From 73bfedff60cc294e172b6a3be8ec273d86e0c1be Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Codex Bot Date: Fri, 20 Nov 2026 02:27:54 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] Review remaining arXiv public decision candidates --- ...ecision-screening-followup-2026-11-20.json | 957 ++++++++++++++++++ ...c-decision-source-boundaries-2026-11-18.md | 4 + 2 files changed, 961 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/coverage/arxiv-public-decision-screening-followup-2026-11-20.json diff --git a/docs/coverage/arxiv-public-decision-screening-followup-2026-11-20.json b/docs/coverage/arxiv-public-decision-screening-followup-2026-11-20.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e24a2ca --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/coverage/arxiv-public-decision-screening-followup-2026-11-20.json @@ -0,0 +1,957 @@ +{ + "status": "committed_and_readonly_verified", + "plan_sha256": "2a2934696d49094e6032c06e9d15c7a1a5e85ae8c55ef008e4d31c089bdcb21a", + "snapshot_at": "2026-11-19 18:26:28.708347+00", + "records": [ + { + "paper_id": 1496642, + "source": "author_public_rejection", + "source_record_id": 3824687, + "external_id": "neurips:2021:arxiv:2107.00451", + "submission_id": 541230, + "decision_id": 580812, + "evidence_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2107.00451", + "title": "VideoLightFormer: Lightweight Action Recognition using Transformers", + "venue": "NeurIPS", + "year": 2021, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "status": "rejected", + "event_key": "", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_arxiv_comment", + "source_metadata_sha256": "736ce6897fbfbfe9bc6b22645d4ea53f4aa3f006cb8bd4e449326c1f49053752", + "arxiv_id": "2107.00451", + "explicit_decision_in_public_version": null, + "source_title_role": "Public preprint title; original submission title is not independently verified.", + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_decision_date_verified": false, + "public_full_decision_expected_count": null, + "scope": "The withdrawn arXiv deposit is separate from the explicitly reported NeurIPS rejection." + } + }, + { + "paper_id": 1553782, + "source": "author_public_rejection", + "source_record_id": 3824688, + "external_id": "emnlp:2020:arxiv:2110.13505", + "submission_id": 541231, + "decision_id": 580813, + "evidence_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2110.13505", + "title": "Part & Whole Extraction: Towards A Deep Understanding of Quantitative Facts for Percentages in Text", + "venue": "EMNLP", + "year": 2020, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "status": "rejected", + "event_key": "", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_arxiv_comment", + "source_metadata_sha256": "55407a6d9ffe17816c2d85f2a8bedad26b1b5a41ca1f1459cc7fcb8c3eb1c72a", + "arxiv_id": "2110.13505", + "explicit_decision_in_public_version": null, + "source_title_role": "Public preprint title; original submission title is not independently verified.", + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_decision_date_verified": false, + "public_full_decision_expected_count": null + } + }, + { + "paper_id": 1554712, + "source": "author_public_rejection", + "source_record_id": 3824689, + "external_id": "icassp:2022:arxiv:2110.14437", + "submission_id": 541232, + "decision_id": 580814, + "evidence_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2110.14437", + "title": "Exploring single-song autoencoding schemes for audio-based music structure analysis", + "venue": "ICASSP", + "year": 2022, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "status": "rejected", + "event_key": "", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_arxiv_comment", + "source_metadata_sha256": "1faf83fd24c69f24b641942410d0cf85003c2c4e04593185e00eb574a29df97a", + "arxiv_id": "2110.14437", + "explicit_decision_in_public_version": null, + "source_title_role": "Public preprint title; original submission title is not independently verified.", + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_decision_date_verified": false, + "public_full_decision_expected_count": null, + "extended_version": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2202.04981" + } + }, + { + "paper_id": 1662399, + "source": "author_public_rejection", + "source_record_id": 3824690, + "external_id": "icml:2022:arxiv:2205.15921", + "submission_id": 541233, + "decision_id": 580815, + "evidence_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.15921", + "title": "Online Meta-Learning in Adversarial Multi-Armed Bandits", + "venue": "ICML", + "year": 2022, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "status": "rejected", + "event_key": "", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_arxiv_comment", + "source_metadata_sha256": "3f4111149d758396c7a5413f1be4930e42a6ecf3732021b0866c7fdb55f308b1", + "arxiv_id": "2205.15921", + "explicit_decision_in_public_version": null, + "source_title_role": "Public preprint title; original submission title is not independently verified.", + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_decision_date_verified": false, + "public_full_decision_expected_count": null, + "scope": "The authors identify an earlier version as rejected. A stated submission elsewhere does not provide that venue’s decision." + } + }, + { + "paper_id": 1686420, + "source": "author_public_rejection", + "source_record_id": 3824691, + "external_id": "neurips:2021:arxiv:2207.08466", + "submission_id": 541234, + "decision_id": 580816, + "evidence_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2207.08466", + "title": "What does Transformer learn about source code?", + "venue": "NeurIPS", + "year": 2021, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "status": "rejected", + "event_key": "", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_arxiv_comment", + "source_metadata_sha256": "1d74e865ce1d1986a559a2847e0db628f7e5c55504f0c075821f4472003c651c", + "arxiv_id": "2207.08466", + "explicit_decision_in_public_version": null, + "source_title_role": "Public preprint title; original submission title is not independently verified.", + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_decision_date_verified": false, + "public_full_decision_expected_count": null + } + }, + { + "paper_id": 1703593, + "source": "author_public_rejection", + "source_record_id": 3824692, + "external_id": "ecml-pkdd:2021:arxiv:2208.10836", + "submission_id": 541235, + "decision_id": 580817, + "evidence_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.10836", + "title": "Evaluating Machine Unlearning via Epistemic Uncertainty", + "venue": "ECML-PKDD", + "year": 2021, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "status": "rejected", + "event_key": "", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_arxiv_comment", + "source_metadata_sha256": "7e79abbcf779e68fdb51678aea0ee7aaeaa241f6dac3700fe58c6c6ab353aad9", + "arxiv_id": "2208.10836", + "explicit_decision_in_public_version": null, + "source_title_role": "Public preprint title; original submission title is not independently verified.", + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_decision_date_verified": false, + "public_full_decision_expected_count": null + } + }, + { + "paper_id": 1834533, + "source": "author_public_rejection", + "source_record_id": 3824693, + "external_id": "neurips:2021:arxiv:2304.14511", + "submission_id": 541236, + "decision_id": 580818, + "evidence_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14511", + "title": "Visual Referential Games Further the Emergence of Disentangled Representations", + "venue": "NeurIPS", + "year": 2021, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "status": "rejected", + "event_key": "", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_arxiv_comment", + "source_metadata_sha256": "9fc2ae10440ec19b69fa08fddb9a57562a3ad1707849d03a00b7365faf1c4d2b", + "arxiv_id": "2304.14511", + "explicit_decision_in_public_version": null, + "source_title_role": "Public preprint title; original submission title is not independently verified.", + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_decision_date_verified": false, + "public_full_decision_expected_count": null + } + }, + { + "paper_id": 1894588, + "source": "author_public_rejection", + "source_record_id": 3824694, + "external_id": "acl:2023:arxiv:2308.04756", + "submission_id": 541237, + "decision_id": 580819, + "evidence_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04756", + "title": "Building Interpretable and Reliable Open Information Retriever for New Domains Overnight", + "venue": "ACL", + "year": 2023, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "status": "rejected", + "event_key": "", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_arxiv_comment", + "source_metadata_sha256": "afc5880619e718a5e3b7d3c5fb14bb328a692622225459e101ef60f6110e53b0", + "arxiv_id": "2308.04756", + "explicit_decision_in_public_version": null, + "source_title_role": "Public preprint title; original submission title is not independently verified.", + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_decision_date_verified": false, + "public_full_decision_expected_count": null + } + }, + { + "paper_id": 1929101, + "source": "author_public_rejection", + "source_record_id": 3824695, + "external_id": "icml:2024:arxiv:2310.04925", + "submission_id": 541238, + "decision_id": 580820, + "evidence_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2310.04925", + "title": "Crystal-GFN: sampling crystals with desirable properties and constraints", + "venue": "ICML", + "year": 2024, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "status": "rejected", + "event_key": "", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_arxiv_comment", + "source_metadata_sha256": "dba8866d1720a3cf9ec47cafc92688ad2fa2891d5063b124f9ab83637aad8edd", + "arxiv_id": "2310.04925", + "explicit_decision_in_public_version": null, + "source_title_role": "Public preprint title; original submission title is not independently verified.", + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_decision_date_verified": false, + "public_full_decision_expected_count": null + } + }, + { + "paper_id": 1990265, + "source": "author_public_rejection", + "source_record_id": 3824696, + "external_id": "iclr:2024:arxiv:2401.08830", + "submission_id": 541239, + "decision_id": 580821, + "evidence_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2401.08830", + "title": "Stochastic Subnetwork Annealing: A Regularization Technique for Fine Tuning Pruned Subnetworks", + "venue": "ICLR", + "year": 2024, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "status": "rejected", + "event_key": "", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_arxiv_comment", + "source_metadata_sha256": "e505a7117119a72f6055f27010690fd1262bddce06f3d3b826cf1eb5fd41aea3", + "arxiv_id": "2401.08830", + "explicit_decision_in_public_version": null, + "source_title_role": "Public preprint title; original submission title is not independently verified.", + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_decision_date_verified": false, + "public_full_decision_expected_count": null + } + }, + { + "paper_id": 2058422, + "source": "author_public_rejection", + "source_record_id": 3824697, + "external_id": "emnlp:2023:arxiv:2404.19154", + "submission_id": 541240, + "decision_id": 580822, + "evidence_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2404.19154", + "title": "RTF: Region-based Table Filling Method for Relational Triple Extraction", + "venue": "EMNLP", + "year": 2023, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "status": "rejected", + "event_key": "", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_arxiv_comment", + "source_metadata_sha256": "385b8bad2c0f5e0b5651ce8b2db25ee997ba2c0350cc28e9ea123db43e9bd995", + "arxiv_id": "2404.19154", + "explicit_decision_in_public_version": null, + "source_title_role": "Public preprint title; original submission title is not independently verified.", + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_decision_date_verified": false, + "public_full_decision_expected_count": null + } + }, + { + "paper_id": 2068323, + "source": "author_public_rejection", + "source_record_id": 3824698, + "external_id": "icml:2024:arxiv:2405.09305", + "submission_id": 541241, + "decision_id": 580823, + "evidence_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2405.09305", + "title": "Gradient Boosted Filters For Signal Processing", + "venue": "ICML", + "year": 2024, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "status": "rejected", + "event_key": "", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_arxiv_comment", + "source_metadata_sha256": "af8f3f06da012e6c1c850be536bcd79c0e2ba3146c4f9973a58b01f9b1b12680", + "arxiv_id": "2405.09305", + "explicit_decision_in_public_version": null, + "source_title_role": "Public preprint title; original submission title is not independently verified.", + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_decision_date_verified": false, + "public_full_decision_expected_count": null + } + }, + { + "paper_id": 2078725, + "source": "author_public_rejection", + "source_record_id": 3824699, + "external_id": "neurips:2023:arxiv:2405.19743", + "submission_id": 541242, + "decision_id": 580824, + "evidence_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19743", + "title": "May the Dance be with You: Dance Generation Framework for Non-Humanoids", + "venue": "NeurIPS", + "year": 2023, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "status": "rejected", + "event_key": "", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_arxiv_comment", + "source_metadata_sha256": "a6b3c84ade90f67ae3eb755fce3a742cd16a6e4145c2c77d89ad4743726a2869", + "arxiv_id": "2405.19743", + "explicit_decision_in_public_version": null, + "source_title_role": "Public preprint title; original submission title is not independently verified.", + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_decision_date_verified": false, + "public_full_decision_expected_count": null + } + }, + { + "paper_id": 1537069, + "source": "author_public_decision", + "source_record_id": 3824700, + "external_id": "acl:2021:arxiv:2109.12105", + "submission_id": 541243, + "decision_id": 580825, + "evidence_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2109.12105", + "title": "Faithful Target Attribute Prediction in Neural Machine Translation", + "venue": "ACL", + "year": 2021, + "track": "findings", + "status": "withdrawn", + "event_key": "", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_arxiv_comment", + "source_metadata_sha256": "ef9d84af33f9688a0fd75b86af1b2ad285fdcbe7d54d9b974a237d759610ab6a", + "arxiv_id": "2109.12105", + "explicit_decision_in_public_version": null, + "source_title_role": "Public preprint title; original submission title is not independently verified.", + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_decision_date_verified": false, + "public_full_decision_expected_count": null + } + }, + { + "paper_id": 2613611, + "source": "author_public_decision", + "source_record_id": 3824701, + "external_id": "cvpr:2026:arxiv:2603.04848", + "submission_id": 541244, + "decision_id": 580826, + "evidence_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.04848", + "title": "Hyperbolic Multiview Pretraining for Robotic Manipulation", + "venue": "CVPR", + "year": 2026, + "track": "submission_unclassified", + "status": "withdrawn", + "event_key": "", + "metadata": { + "evidence_role": "author_arxiv_comment", + "source_metadata_sha256": "80aa39bfe36002f4afd652cb9e8d7421d019ddb8be9162a8d6477434879c5caa", + "arxiv_id": "2603.04848", + "explicit_decision_in_public_version": null, + "source_title_role": "Public preprint title; original submission title is not independently verified.", + "original_submission_id": null, + "original_decision_date_verified": false, + "public_full_decision_expected_count": null, + "scope": "The authors report CVPR withdrawal. The Findings recommendation does not establish acceptance or a separate Findings submission." + } + } + ], + "new_papers": 0, + "existing_history_preserved": true, + "previously_recorded": [], + "screening_receipt": "arxiv-public-decision-screening-2026-11-20.json", + "normal_query": [ + { + "paper_id": 1496642, + "new_decisions_verified": 1, + "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance", + "known_acceptances": [] + }, + { + "paper_id": 1537069, + "new_decisions_verified": 1, + "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance", + "known_acceptances": [] + }, + { + "paper_id": 1553782, + "new_decisions_verified": 1, + "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance", + "known_acceptances": [] + }, + { + "paper_id": 1554712, + "new_decisions_verified": 1, + "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance", + "known_acceptances": [] + }, + { + "paper_id": 1662399, + "new_decisions_verified": 1, + "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance", + "known_acceptances": [] + }, + { + "paper_id": 1686420, + "new_decisions_verified": 1, + "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance", + "known_acceptances": [] + }, + { + "paper_id": 1703593, + "new_decisions_verified": 1, + "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance", + "known_acceptances": [] + }, + { + "paper_id": 1834533, + "new_decisions_verified": 1, + "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance", + "known_acceptances": [] + }, + { + "paper_id": 1894588, + "new_decisions_verified": 1, + "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance", + "known_acceptances": [] + }, + { + "paper_id": 1929101, + "new_decisions_verified": 1, + "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance", + "known_acceptances": [] + }, + { + "paper_id": 1990265, + "new_decisions_verified": 1, + "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance", + "known_acceptances": [] + }, + { + "paper_id": 2058422, + "new_decisions_verified": 1, + "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance", + "known_acceptances": [] + }, + { + "paper_id": 2068323, + "new_decisions_verified": 1, + "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance", + "known_acceptances": [] + }, + { + "paper_id": 2078725, + "new_decisions_verified": 1, + "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance", + "known_acceptances": [] + }, + { + "paper_id": 2613611, + "new_decisions_verified": 1, + "publication_outcome": "no_known_acceptance", + "known_acceptances": [] + } + ], + "counts_by_status": { + "rejected": 13, + "withdrawn": 2 + }, + "candidate_dispositions": [ + { + "arxiv_id": "2005.00152", + "paper_id": 1282258, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "ijcai" + ], + "status": "decision_scope_uncertain", + "metadata_sha256": "20fd1055c0839652903e7dd67063e8883be5b9105fbcccc5b71b941d99c615ed", + "assessment": "Temporary withdrawal lacks a venue target. The IJCAI 2020 acceptance already exists." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2005.00153", + "paper_id": 1282259, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "ijcai" + ], + "status": "decision_scope_uncertain", + "metadata_sha256": "d6bc6dde332d8b5d119d51b617500b01fd478fb824c5ce144b48d871bf5a6b26", + "assessment": "Temporary withdrawal lacks a venue target. The IJCAI 2020 acceptance already exists." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2006.01554", + "paper_id": 1298365, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "acl" + ], + "status": "conflicting_history", + "metadata_sha256": "c831167642d263d34436f1e1540d41582004d28b868013b2f055f20ea34c041c", + "assessment": "Author says ACL 2020 withdrawal. Existing ACL 2020 acceptance needs comparison with formal publication and original attempt." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2006.03719", + "paper_id": 1300530, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "emnlp" + ], + "status": "decision_scope_uncertain", + "metadata_sha256": "cc848ea8435edd2812c0773e2fab44af38ee231097ff80005ba9a4bc2e1e76b5", + "assessment": "EMNLP withdrawal mentioned without edition. Passing reviews does not by itself identify an acceptance." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2006.08594", + "paper_id": 1305401, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "www" + ], + "status": "no_conference_decision", + "metadata_sha256": "056bf0793190613fb5a6b694beab89a4c2974b6fc783585b26788f6c62fc6985", + "assessment": "arXiv administrator removed a preprint version. Conference acronym was a keyword coincidence." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2006.09046", + "paper_id": 1305853, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "icml" + ], + "status": "identity_review", + "metadata_sha256": "b8e4c1384bf5d6854a04196c1b1819599d80a207e045ee08316689cd5fadb5c3", + "assessment": "Two exact-title work IDs, 1133255 and 1305853. Retain ICML 2020 author rejection evidence for identity review." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2010.12673", + "paper_id": 1371254, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "icassp", + "interspeech" + ], + "status": "sequential_history", + "metadata_sha256": "7b6e3e830d1070c41fc30ab3ab3010a98bdaf190d219b09b4af0e5348e8e486d", + "assessment": "Author explicitly reports ICASSP 2021 acceptance then withdrawal. Existing Interspeech 2021 acceptance needs cross-venue history linking." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2104.01083", + "paper_id": 1450705, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "eacl" + ], + "status": "paired_publication", + "metadata_sha256": "b59b40ba58ff7bae4a3b47c2e5840978d9ed543c6123e33c82ad52acbb83f966", + "assessment": "EACL 2021 rejection and official NoDaLiDa 2021 publication identified; verify identifiers and both decisions together." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2107.00451", + "paper_id": 1496642, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "neurips" + ], + "status": "verified_and_imported", + "metadata_sha256": "736ce6897fbfbfe9bc6b22645d4ea53f4aa3f006cb8bd4e449326c1f49053752", + "assessment": "Verified against the public arXiv comment, same-work history checked, result passed normal query." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2109.06151", + "paper_id": 1315091, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "www" + ], + "status": "no_conference_decision", + "metadata_sha256": "99f581a37f1a0d48bd5adfbd1e2b924d50a3df70a73a306b6511a256cd0176d3", + "assessment": "Duplicate arXiv deposit was withdrawn and linked to 2007.01289." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2109.12105", + "paper_id": 1537069, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "acl" + ], + "status": "verified_and_imported", + "metadata_sha256": "ef9d84af33f9688a0fd75b86af1b2ad285fdcbe7d54d9b974a237d759610ab6a", + "assessment": "Verified against the public arXiv comment, same-work history checked, result passed normal query." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2110.13505", + "paper_id": 1553782, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "emnlp" + ], + "status": "verified_and_imported", + "metadata_sha256": "55407a6d9ffe17816c2d85f2a8bedad26b1b5a41ca1f1459cc7fcb8c3eb1c72a", + "assessment": "Verified against the public arXiv comment, same-work history checked, result passed normal query." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2110.14437", + "paper_id": 1554712, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "icassp" + ], + "status": "verified_and_imported", + "metadata_sha256": "1faf83fd24c69f24b641942410d0cf85003c2c4e04593185e00eb574a29df97a", + "assessment": "Verified against the public arXiv comment, same-work history checked, result passed normal query." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2203.14553", + "paper_id": 1629496, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "interspeech" + ], + "status": "paired_publication", + "metadata_sha256": "55c9e92a164534cf1cb48f8d29d32aff4e51677c1173be745adbc2d32253e226", + "assessment": "Interspeech 2022 rejection and revised IEEE SLT publication identified; verify publisher DOI and relationship." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2205.15921", + "paper_id": 1662399, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "icml", + "neurips" + ], + "status": "verified_and_imported", + "metadata_sha256": "3f4111149d758396c7a5413f1be4930e42a6ecf3732021b0866c7fdb55f308b1", + "assessment": "Verified against the public arXiv comment, same-work history checked, result passed normal query." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2207.08466", + "paper_id": 1686420, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "neurips" + ], + "status": "verified_and_imported", + "metadata_sha256": "1d74e865ce1d1986a559a2847e0db628f7e5c55504f0c075821f4472003c651c", + "assessment": "Verified against the public arXiv comment, same-work history checked, result passed normal query." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2208.03486", + "paper_id": 1696249, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "eccv" + ], + "status": "decision_scope_uncertain", + "metadata_sha256": "8ea54f61ea56e8c5ab42a45126cca41414e013fb440c8994e7784c6543bea47e", + "assessment": "Author names ECCV 2023, but the official ECCV archive shows biennial even-year editions." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2208.10836", + "paper_id": 1703593, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "ecml" + ], + "status": "verified_and_imported", + "metadata_sha256": "7e79abbcf779e68fdb51678aea0ee7aaeaa241f6dac3700fe58c6c6ab353aad9", + "assessment": "Verified against the public arXiv comment, same-work history checked, result passed normal query." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2304.13416", + "paper_id": 1833438, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "ijcai", + "miccai" + ], + "status": "decision_scope_uncertain", + "metadata_sha256": "3704da1503703cf71e511c4668434549b10485086a9b1f4e140a73c16e8373ba", + "assessment": "MICCAI rejection lacks a year. Resolve the original edition and the IJCAI workshop independently." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2304.14511", + "paper_id": 1834533, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "neurips" + ], + "status": "verified_and_imported", + "metadata_sha256": "9fc2ae10440ec19b69fa08fddb9a57562a3ad1707849d03a00b7365faf1c4d2b", + "assessment": "Verified against the public arXiv comment, same-work history checked, result passed normal query." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2308.04756", + "paper_id": 1894588, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "acl" + ], + "status": "verified_and_imported", + "metadata_sha256": "afc5880619e718a5e3b7d3c5fb14bb328a692622225459e101ef60f6110e53b0", + "assessment": "Verified against the public arXiv comment, same-work history checked, result passed normal query." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2310.04925", + "paper_id": 1929101, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "icml" + ], + "status": "verified_and_imported", + "metadata_sha256": "dba8866d1720a3cf9ec47cafc92688ad2fa2891d5063b124f9ab83637aad8edd", + "assessment": "Verified against the public arXiv comment, same-work history checked, result passed normal query." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2401.08830", + "paper_id": 1990265, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "iclr" + ], + "status": "verified_and_imported", + "metadata_sha256": "e505a7117119a72f6055f27010690fd1262bddce06f3d3b826cf1eb5fd41aea3", + "assessment": "Verified against the public arXiv comment, same-work history checked, result passed normal query." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2402.19170", + "paper_id": 2018663, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "coling" + ], + "status": "decision_scope_uncertain", + "metadata_sha256": "8b00883c636709b0d9082394abe6fd41d5e2e6c52fbbd3501a88a61fc4e2eb5a", + "assessment": "LREC-COLING rejection confirmed as author statement; verify canonical joint edition label and any same-work source before import." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2403.17704", + "paper_id": 2036657, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "clear" + ], + "status": "no_conference_decision", + "metadata_sha256": "38f5018456f7f2c27798041714dc6736fb9f294e731a883f9baac1b29c3c9617", + "assessment": "Withdrawal refers to the current preprint without identifying a conference." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2404.19154", + "paper_id": 2058422, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "emnlp" + ], + "status": "verified_and_imported", + "metadata_sha256": "385b8bad2c0f5e0b5651ce8b2db25ee997ba2c0350cc28e9ea123db43e9bd995", + "assessment": "Verified against the public arXiv comment, same-work history checked, result passed normal query." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2405.09305", + "paper_id": 2068323, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "icml" + ], + "status": "verified_and_imported", + "metadata_sha256": "af8f3f06da012e6c1c850be536bcd79c0e2ba3146c4f9973a58b01f9b1b12680", + "assessment": "Verified against the public arXiv comment, same-work history checked, result passed normal query." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2405.19743", + "paper_id": 2078725, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "neurips" + ], + "status": "verified_and_imported", + "metadata_sha256": "a6b3c84ade90f67ae3eb755fce3a742cd16a6e4145c2c77d89ad4743726a2869", + "assessment": "Verified against the public arXiv comment, same-work history checked, result passed normal query." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2406.11730", + "paper_id": 2091745, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "iclr" + ], + "status": "identity_review", + "metadata_sha256": "8273f415086ceeab51bdc9625280b2d08eaf69617a57f0c948fb34ab8b8f7ed6", + "assessment": "ICLR 2025 rejection explicitly cites OpenReview uVMZgtw2pf; compare the forum binding and original decision source." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2410.05353", + "paper_id": 2237494, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "iclr" + ], + "status": "no_conference_decision", + "metadata_sha256": "8d911110e04924922f9b3daefcd7d0b5f5052475f6e7846489e11bcbcf6454bc", + "assessment": "Third-party survey corrects an erroneous claim; says the published ICLR work was not withdrawn." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2410.08207", + "paper_id": 2240057, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "cvpr", + "iclr" + ], + "status": "sequential_history", + "metadata_sha256": "af551c1fe2c743e8145172e47b81eac8ad816e00ec0782a3d00f1158ad58eccd", + "assessment": "Author reports CVPR acceptance then desk rejection and an earlier ICLR withdrawal. Verify all venue attempts and chronology." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2410.12606", + "paper_id": 2244017, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "neurips" + ], + "status": "no_conference_decision", + "metadata_sha256": "1753e3b0021f0347edd2f022d7eaefab1d9e1876503ca46525804d0c00ce7a55", + "assessment": "The withdrawn item was a duplicate arXiv version, though a NeurIPS workshop is mentioned." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2502.00969", + "paper_id": 2135601, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "sigdial" + ], + "status": "sequential_history", + "metadata_sha256": "2eb0e6519794238dd231e4706d655324e93571910b7d34ea53f70906e857cdc9", + "assessment": "SIGDIAL 2024 acceptance then withdrawal; existing ACL 2025 publication needs preservation." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2506.11679", + "paper_id": 2410594, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "clear" + ], + "status": "no_conference_decision", + "metadata_sha256": "06f3b7e4b2234c479e8666ff7ba1238aa642a2f232a48c41c2e65b0444fb8be9", + "assessment": "Author asks to withdraw the arXiv submission; no named conference result." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2508.20614", + "paper_id": 2465460, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "neurips" + ], + "status": "no_conference_decision", + "metadata_sha256": "81a344d098e5ac0b75f75d7697366b8bcf34c4155c15eb31824782e1270f15c5", + "assessment": "Withdrawal refers to duplicate preprint 2512.14308v2; NeurIPS workshop is prior presentation context." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2509.23373", + "paper_id": 2488878, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "neurips" + ], + "status": "conflicting_history", + "metadata_sha256": "a1dbccc73e866035267890d65ba818d90f93dd03649f0019818225b9d3ecb61b", + "assessment": "Stored comments say not accepted at NeurIPS 2025; current author-corrected version and proceedings listing require separate review." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2510.08779", + "paper_id": 2499763, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "icaps" + ], + "status": "sequential_history", + "metadata_sha256": "a274acfe837c8f54740df0150fef3e8a2e9e724ee77493e6778695ccf5b5d2c3", + "assessment": "ICAPS 2025 workshop acceptance and withdrawal before presentation; verify workshop event identity and store both observations." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2512.01707", + "paper_id": 2542098, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "cvpr" + ], + "status": "sequential_history", + "metadata_sha256": "08509cce354929a5346dcd1b910aebb263b6ffebadd09e58569609c194cc3a71", + "assessment": "Author reports CVPR 2026 acceptance followed by desk rejection at camera-ready. Verify submission chronology and proceedings." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2602.16786", + "paper_id": 2601999, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "clear" + ], + "status": "no_conference_decision", + "metadata_sha256": "f98d478bd2223028123964dc72bd577f0b7f7f56039974645aa6159153af0a42", + "assessment": "Preprint withdrawal and generic referee feedback do not name a venue." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2603.04848", + "paper_id": 2613611, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "cvpr" + ], + "status": "verified_and_imported", + "metadata_sha256": "80aa39bfe36002f4afd652cb9e8d7421d019ddb8be9162a8d6477434879c5caa", + "assessment": "Verified against the public arXiv comment, same-work history checked, result passed normal query." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2603.07819", + "paper_id": 2616462, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "cvpr" + ], + "status": "sequential_history", + "metadata_sha256": "448f6073547f7b28cf8e430d369279ab9a13d27bcde9e11e1aac43c715149ecb", + "assessment": "CVPR Vision for Agriculture workshop acceptance then withdrawal, with workshop event identity to be verified." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2605.09492", + "paper_id": 2673707, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "acl" + ], + "status": "decision_scope_uncertain", + "metadata_sha256": "9737a2f0644db16b56f20d0db70142c7b804d40898ff525f3c82379b440328f4", + "assessment": "ACL format indicates formatting only. No named withdrawal venue or year." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2608.20065", + "paper_id": 2774302, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "clear" + ], + "status": "no_conference_decision", + "metadata_sha256": "2a19d9deff60e2eb54207f82a4b1ea26bed42e3e2fb39f28198fdf7ceeebaa78", + "assessment": "Withdrawn arXiv deposit superseded by arXiv 2609.20800." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2608.29850", + "paper_id": 2783678, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "recsys" + ], + "status": "sequential_history", + "metadata_sha256": "8e2d35d584a3a09135ec81dc7dec3dd0f0849874b27d3fed2d8637b3b31ea111", + "assessment": "WWW 2026 short-paper acceptance and withdrawal followed by RecSys workshop acceptance; verify each event and preserve chronological decisions." + }, + { + "arxiv_id": "2609.30151", + "paper_id": 2814303, + "venue_name_tokens": [ + "cikm" + ], + "status": "no_conference_decision", + "metadata_sha256": "4822a0ce298fdbe447b39e4cd0a1b2805dbd714d7a5d49b5ba03b8d0ea2cd2e7", + "assessment": "Rejection is a research topic, while conference comment attests a workshop acceptance." + } + ], + "disposition_counts": { + "decision_scope_uncertain": 7, + "conflicting_history": 2, + "no_conference_decision": 10, + "identity_review": 2, + "sequential_history": 7, + "paired_publication": 2, + "verified_and_imported": 15 + }, + "followup_cases_pending": 20, + "additional_primary_sources": { + "2104.01083": "https://aclanthology.org/2021.nodalida-main.31/", + "2203.14553": "https://yamagishilab.jp/publication/investigating-active-learning-based-training-data-selection-for-speech-spoofing-countermeasure/", + "2208.03486": "https://eccv2024.ecva.net/Conferences/2024" + } +} diff --git a/docs/coverage/public-decision-source-boundaries-2026-11-18.md b/docs/coverage/public-decision-source-boundaries-2026-11-18.md index cccb097..2819917 100644 --- a/docs/coverage/public-decision-source-boundaries-2026-11-18.md +++ b/docs/coverage/public-decision-source-boundaries-2026-11-18.md @@ -152,3 +152,7 @@ Olivier Jeunen 公开说明其关于利用策略重叠降低 A/B 测试方差的 两篇论文保留后续正式录用。《Self-Discriminative Modeling for Anomalous Graph Detection》从 NeurIPS 2023 拒稿到 ICML 2025 发表。《Non-contrastive sentence representations via self-supervision》从 EMNLP 2023 拒稿到 NAACL 2024 Findings 发表。 [ICML 正式稿](https://proceedings.mlr.press/v267/cai25k.html) · [NAACL 正式稿](https://aclanthology.org/2024.findings-naacl.266/) 剩余 54 条会议词候选中,5 条已有对应决定,4 条涉及 2020 年以前的投稿并保留作历史线索,45 条仍需人工区分明确投稿决定、撤下 arXiv 稿件、版本替代和术语误命中。 [逐条恢复清单](arxiv-public-decision-screening-2026-11-20.json) + +### arXiv 候选逐条处置 + +上一批剩余 45 条已逐条分流。由 arXiv 作者原文核实的 13 条拒稿和 2 条会议撤稿写入了已有论文,均通过生产只读核验和正常查询。其中 ACL 2021 撤稿明确属于 Findings。CVPR 2026 仅披露撤稿与 Findings 推荐,推荐未计作录用。另有 10 条属于预印本撤下、作品替代或术语误命中,未形成会议负面记录。剩余 20 条保留了需要解决的具体证据问题,包括同题作品、届次不明、与既有决定的冲突以及先录用后撤稿的顺序。 [ACL Findings 撤稿](https://arxiv.org/abs/2109.12105) · [CVPR 撤稿](https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.04848) · [45 条的逐条处置和入库验收](arxiv-public-decision-screening-followup-2026-11-20.json)