From b62b39e629bc5366784b8d69a09c0e76020a4bb4 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Codex Bot Date: Thu, 19 Nov 2026 02:15:28 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] Verify public COLM and MLSys rejection histories --- ...sclosed-negative-decisions-2026-11-19.json | 327 ++++++++++++++++++ ...c-decision-source-boundaries-2026-11-18.md | 15 + 2 files changed, 342 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/coverage/author-disclosed-negative-decisions-2026-11-19.json diff --git a/docs/coverage/author-disclosed-negative-decisions-2026-11-19.json b/docs/coverage/author-disclosed-negative-decisions-2026-11-19.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1c63ced --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/coverage/author-disclosed-negative-decisions-2026-11-19.json @@ -0,0 +1,327 @@ +{ + "database": "foundry_data/research", + "api_probe_sha256": "7df95bef70c842511a0c06b7678e1a90e8cf472aa9ec13bd6c273c5cb7b10963", + "official_api_probes": [ + { + "venue": "UAI", + "year": 2026, + "track": "main", + "policy_url": "https://www.auai.org/uai2026/submission_instructions", + "group_id": "auai.org/UAI/2026/Conference", + "group_response": { + "url": "https://api2.openreview.net/groups?id=auai.org%2FUAI%2F2026%2FConference", + "observed_at": "2026-11-18T18:09:26.785604+00:00", + "http_status": 200, + "bytes": 11127, + "sha256": "35e06545ecd2b95953fc1e2e0563d0f25caa42b2533832126fe21212cc3c9be8" + }, + "declaration": { + "rejected_venue_id": "auai.org/UAI/2026/Conference/Rejected_Submission", + "desk_rejected_venue_id": "auai.org/UAI/2026/Conference/Desk_Rejected_Submission", + "withdrawn_venue_id": "auai.org/UAI/2026/Conference/Withdrawn_Submission", + "submissions_public": null, + "withdrawn_submissions_public": null, + "desk_rejected_submissions_public": null, + "submission_name": "Submission" + }, + "notes": { + "rejected": { + "url": "https://api2.openreview.net/notes?content.venueid=auai.org%2FUAI%2F2026%2FConference%2FRejected_Submission&limit=1", + "observed_at": "2026-11-18T18:09:27.842066+00:00", + "http_status": 403, + "bytes": 352, + "sha256": "2b0ef4794d083b8434733851abf8cb06cc1ebd16dd343ee257518eebfa67da31" + }, + "desk_rejected": { + "state": "unqueried_after_access_response", + "prior_http_status": 403 + }, + "withdrawn": { + "state": "unqueried_after_access_response", + "prior_http_status": 403 + } + } + }, + { + "venue": "MLSys", + "year": 2024, + "track": "main", + "policy_url": "https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2024/CallForPapers", + "group_id": "MLSys.org/2024/Conference", + "group_response": { + "url": "https://api2.openreview.net/groups?id=MLSys.org%2F2024%2FConference", + "observed_at": "2026-11-18T18:09:28.795905+00:00", + "http_status": 200, + "bytes": 7902, + "sha256": "19ef980ef1a60803e6b9c36a0b388ffa631d115206e5d2776834a13e4f8f0fe3" + }, + "declaration": { + "rejected_venue_id": "MLSys.org/2024/Conference/Rejected_Submission", + "desk_rejected_venue_id": "MLSys.org/2024/Conference/Desk_Rejected_Submission", + "withdrawn_venue_id": "MLSys.org/2024/Conference/Withdrawn_Submission", + "submissions_public": null, + "withdrawn_submissions_public": null, + "desk_rejected_submissions_public": null, + "submission_name": "Submission" + }, + "notes": { + "rejected": { + "url": "https://api2.openreview.net/notes?content.venueid=MLSys.org%2F2024%2FConference%2FRejected_Submission&limit=1", + "observed_at": "2026-11-18T18:09:29.861305+00:00", + "http_status": 403, + "bytes": 345, + "sha256": "e66bf28ce4f38b44ef1927fcd6fa4fe027ed8d98b738419e31f749e21ddc0aa7" + }, + "desk_rejected": { + "state": "unqueried_after_access_response", + "prior_http_status": 403 + }, + "withdrawn": { + "state": "unqueried_after_access_response", + "prior_http_status": 403 + } + } + }, + { + "venue": "MLSys", + "year": 2025, + "track": "main", + "policy_url": "https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2025/CallForPapers", + "group_id": "MLSys.org/2025/Conference", + "group_response": { + "url": "https://api2.openreview.net/groups?id=MLSys.org%2F2025%2FConference", + "observed_at": "2026-11-18T18:09:30.888731+00:00", + "http_status": 200, + "bytes": 8682, + "sha256": "e66d7457eb993d0518d1cc09d2bf9a5319975c3bb2155038ff6e53b70c625c9d" + }, + "declaration": { + "rejected_venue_id": "MLSys.org/2025/Conference/Rejected_Submission", + "desk_rejected_venue_id": "MLSys.org/2025/Conference/Desk_Rejected_Submission", + "withdrawn_venue_id": "MLSys.org/2025/Conference/Withdrawn_Submission", + "submissions_public": null, + "withdrawn_submissions_public": null, + "desk_rejected_submissions_public": null, + "submission_name": "Submission" + }, + "notes": { + "rejected": { + "url": "https://api2.openreview.net/notes?content.venueid=MLSys.org%2F2025%2FConference%2FRejected_Submission&limit=1", + "observed_at": "2026-11-18T18:09:31.982660+00:00", + "http_status": 403, + "bytes": 345, + "sha256": "b1ede889fe4dca20b376dfd59dcfb1f1d4dd8fa796be2aefeb9af770f1a9c99e" + }, + "desk_rejected": { + "state": "unqueried_after_access_response", + "prior_http_status": 403 + }, + "withdrawn": { + "state": "unqueried_after_access_response", + "prior_http_status": 403 + } + } + } + ], + "production_snapshot_at": "2026-11-18 18:14:07.064902+00", + "transaction_receipt_sha256": "f5bc6871be0312f43c3b6c249fa2ba0263dbc2cec1f6d64b6364ae2c06df94f4", + "normal_query_sha256": "ddc89e0bda78cd24dbbb563b9ce1628ee8fa93d643d9b2029013c41aa202d2e9", + "records": [ + { + "paper_id": 2013403, + "source": "author_public_rejection", + "source_record_id": 3816466, + "external_id": "colm:2024:arxiv:2402.13904", + "submission_id": 533155, + "decision_id": 572706, + "venue": "COLM", + "year": 2024, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "status": "rejected" + }, + { + "paper_id": 2403684, + "source": "author_public_rejection", + "source_record_id": 3816467, + "external_id": "mlsys:2025:arxiv:2506.04165", + "submission_id": 533156, + "decision_id": 572707, + "venue": "MLSys", + "year": 2025, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "status": "rejected" + }, + { + "paper_id": 2403684, + "source": "tmlr_publication", + "source_record_id": 3816468, + "external_id": "izqZ1Crpjz", + "submission_id": 533157, + "decision_id": 572708, + "venue": "TMLR", + "year": 2026, + "track": "main", + "status": "accepted" + } + ], + "query_verified_histories": { + "2013403": [ + { + "venue": "COLM", + "year": 2024, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "submission_id": 533155, + "decision_id": 572706, + "status": "rejected", + "sources": [ + { + "name": "author_public_rejection", + "external_id": "colm:2024:arxiv:2402.13904", + "source_decision_id": "" + } + ], + "decision_date": null + }, + { + "venue": "AAAI", + "year": 2025, + "track": "main", + "submission_id": 186215, + "decision_id": 187321, + "status": "accepted", + "sources": [ + { + "name": "dblp", + "external_id": "conf/aaai/0001SM0ETASC25", + "source_decision_id": "" + } + ], + "decision_date": null + } + ], + "2403684": [ + { + "venue": "MLSys", + "year": 2025, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "submission_id": 533156, + "decision_id": 572707, + "status": "rejected", + "sources": [ + { + "name": "author_public_rejection", + "external_id": "mlsys:2025:arxiv:2506.04165", + "source_decision_id": "" + } + ], + "decision_date": null + }, + { + "venue": "TMLR", + "year": 2026, + "track": "main", + "submission_id": 533157, + "decision_id": 572708, + "status": "accepted", + "sources": [ + { + "name": "tmlr_publication", + "external_id": "izqZ1Crpjz", + "source_decision_id": "" + } + ], + "decision_date": null + } + ] + }, + "venue_year_rejected_submissions": [ + { + "venue": "COLM", + "year": 2024, + "rejected_submissions": 1 + }, + { + "venue": "MLSys", + "year": 2025, + "rejected_submissions": 1 + } + ], + "new_papers": 0, + "rejection_disclosures": [ + { + "paper_id": 2013403, + "venue": "COLM", + "year": 2024, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "url": "https://yanaiela.github.io/502.html", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_disclosure", + "source_receipt": { + "url": "https://yanaiela.github.io/502.html", + "sha256": "6db35cabdf28e01e46b23dfa2bef18f49d6e32c8b6cdb61d65e2cfea62e7da84", + "bytes": 31030, + "observed_at": "2026-11-18T18:10:42.876467+00:00" + }, + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_track": null, + "original_title_and_abstract_verified": false, + "decision_date_verified": false, + "observed_version_is_original_submission": false + } + }, + { + "paper_id": 2403684, + "venue": "MLSys", + "year": 2025, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.04165v2", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_disclosure", + "source_receipt": { + "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.04165v2", + "sha256": "d32fe8ee67aabb263c063b310d8947903cc34ab6a5084c7e85554b3c4bf934db", + "bytes": 43020, + "observed_at": "2026-11-18T18:10:42.842601+00:00" + }, + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_track": null, + "original_title_and_abstract_verified": false, + "decision_date_verified": false, + "observed_version_is_original_submission": false + } + } + ], + "additional_publication_evidence": { + "evidence_role": "official_journal_publication", + "source_receipt": { + "url": "https://jmlr.org/tmlr/papers/", + "sha256": "6b5d79d89d8f957afac6dae0b99bc172a0c28de5833225ca83f7df2053cff0aa", + "bytes": 3662717, + "observed_at": "2026-11-18T18:10:46.279409+00:00" + }, + "author_arxiv_v3_receipt": { + "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.04165v3", + "sha256": "8674ce63a76db28ee7e3e62bfaa04efdd0a145b1983f5c4c317d5bf159d57d6b", + "bytes": 42681, + "observed_at": "2026-11-18T18:10:42.793225+00:00" + }, + "publication_month": "2026-05", + "official_forum": "https://openreview.net/forum?id=izqZ1Crpjz", + "official_publication_and_arxiv_author_name_difference": "Journal spells first author Yashas Samaga B L. Both arXiv versions spell Yashas Samaga; other authors match in order." + }, + "prior_publication_evidence": { + "url": "https://ojs.aaai.org/index.php/AAAI/article/view/34120", + "doi": "10.1609/aaai.v39i18.34120", + "primary_page_verified_via_web": true, + "local_snapshot_saved": false + }, + "untitled_author_disclosures": { + "candidate_paper_identity_verified": false, + "publication_years": [ + 2025, + 2026 + ], + "source": "https://nbalepur.github.io/" + }, + "coverage_completeness_claimed": false +} diff --git a/docs/coverage/public-decision-source-boundaries-2026-11-18.md b/docs/coverage/public-decision-source-boundaries-2026-11-18.md index 4bbcb21..3422dff 100644 --- a/docs/coverage/public-decision-source-boundaries-2026-11-18.md +++ b/docs/coverage/public-decision-source-boundaries-2026-11-18.md @@ -45,3 +45,18 @@ KDD 2026 二月周期的 Applied Data Science 目录明确标了一条撤回并 | 撤稿 | 11,966 | 11,966 | 11,945 | 固定的 278 个会议年度中,16 个有以上至少一种决定观察,覆盖 EMNLP、ICLR、ICML、KDD 和 NeurIPS。其余 262 个需要继续核查逐篇公开来源。自 2020 年起的已记录拒稿中,555 篇作品在另一会议的后续年度也有录用观察。同年度的先后顺序需另核决定日期。 + +### COLM、MLSys、UAI 和 ACM Multimedia 补查 + +COLM 2024 官方征稿说明,会议不会发布被拒稿件、讨论或元数据。2025 和 2026 两届明确把撤稿纳入这一范围。逐篇保留有明确来源的作者披露。 [COLM 2024](https://colmweb.org/2024/cfp.html) · [COLM 2025](https://colmweb.org/2025/cfp.html) · [COLM 2026](https://colm.cc/Conferences/2026/CallForPapers) + +MLSys 2024 和 2025 的官方征稿分别链接各届 OpenReview 主会。UAI 2026 官网说明拒稿默认私密,作者可选择公开。三届 OpenReview 配置均可匿名读取,按配置发出的限一条拒稿查询均返回 403,公开子集大小仍未知。初筛拒稿及撤稿入口记为未查询。 [MLSys 2024](https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2024/CallForPapers) · [MLSys 2025](https://mlsys.org/Conferences/2025/CallForPapers) · [UAI 2026](https://www.auai.org/uai2026/submission_instructions) + +ACM MM 2022 的公开评审政策针对录用口头报告,而且需要参与方同意。2023 的 SIGMM 年报也把公开范围表述为经同意的录用稿评审。2026 技术征稿描述流程结束后公开最终评审与适用的作者回复,逐篇公开拒稿范围仍未核实。2022 的复现伴随论文有单独的政策,明确不披露被拒稿件。 [2022 公开评审](https://2022.acmmm.org/open-review/) · [SIGMM 年报](https://www.acm.org/binaries/content/assets/about/annual-reports/appendix-d-fy24-sig-annual-reports.pdf) · [2026 技术征稿](https://2026.acmmm.org/site/cfp-guidelines.html) · [2022 复现伴随论文](https://2022.acmmm.org/call-for-reproducibility/) + +### 两条可关联的作者拒稿披露 + +- *Calibrating Large Language Models with Sample Consistency* 的共同作者在同一条作品记录中明确标注 COLM 2024 拒稿,并链接对应 arXiv 预印本。正式 DOI 对应库内已有 AAAI 2025 主会录用,原决定和来源已复核。 [作者披露](https://yanaiela.github.io/502.html) · [AAAI 正式论文](https://ojs.aaai.org/index.php/AAAI/article/view/34120) +- *A Faster Generalized Two-Stage Approximate Top-K* 的 arXiv v2 说明其早期版本被 MLSys 2025 拒稿。同一 arXiv 编号的 v3 标注 TMLR 录用,期刊目录亦列出该文及其 OpenReview 论坛。 [arXiv v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.04165v2) · [arXiv v3](https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.04165v3) · [TMLR 发表目录](https://jmlr.org/tmlr/papers/) + +两条拒稿均作为作者公开披露入库。原始投稿编号、稿件和具体轨道未公开,决定日期保持空值,来源时间记录在观测字段。生产事务沿用两个论文 ID,新增 2 条拒稿和 1 条期刊录用。提交后以正常论文查询核验两篇的完整历史。COLM 2024 与 MLSys 2025 各查到 1 条拒稿投稿。另有未给出论文标题的 COLM 2025 和 2026 作者披露,留在待核记录。 [逐条核验与 API 回执](author-disclosed-negative-decisions-2026-11-19.json)