Verify paper versions and recover Bayesian submission history

This commit is contained in:
2026-11-19 03:27:49 +08:00
parent 63e3976d51
commit 2037387efb
2 changed files with 222 additions and 0 deletions
@@ -94,3 +94,9 @@ CVPR 2023–2026 的作者指南明确说明评审及作者回复不公开。ICC
《Edisum》的合作者在 Wikimedia 项目讨论中明确报告 WWW 2024 拒稿,之后贴出同一工作的 arXiv 页面。讨论还确认向 COLM 投稿,最终决定待核。Wikimedia 原始页面直连超时,本批的拒稿证据来自该公开讨论的索引副本。 [Wikimedia 原始讨论](https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T354565) · [arXiv 论文](https://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03428)
《Set Functions for Time Series》已有相符的拒稿记录。另有 3 篇的 8 条声明暂缓,其中《Topological Autoencoders》和《MAGNet》的录用与拒稿分在不同库内 ID 下,《Bayesian Computation Meets Topology》待定位作品。作者披露的拒稿原始 track、投稿 ID 和决定日期均待核。四条 2020 年以前的相关线索保存在项目文档。 [逐条验收与待核记录](coauthor-rejection-histories-2026-11-19.json)
## 2026-11-19 投稿版本核对
《Topological Autoencoders》的 arXiv、ICLR 2020 拒稿及 ICML 2020 录用已核实属于同一作品。《MAGNet》的早期稿和后期 ICLR 录用也已核对,两个版本独立保留原文。两组服务器内只读验收覆盖 9 条来源、4 次投稿、7 条决定和 32 条标签证据。生产库实体合并仍待明确授权。 [作者项目](https://github.com/BorgwardtLab/topological-autoencoders) · [作者公开投稿记录](https://bastian.rieck.me/blog/2025/rejections/) · [ICLR 正式出版](https://iclr.cc/virtual/2025/poster/30958)
《Bayesian Computation Meets Topology》换题后于 2024 年 11 月发表于 TMLR。对照早期 ICLR 论文与正式稿,确认作者、方法和关键验证实验对应。原论文 ID 已补记 TMLR 录用、NeurIPS 2023 和 ICML 2024 的两条作者公开拒稿。正常查询确认四个投稿结果都可找回,包括已有的 ICLR 2024 撤回。作者另提到 ICLR 2024 拒稿,该说法与现有论坛的撤回记录关系不明,暂缓录入。 [TMLR 目录](https://www.jmlr.org/tmlr/papers/) · [早期 ICLR 稿](https://openreview.net/pdf?id=PrkyCAspfx) · [逐条验收](version-links-and-bayesian-history-2026-11-19.json)
@@ -0,0 +1,216 @@
{
"source_snapshots": {
"autoencoder-readme.md": {
"sha256": "2a0ae2c7ce872fedd1a89d1fc458db8b3ea1c8ca923db2498e8ef8267c59242f",
"url": "https://github.com/BorgwardtLab/topological-autoencoders"
},
"rieck.html": {
"sha256": "d08f7c35198a36833dba283b34a106a8d248663cf6d1e60eaae212bb32b6e762",
"url": "https://bastian.rieck.me/blog/2025/rejections/"
},
"magnet-iclr.html": {
"sha256": "a00b383ba725035754dacd80ddb65ebc27760f145873cd5ddcd2121f294dad72",
"url": "https://proceedings.iclr.cc/paper_files/paper/2025/hash/43d1d3bdd92204c96fa4ac3c578f6a33-Abstract-Conference.html"
},
"bayesian-helmholtz.html": {
"sha256": "6f12b7f50322f47a4a89c0bd261472dd06c726bf0c5efebfce9c815e710bcea5",
"url": "https://push-zb.helmholtz-munich.de/frontdoor.php?la=en&source_opus=73646"
}
},
"receipts_sha256": {
"paper-identity-merge-preflight-v1.json": "868c5314067f91b9f0708efab8df01351e9b447a446c435d8857566b81bf2b13",
"bayesian-topology-preflight-v1.json": "258295bd5b46525d97e128a0b60865a2de9fb163304fca5e7c126422d6934825",
"bayesian-topology-plan-v1.json": "e0db1b1ce66a06b5cc41a7d7156d4540c7893ba55691bc3922a4e55c012d3e15",
"bayesian-topology-accepted-v1.json": "e6dd0475516c4bf8d6b464260cdaff1431cd5717d68af638741d0af47acbd322",
"bayesian-topology-query-v1.json": "6f17f030098b1a62dcd653055da69af8c130343aecf13bb76d51ef607d31133b",
"paper-identity-merge-v1.py": "f3c2aeb60c18ce566c73049899b4d06df77e4817fdb63a99d976a1630bb15b3e"
},
"version_groups": {
"status": "verified_readonly_awaiting_explicit_merge_authorization",
"production_entities_merged": 0,
"lookup": {
"1135322": {
"former": [
2113891,
3537122
],
"preflight_sha256": "b39e4479d189966465098a49e20a0ed4fb29df27869833c70523aecd6d93736c",
"sources": 4,
"submissions": 2,
"decisions": 3,
"tags": 19,
"internal_candidates_to_archive": 3,
"external_candidates_after_merge": 0,
"public_history_checks": [
[
"ICLR",
2020,
"rejected"
],
[
"ICML",
2020,
"accepted"
]
]
},
"1854320": {
"former": [
2177209
],
"preflight_sha256": "cc2d1cadd5fe10d31da1dc540907e394281b74d7137e27e8c4551ba0417589ed",
"sources": 5,
"submissions": 2,
"decisions": 4,
"tags": 13,
"internal_candidates_to_archive": 0,
"external_candidates_after_merge": 0,
"public_history_checks": [
[
"ICLR",
2024,
"rejected"
],
[
"ICLR",
2025,
"accepted"
]
]
}
},
"approval": "Automated review rejected the production merge as an impactful entity deletion and association change. A separate complete-row export was rejected. Only bounded read-only counts, digests and relevant public statuses were returned.",
"evidence": {
"1135322": "The author repository links the preprint and PMLR records. The coauthor explicitly reports the ICLR rejection of the same work. Full author sets agree and arXiv/PMLR abstracts match after normalization.",
"1854320": "The ICLR publication and arXiv preprint have identical author sets. The coauthor describes the title variants as work revised and resubmitted before ICLR 2025 acceptance."
}
},
"bayesian": {
"status": "committed_and_independently_queried",
"acceptance": {
"status": "committed_and_readonly_verified",
"plan_sha256": "e0db1b1ce66a06b5cc41a7d7156d4540c7893ba55691bc3922a4e55c012d3e15",
"snapshot_at": "2026-11-18 19:26:30.034277+00",
"records": [
{
"paper_id": 3279406,
"source": "tmlr_publication",
"source_record_id": 3816624,
"external_id": "0h1DtRK6dA",
"submission_id": 533307,
"decision_id": 572858,
"venue": "TMLR",
"year": 2024,
"track": "main",
"status": "accepted"
},
{
"paper_id": 3279406,
"source": "author_public_rejection",
"source_record_id": 3816625,
"external_id": "neurips:2023:tmlr:0h1DtRK6dA",
"submission_id": 533308,
"decision_id": 572859,
"venue": "NeurIPS",
"year": 2023,
"track": "submission_unclassified",
"status": "rejected"
},
{
"paper_id": 3279406,
"source": "author_public_rejection",
"source_record_id": 3816626,
"external_id": "icml:2024:tmlr:0h1DtRK6dA",
"submission_id": 533309,
"decision_id": 572860,
"venue": "ICML",
"year": 2024,
"track": "submission_unclassified",
"status": "rejected"
}
],
"new_papers": 0,
"existing_history_preserved": true
},
"normal_query": {
"paper_id": 3279406,
"publication_outcome": "accepted",
"records": [
{
"paper_id": 3279406,
"source": "tmlr_publication",
"source_record_id": 3816624,
"external_id": "0h1DtRK6dA",
"submission_id": 533307,
"decision_id": 572858,
"venue": "TMLR",
"year": 2024,
"track": "main",
"status": "accepted",
"source_refs": [
{
"name": "tmlr_publication",
"external_id": "0h1DtRK6dA",
"source_decision_id": ""
}
]
},
{
"paper_id": 3279406,
"source": "author_public_rejection",
"source_record_id": 3816625,
"external_id": "neurips:2023:tmlr:0h1DtRK6dA",
"submission_id": 533308,
"decision_id": 572859,
"venue": "NeurIPS",
"year": 2023,
"track": "submission_unclassified",
"status": "rejected",
"source_refs": [
{
"name": "author_public_rejection",
"external_id": "neurips:2023:tmlr:0h1DtRK6dA",
"source_decision_id": ""
}
]
},
{
"paper_id": 3279406,
"source": "author_public_rejection",
"source_record_id": 3816626,
"external_id": "icml:2024:tmlr:0h1DtRK6dA",
"submission_id": 533309,
"decision_id": 572860,
"venue": "ICML",
"year": 2024,
"track": "submission_unclassified",
"status": "rejected",
"source_refs": [
{
"name": "author_public_rejection",
"external_id": "icml:2024:tmlr:0h1DtRK6dA",
"source_decision_id": ""
}
]
}
],
"known_acceptances": [
{
"submission_id": 533307,
"venue": "TMLR",
"year": 2024,
"track": "main",
"event_key": "",
"decision_id": 572858,
"decision_date": null,
"observed_at": "2026-11-18T19:26:11.875Z",
"evidence_url": "https://openreview.net/forum?id=0h1DtRK6dA"
}
]
},
"original_ICLR_2024_withdrawal_retained": true,
"author_ICLR_2024_rejection_claim": "Held; relationship to the withdrawn forum PrkyCAspfx is unverified.",
"publication_index": "https://www.jmlr.org/tmlr/papers/",
"submission_pdf": "https://openreview.net/pdf?id=PrkyCAspfx"
}
}