From c347671d842ac8962d819b8cb8408caeaa91e79a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Codex Bot Date: Thu, 19 Nov 2026 22:41:53 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] Verify public AISTATS rejections and preserve CARE submission history --- ...ts-public-negative-sources-2026-11-19.json | 466 ++++++++++++++++++ ...tats-public-negative-sources-2026-11-19.md | 13 + 2 files changed, 479 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/coverage/aistats-public-negative-sources-2026-11-19.json create mode 100644 docs/coverage/aistats-public-negative-sources-2026-11-19.md diff --git a/docs/coverage/aistats-public-negative-sources-2026-11-19.json b/docs/coverage/aistats-public-negative-sources-2026-11-19.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..549046f --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/coverage/aistats-public-negative-sources-2026-11-19.json @@ -0,0 +1,466 @@ +{ + "scope": { + "venue": "AISTATS", + "years": [ + 2020, + 2026 + ], + "snapshot_at": "2026-11-19 14:39:59.323132+00" + }, + "primary_sources": { + "aistats2025_official_list": "https://aistats.org/aistats2025/", + "aistats2026_submission_faq": "https://virtual.aistats.org/Conferences/2026/SubmissionFAQ", + "care_coauthor_disclosure": "https://namburisrinath.github.io/researchjourney.html", + "care_later_publication": "https://proceedings.mlr.press/v306/zhao26aq.html", + "vixra2023_author_document": "https://vixra.org/pdf/2312.0138v1.pdf" + }, + "mirror_audit": [ + { + "source": "papercopilot", + "year": 2020, + "url": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/papercopilot/paperlists/2a8ffb27f88fe34adcd6f58b3d04007246fa4e75/aistats/aistats2020.json", + "sha256": "c0a9461238d5210fd650c45a192555a19125e62e60209730949dd4ce71e63708", + "git_blob_sha1": "eedfff6689226f66526ca63d6d6fe0fdb53321a8", + "rows": 423, + "status_labels": { + "Poster": 423 + }, + "venue_labels": { + "None": 423 + }, + "decision_labels": {}, + "root_fields": { + "id": 423, + "title": 423, + "site": 423, + "author": 423, + "abstract": 423, + "bibtex": 423, + "pdf": 423, + "supp": 423, + "pdf_size": 423, + "gs_citation": 423, + "gs_cited_by_link": 423, + "gs_version_total": 423, + "aff": 423, + "aff_domain": 423, + "email": 423, + "github": 423, + "project": 423, + "author_num": 423, + "track": 423, + "status": 423, + "aff_unique_index": 234, + "aff_unique_norm": 234, + "aff_unique_dep": 234, + "aff_unique_url": 234, + "aff_unique_abbr": 234, + "aff_campus_unique_index": 227, + "aff_campus_unique": 227, + "aff_country_unique_index": 233, + "aff_country_unique": 233 + } + }, + { + "source": "papercopilot", + "year": 2021, + "url": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/papercopilot/paperlists/2a8ffb27f88fe34adcd6f58b3d04007246fa4e75/aistats/aistats2021.json", + "sha256": "809fc14034b7d323a032bc80a0401709797cfbcdef41226715db07c65915a8f8", + "git_blob_sha1": "e975652efa69827da0866b093ed600dc73f0e09b", + "rows": 455, + "status_labels": { + "Poster": 455 + }, + "venue_labels": { + "None": 455 + }, + "decision_labels": {}, + "root_fields": { + "id": 455, + "title": 455, + "site": 455, + "author": 455, + "abstract": 455, + "bibtex": 455, + "pdf": 455, + "supp": 455, + "pdf_size": 455, + "gs_citation": 455, + "gs_cited_by_link": 455, + "gs_version_total": 455, + "aff": 455, + "aff_domain": 455, + "email": 455, + "github": 455, + "project": 455, + "author_num": 455, + "track": 455, + "status": 455, + "aff_unique_index": 319, + "aff_unique_norm": 319, + "aff_unique_dep": 319, + "aff_unique_url": 319, + "aff_unique_abbr": 319, + "aff_campus_unique_index": 308, + "aff_campus_unique": 308, + "aff_country_unique_index": 319, + "aff_country_unique": 319 + } + }, + { + "source": "papercopilot", + "year": 2022, + "url": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/papercopilot/paperlists/2a8ffb27f88fe34adcd6f58b3d04007246fa4e75/aistats/aistats2022.json", + "sha256": "6d261117ab7c456091cc061334c099a85cfa4c210e04a82a02e9328a2b79dcbf", + "git_blob_sha1": "2b6007291acd3baec169473cb8150f72272f7a5c", + "rows": 492, + "status_labels": { + "Poster": 492 + }, + "venue_labels": { + "None": 492 + }, + "decision_labels": {}, + "root_fields": { + "id": 492, + "title": 492, + "site": 492, + "author": 492, + "abstract": 492, + "bibtex": 492, + "pdf": 492, + "supp": 492, + "pdf_size": 492, + "gs_citation": 492, + "gs_cited_by_link": 492, + "gs_version_total": 492, + "aff": 492, + "aff_domain": 492, + "email": 492, + "github": 492, + "project": 492, + "author_num": 492, + "track": 492, + "status": 492, + "aff_unique_index": 287, + "aff_unique_norm": 287, + "aff_unique_dep": 287, + "aff_unique_url": 287, + "aff_unique_abbr": 287, + "aff_campus_unique_index": 277, + "aff_campus_unique": 277, + "aff_country_unique_index": 287, + "aff_country_unique": 287 + } + }, + { + "source": "papercopilot", + "year": 2023, + "url": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/papercopilot/paperlists/2a8ffb27f88fe34adcd6f58b3d04007246fa4e75/aistats/aistats2023.json", + "sha256": "78d32b0c0c124ac39d13967985aaafadc2699e338f0398526a985021181d5c39", + "git_blob_sha1": "926ff2c82f568579ea8cab4cd60de998ed23bbec", + "rows": 496, + "status_labels": { + "Poster": 496 + }, + "venue_labels": { + "None": 496 + }, + "decision_labels": {}, + "root_fields": { + "id": 496, + "title": 496, + "site": 496, + "author": 496, + "abstract": 496, + "bibtex": 496, + "pdf": 496, + "supp": 496, + "pdf_size": 496, + "gs_citation": 496, + "gs_cited_by_link": 496, + "gs_version_total": 496, + "aff": 496, + "aff_domain": 496, + "email": 496, + "github": 496, + "project": 496, + "author_num": 496, + "track": 496, + "status": 496, + "aff_unique_index": 284, + "aff_unique_norm": 284, + "aff_unique_dep": 284, + "aff_unique_url": 284, + "aff_unique_abbr": 284, + "aff_campus_unique_index": 279, + "aff_campus_unique": 279, + "aff_country_unique_index": 284, + "aff_country_unique": 284 + } + }, + { + "source": "papercopilot", + "year": 2024, + "url": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/papercopilot/paperlists/2a8ffb27f88fe34adcd6f58b3d04007246fa4e75/aistats/aistats2024.json", + "sha256": "77247da91cfa2c2fae3f41462032d198f3cce35fdf30f56d8c6bdb0ee375c2a0", + "git_blob_sha1": "6944c78f61bd85680598bd42a06c7894b33eae7c", + "rows": 547, + "status_labels": { + "Poster": 547 + }, + "venue_labels": { + "None": 547 + }, + "decision_labels": {}, + "root_fields": { + "id": 547, + "title": 547, + "site": 547, + "author": 547, + "abstract": 547, + "bibtex": 547, + "pdf": 547, + "supp": 547, + "pdf_size": 547, + "gs_citation": 547, + "gs_cited_by_link": 547, + "gs_version_total": 547, + "aff": 547, + "aff_domain": 547, + "email": 547, + "github": 547, + "project": 547, + "author_num": 547, + "track": 547, + "status": 547, + "aff_unique_index": 307, + "aff_unique_norm": 307, + "aff_unique_dep": 307, + "aff_unique_url": 307, + "aff_unique_abbr": 307, + "aff_campus_unique_index": 299, + "aff_campus_unique": 299, + "aff_country_unique_index": 307, + "aff_country_unique": 307 + } + }, + { + "source": "papercopilot", + "year": 2025, + "url": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/papercopilot/paperlists/2a8ffb27f88fe34adcd6f58b3d04007246fa4e75/aistats/aistats2025.json", + "sha256": "e285034a93273b2ee4d4bd58911c2448eec7d9e9a4ade592980668df21c84e15", + "git_blob_sha1": "3602a6d9f2b3e1e99a10813307513eb2105f4bca", + "rows": 583, + "status_labels": { + "Poster": 546, + "Oral": 37 + }, + "venue_labels": { + "None": 583 + }, + "decision_labels": {}, + "root_fields": { + "id": 583, + "title": 583, + "track": 583, + "status": 583, + "tldr": 583, + "abstract": 583, + "keywords": 583, + "primary_area": 583, + "supplementary_material": 583, + "author": 583, + "authorids": 583, + "gender": 583, + "homepage": 583, + "dblp": 583, + "google_scholar": 583, + "orcid": 583, + "linkedin": 583, + "or_profile": 583, + "aff": 583, + "aff_domain": 583, + "position": 583, + "bibtex": 583, + "github": 583, + "project": 583, + "reviewers": 583, + "site": 583, + "pdf_size": 583, + "wc_review": 583, + "replies_avg": 583, + "authors#_avg": 583, + "wc_review_avg": 583, + "gs_citation": 583, + "gs_cited_by_link": 583, + "gs_version_total": 583, + "aff_unique_index": 581, + "aff_unique_norm": 581, + "aff_unique_dep": 581, + "aff_unique_url": 581, + "aff_unique_abbr": 581, + "aff_campus_unique_index": 575, + "aff_campus_unique": 575, + "aff_country_unique_index": 581, + "aff_country_unique": 581 + } + }, + { + "source": "latkes_raw", + "year": 2025, + "url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/latkes/ai-research-index-iclr-openreview/resolve/4c9e09931a7814d7500630ffd064b74f1c01bcf3/raw/aistats2025.jsonl", + "sha256": "65e5e42f772e559ac63ad55005e5ae126e182dd14952891942eb450fe4645387", + "git_blob_sha1": "e4242dffb92c2639f8499ca5999b16e46d8b0eb1", + "rows": 583, + "reply_count": 0, + "status_labels": { + "None": 583 + }, + "venue_labels": { + "AISTATS 2025 Oral": 37, + "AISTATS 2025 Poster": 546 + }, + "decision_labels": {}, + "root_fields": { + "note": 583, + "replies": 583 + } + }, + { + "source": "latkes_raw", + "year": 2026, + "url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/latkes/ai-research-index-iclr-openreview/resolve/4c9e09931a7814d7500630ffd064b74f1c01bcf3/raw/aistats2026.jsonl", + "sha256": "e30457bf858028185488526b0f72cc308e0b6e068e8ac8a4d303c55ee15557f8", + "git_blob_sha1": "803726c24220c66d157ae0167584c1363db2707f", + "rows": 587, + "reply_count": 0, + "status_labels": { + "None": 587 + }, + "venue_labels": { + "AISTATS 2026 Poster": 522, + "AISTATS 2026 Spotlight": 55, + "AISTATS 2026 Oral": 10 + }, + "decision_labels": {}, + "root_fields": { + "note": 587, + "replies": 587 + } + } + ], + "mirror_rows_new_paper_level_negative_decisions": 0, + "author_evidence": { + "status": "committed_and_readonly_verified", + "snapshot_at": "2026-11-19 14:39:59.323132+00", + "records": [ + { + "paper_id": 2125232, + "source_record_id": 3819106, + "submission_id": 535748, + "decision_id": 575330, + "venue": "AISTATS", + "year": 2026, + "author_evidence_url": "https://namburisrinath.github.io/researchjourney.html", + "source_external_id": "aistats:2026:arxiv:2603.00039" + }, + { + "paper_id": 2125232, + "source_record_id": 3819107, + "submission_id": 535749, + "decision_id": 575331, + "venue": "NeurIPS", + "year": 2025, + "author_evidence_url": "https://namburisrinath.github.io/researchjourney.html", + "source_external_id": "neurips:2025:arxiv:2603.00039" + }, + { + "paper_id": 3569512, + "source_record_id": 3819108, + "submission_id": 535750, + "decision_id": 575332, + "venue": "AISTATS", + "year": 2023, + "author_evidence_url": "https://vixra.org/pdf/2312.0138v1.pdf", + "source_external_id": "aistats:2023:vixra:2312.0138:117" + } + ], + "new_papers": 1, + "prior_icml_acceptance_preserved": true, + "author_source_sha256": "cd1d141e303d93b6b1bda430ebc7f4b68b1f66f816a13b0d2fb1b67dda0ea2d2", + "vixra_pdf_sha256": "636ea245f772c8ac6e17f0793f9b1f1d286906836589419df797fd4ccf669f80", + "preflight_sha256": "74e080e1dc1d9a60533aed011e7cceb4dfd166c56f6892e7949b1859ba46dd85" + }, + "source_limitations": { + "aistats2023": { + "figure": 10, + "reported_submission_number": "117", + "notification_local_date": "2023-01-20", + "notification_timezone": null, + "candidate_work_provisional": true + }, + "care": { + "aistats_openreview_locator": "OFVC9JuODh", + "neurips_openreview_locator": "1kuJqy1ZRy", + "original_forum_decision_verified": false, + "original_tracks_verified": false + } + }, + "normal_query": { + "verified": [ + { + "paper_id": 2125232, + "decision_id": 575330, + "publication_outcome": "accepted" + }, + { + "paper_id": 2125232, + "decision_id": 575331, + "publication_outcome": "accepted" + }, + { + "paper_id": 3569512, + "decision_id": 575332, + "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance" + } + ], + "active_aistats_negative_counts": [ + { + "year": 2023, + "status": "rejected", + "observations": 1, + "submissions": 1 + }, + { + "year": 2026, + "status": "rejected", + "observations": 1, + "submissions": 1 + } + ], + "readonly": true + }, + "receipts": { + "preflight": { + "filename": "pa-aistats-care-preflight-v2.json", + "sha256": "74e080e1dc1d9a60533aed011e7cceb4dfd166c56f6892e7949b1859ba46dd85" + }, + "mirrors": { + "filename": "pa-aistats-mirrors-v1.json", + "sha256": "94ebf9ea7b63aede7b2ce2c186c5042c70b247810135dc45497cbd1f1104532d" + }, + "raw_replies": { + "filename": "pa-aistats-raw-replies-v1.json", + "sha256": "949ef1442c53103a737c83f5d6632f0dada3bd95781fc58404a63bc8a91236b4" + }, + "write": { + "filename": "pa-aistats-author-accepted-v3.json", + "sha256": "ccf19b66ae0458fbd7eed644409c19351b535a260bd70349a92345c45657c06b" + }, + "normal_query": { + "filename": "pa-aistats-author-query-v1.json", + "sha256": "3c2d9905b14e1b2cf5056e47727346f16ed09283009bf8607237504c1b47bf94" + } + } +} diff --git a/docs/coverage/aistats-public-negative-sources-2026-11-19.md b/docs/coverage/aistats-public-negative-sources-2026-11-19.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ba32a74 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/coverage/aistats-public-negative-sources-2026-11-19.md @@ -0,0 +1,13 @@ +# AISTATS 2020–2026 公开拒稿来源核查 + +PostgreSQL 已入库并独立查询核验两届 AISTATS 的逐篇拒稿。2023、2026 各有一条。2020–2022、2024–2025 的当前查询未返回逐篇拒稿、初筛拒稿或撤回记录,现有证据范围仍需补查。 [逐条验收与来源哈希](aistats-public-negative-sources-2026-11-19.json) + +- **AISTATS 2026**。CARE 的共同作者明确叙述了 NeurIPS 2025 和 AISTATS 2026 两次拒稿,以及修改后在 ICML 2026 录用。两次拒稿分别入库,同一篇论文原有的 ICML 录用及出版来源保留。两次拒稿的 OpenReview 链接作为来源线索,具体赛道和决定日期留空。 [共同作者记录](https://namburisrinath.github.io/researchjourney.html) · [ICML 出版目录](https://proceedings.mlr.press/v306/zhao26aq.html) +- **AISTATS 2023**。作者公开的文档在图 10 保留了稿件 117 的拒稿通知。入库使用通知里的原投稿标题,保留作者发布页面与文档哈希。通知上的日期缺少时区,原日期保存在来源元数据。作品纳入最终去重复查。 [作者公开的拒稿通知](https://vixra.org/pdf/2312.0138v1.pdf) + +| 固定版本镜像 | 实际读到的范围 | 逐篇负面决定 | +| --- | --- | ---: | +| Paper Copilot | 2020–2025 六个文件分别有 423、455、492、496、547、583 条,均为 Poster 或 Oral 标签 | 0 | +| Latkes 的 OpenReview 原始格式档案 | 2025 年 583 条,2026 年 587 条。根记录均是录用展示类别,两年外层回复列表均为空 | 0 | + +2025 官网发布的是录用清单。镜像页面上的总投稿数与镜像逐篇文件各有口径。名单之外的稿件没有据此添加拒稿。 [2025 官网](https://aistats.org/aistats2025/) · [Paper Copilot 固定版本](https://github.com/papercopilot/paperlists/tree/2a8ffb27f88fe34adcd6f58b3d04007246fa4e75/aistats) · [Latkes 固定版本](https://huggingface.co/datasets/latkes/ai-research-index-iclr-openreview/tree/4c9e09931a7814d7500630ffd064b74f1c01bcf3)