": 38,
"session_index_entry_ids": 38,
"abstract_index_entry_ids": 38,
"all_three_id_sets_equal": true,
"entry_ids": [
"44",
"46",
"47",
"48",
"49",
"50",
"51",
"52",
"54",
"55",
"58",
"59",
"60",
"62",
"65",
"67",
"68",
"70",
"72",
"75",
"76",
"77",
"78",
"79",
"80",
"82",
"84",
"86",
"87",
"88",
"89",
"90",
"94",
"95",
"97",
"100",
"104",
"105"
],
"literal_url_sets_equal": false,
"url_discrepancy": {
"entry_id": "80",
"author_and_session": "80/userpatterns/UserPatterns.Paper4.formatted.html",
"abstract": "80/userpatterns/ UserPatterns.Paper4.formatted.html",
"action": "Retain raw malformed href; use exact same event/entry ID corroborated byboth otherindexes, neverfuzzytitle-only join."
}
},
"posters": {
"author_index_link_occurrences": 83,
"distinct_linked_author_index_entry_ids": 47,
"abstract_index_entry_ids": 53,
"abstract_only_entry_ids": [
"37",
"41",
"47",
"50",
"55",
"59"
],
"scope": "53 linked poster abstractentries are not 53 mainpapers; authorindexhasplaceholder#links andsuspectperson/place strings, so missinglinks ornames requireper-entry verification.",
"entry_ids": [
"01",
"03",
"04",
"05",
"06",
"07",
"08",
"09",
"13",
"14",
"15",
"16",
"17",
"18",
"19",
"20",
"21",
"22",
"23",
"24",
"26",
"27",
"28",
"29",
"30",
"31",
"32",
"33",
"34",
"35",
"36",
"37",
"38",
"40",
"41",
"42",
"43",
"44",
"45",
"46",
"47",
"48",
"50",
"51",
"52",
"53",
"54",
"55",
"56",
"57",
"58",
"59",
"60"
]
},
"separate_not_fetched": [
"Tutorial notes",
"Workshop proceedings",
"Developers Day notes"
]
}
],
"production_boundary": {
"existing_www1995_fall_edition_id": 1212,
"existing_fall_submissions": 59,
"new_source_rows_imported": 0,
"source_record_ids_assigned": false,
"no_rejected_decision_acquired": true,
"no_pdf_downloaded": true
},
"next_actions": [
"Implementmaintainedcollectorwithsourcecaching,exactevent/trackidentity,sourceevidenceandparserfixtures;build/testonlyremoteapprovedrunner.",
"ResolveWWW1count/scopeandWWW2category-per-itemboundariesbeforeacceptedmainassignment.",
"NormalizeWWW3papers/postersindependently,verifyabstractsauthorsandmalformedhrefhandling,preflightcurrentPGidentitiesbeforeimport.",
"Completeproductioneventmigrationindependentacceptance;do notreimportexisting59Fallrows."
]
}
+4 -3
View File
@@ -306,10 +306,10 @@
"1995": 2
},
"blocking_model_gap": {
"status": "must_resolve_before_same_year_event_import",
"status": "PR30and31_remote_verified_production_upgrade_running_not_yet_accepted",
"code_evidence": "paper_atlas/db/schema.sql UNIQUE(venue_id,year,track), also mirrored by PostgreSQL schema",
"problem": "Two main events in one year cannot be distinguished by the current edition uniqueness. The1995observedyear does not prove both events imported.",
"next_action": "Read existing1995submission/source volume identifiers; implement distinct event identity preserving IDs/track, with migration+PGtests, before importing1994/1995. Do not invent fake tracks or overwrite dates to bypass uniqueness."
"next_action": "Trackexistingpaper-atlas-event-identity-upgrade-v1 invocationf2dacabc640144c9b1550ba77400fb22; independentlyverifyafterterminal. Do not rerunolddataimports. Newsourceinventoryisnotanimport."
},
"scope": "35explicitactualevents1994–2026in33years:1994and1995eachhavetwoevents. Official2024historylists33eventrows1994–2024, serieshomepageadds2025/2026. Future2027/2028excluded. Sourceeventkeysarecensusidentifiers,notdatabaseIDsorverifiedcrosssourcealiases. RenamedTheWebConferencefrom2018, ACM/SIGWEBfrom2022; preserveoriginalWWWnames. Workshops/companion/industry/researchtracksandOpenReviewpoliciesseparate.",
"existing_event_identity_preflight": {
@@ -327,5 +327,6 @@
"booktitle": "WWW (Fall)",
"dblp_volume": "db/conf/www/www1995f.html",
"next_action": "Preserveexisting1212and59histories; implementdistinctsamevenue/yearmaineventidentitybeforeaddingSpring1995orboth1994events. Noautomaticdeletion/reimport."
}
},
"early_proceedings_source_inventory": "www-early-proceedings-2026-11-08.json"
}